Arkansas Tech University The Culture Wars & Political Polarization in Perspective



Download 4.38 Mb.
Page18/42
Date18.10.2016
Size4.38 Mb.
#2677
1   ...   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   ...   42

Table 10.4: Class – Unweighted Percent Contribution & Mean Deviation on GP on Party ID, 1970-2004

YEAR

POOR

P-DEV

WC

WC-DEV

LMC

LMC-DEV

UMC

UMC-DEV

RICH

R-DEV

1970

25.83%

10.20%

34.26%

7.41%

14.54%

-3.48%

10.94%

-0.75%

14.45%

-13.37%

1972

18.03%

2.40%

18.22%

-8.63%

10.02%

-8.00%

10.00%

-1.69%

43.78%

15.96%

1974

23.78%

8.15%

11.76%

-15.10%

33.69%

15.67%

10.52%

-1.17%

20.25%

-7.56%

1976

19.24%

3.61%

26.34%

-0.51%

19.03%

1.02%

10.00%

-1.69%

25.36%

-2.46%

1978

18.04%

2.41%

24.06%

-2.79%

24.00%

5.99%

11.20%

-0.49%

22.68%

-5.14%

1980

10.80%

-4.83%

29.08%

2.23%

12.35%

-5.66%

13.49%

1.80%

34.28%

6.46%

1982

19.96%

4.33%

33.97%

7.12%

12.22%

-5.79%

10.21%

-1.48%

23.63%

-4.19%

1984

14.12%

-1.50%

33.27%

6.41%

15.51%

-2.50%

11.39%

-0.30%

25.69%

-2.12%

1986

10.62%

-5.00%

29.85%

2.99%

10.55%

-7.47%

10.41%

-1.28%

38.56%

10.75%

1988

11.72%

-3.90%

25.85%

-1.00%

11.28%

-6.73%

10.86%

-0.83%

40.27%

12.46%

1990

12.62%

-3.01%

26.25%

-0.60%

22.67%

4.66%

15.87%

4.18%

22.60%

-5.21%

1992

11.07%

-4.55%

25.07%

-1.79%

18.10%

0.08%

10.43%

-1.26%

35.32%

7.51%

1994

11.54%

-4.08%

23.48%

-3.38%

15.20%

-2.82%

14.82%

3.13%

34.96%

7.15%

1996

10.95%

-4.67%

24.14%

-2.71%

17.40%

-0.62%

10.07%

-1.62%

37.43%

9.62%

1998

11.83%

-3.79%

12.38%

-14.48%

38.06%

20.04%

12.50%

0.81%

25.24%

-2.57%

2000

14.51%

-1.11%

43.41%

16.55%

10.93%

-7.09%

13.32%

1.63%

17.83%

-9.99%

2002

16.73%

1.10%

36.14%

9.28%

15.87%

-2.14%

12.66%

0.97%

18.61%

-9.20%

2004

19.86%

4.24%

25.86%

-0.99%

22.85%

4.84%

11.72%

0.03%

19.72%

-8.10%

trend line for the poor to unweighted group polarization. It decline sharply from 1970 to 1980, and then stabilizes until a slight spike upward during the George W. Bush administration (Figure 10.5). But note this uptick doesn’t even reach the 1970’s level of percent contribution to group polarization for the poor. The two biggest categorical contributors in the unweighted scores are the working class on the one hand and the rich on the other. The peak for the rich was in 1988 (40.27%) while the peak for the poor was in 1970 (25.83%). It does appear that the rich contributed more in the 1990’s (local max = 40.27%) than they have in the 2000’s (local max = 19.72%). However, there is little by way of an overall trend in contribution to group polarization on partisanship since 1970 by the rich.

In Table 10.5 I report a multiple regression of the weighted and unweighted group polarization measure using survey year (time trend) and the party of the presidential administration as independent variables. As in previous analyses, the logic of including a presidential variable is to test whether the public polarizes in reaction to the party of the president, given their generally distinct policy positions and the consequence of having a president who shares or does not share your own partisanship in office.

Figure 10.5: Unweighted Mean Deviation Trends in Average Party Identification for Rich and Poor Citizens



Table 10.5: Weighted & Unweighted Mean Dev. Trend Regressions of Class GP on Party ID, 1970-2004

Model:

GPMD(pd) = B0 + B1(year) + e

Intercept

(R.S.E.)


YEAR

P.E.


(R.S.E.)




PPA

P.E.


(R.S.E.)




R2

N

WEIGHTED

GROUP POLARIZATION
























Poor

444.693

(144.655)




-0.225

(0.075)


***

2.921

(1.092)


**

.495

18

Working

-725.653

(481.588)




0.363

(0.242)





7.365

(4.858)





.227


18


Lower Middle

194.606

(498.873)




-0.095

(0.251)






-9.416

(4.570)



**

.163

18

Upper Middle


101.041

(149.955)




-0.051

(0.076)





0.232

(1.856)





.021


18


Rich


-14.732

(167.929)




0.008

(0.084)





-1.102

(1.032)





.031


18


UNWEIGHTED

GROUP POLARIZATION
























Poor

412.372

(199.017)




-0.208

(0.100)


**

2.145

(1.553)





.296

18

Working

-373.008

(340.290)




0.185

(0.189)





6.971

(3.060)


**

.216


18


Lower Middle

-83.511

(325.096)




0.044

(0.164)






-5.792

(3.397)



*

.138

18

Upper Middle


-140.782

(43.607)



0.071

(0.022)


***

0.488

(0.762)





.191


18


Rich


221.312

(42.509)



-0.092

(0.210)





-3.639

(3.640)





.049


18


Download 4.38 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   ...   42




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page