FSB May Slap Spy Charges On Tobin
Author: By Ana Uzelac Staff Writer
John Tobin, the American Fulbright scholar convicted of using marijuana, could face espionage> charges based on testimony by a new witness who accuses Tobin of trying to recruit him to be a U.S. spy, the Federal Security Service said Tuesday.
A former U.S. colleague of the witness, Dmitry Kuznetsov, painted him Tuesday as a liar and a thief.
Pavel Bolshunov, spokesman for the FSB branch in Voronezh, said Tuesday that the FSB was undecided about bringing <espionage> charges against Tobin, 24, but was reviewing allegations by Kuznetsov that he was questioned by Tobin three years ago while awaiting trial on embezzlement charges in Bridgeport, Connecticut.
In interviews published Tuesday by Interfax and the Moskovsky Komsomolets newspaper, Kuznetsov said Tobin offered him favors in exchange for cooperation with the FBI. He also told MK that Tobin interrogated him at length about his friendships with several American professors.
Kuznetsov said that he was in prison on charges of embezzling grant funds from a Connecticut university.
He could not be reached for comment Tuesday.
Bridgeport Correction Center spokesman Brian Garnett said by telephone Tuesday that the prison had no record of ever holding a suspect named Dmitry Kuznetsov.
However, Sidney Weinstein and Ted Sarafian, whom Kuznetsov named in his interview with MK, recalled knowing the Russian, and Weinstein called him a crook.
Weinstein said he knew of several instances in which Kuznetsov was involved in unethical scientific research, including cases when he published articles based on fictitious data and quoted fictional scientific journals.
"[He] fell from being a promising scientist to becoming a competent crook," Weinstein said by telephone from Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
He said Kuznetsov stayed at his home for a while in the late 1980s and left suddenly without returning $36,000 that he had loaned the Russian.
"I would have strong doubts about anything that Kuznetsov has to say on any subject," Weinstein said. "The man is a liar and a sociopath."
Sarafian, a scientist and professor at the University of California at Los Angeles, said he knew Kuznetsov as a scientist interested in toxicology who had attained "adequate" results in his research.
"I remember he approached me in the mid-'80s with the results of his research in mercury toxicity which were strikingly similar to mine," Sarafian said by telephone from Los Angeles. "Actually, the introduction to his work had some sentences which were identical to ones I wrote a bit earlier in one of my papers, but I hadn't given it much though at the time."
The Voronezh FSB spokesman said there were no immediate plans to file <espionage> charges against Tobin because interrogating or trying to recruit a prisoner in the United States is not a Russian offense. "But it does confirm that the FSB was on the right track in suspecting Tobin of working for the U.S. intelligence," he said. "We have not stained his reputation by accusing him of being a spy in training."
Tobin has repeatedly denied accusations that he has ties to U.S. intelligence. He was detained in Voronezh in late January while studying at a university and charged a few days later with possession and use of marijuana.
At the time, the FSB also accused him of being a spy in training, pointing to his studies at a U.S. military school and the elite Defense Language Institute in Monterrey, California.
However, no <espionage> charges were brought against Tobin.
A Voronezh court found him guilty on the marijuana charges in April and sentenced him to 36 months in prison. The sentence was later cut on appeal to one year.
Tobin's resume, however, confirms another FSB allegation that he is a trained interrogator, said Jim Maloney, a U.S. congressman from Tobin's home state of Connecticut who traveled to <Russia> with Tobin's father several weeks ago to appeal the verdict on marijuana charges.
"John Tobin was a U.S. military reservist, and Russian authorities knew that from the start," Maloney said by telephone from Washington. "Whatever he did as a member of the U.S. military on American territory is irrelevant to his stay in <Russia and his case."
John Tobin, in an e-mail to his colleagues from the Fulbright scholarship program, said the marijuana charges were a frame-up by the Voronezh FSB because he refused an offer from the Russian authorities to work for them in an unspecified role.
Kuznetsov told the Russian press that Tobin identified himself under a false name and offered to improve his prison conditions in return for his cooperation.
Kuznetsov said he agreed to review scientific material on toxicology for $100 per article but refused to cooperate further. He said he was released six months later after paying a $2,500 fine and promising to deliver 150 hours of free lectures to various U.S. universities.
Kuznetsov said he recognized Tobin on television and later traveled to Voronezh to confirm that the U.S. student was the same person who had interrogated him.
"Although he pretended that he was seeing me for the first time, I immediately recognized that he was the FBI agent who tried to force me to cooperate in prison," Kuznetsov said. "He has a special, characteristic smile."
Maloney, the U.S. congressman, said he was "very disappointed in the FSB statements" and that they were "inflammatory and counter-productive."
Tobin's lawyer Maxim Bayev dismissed the accusations as irrelevant and suggested that they were an attempt to prevent a weak case against his client from falling apart at a second appeal hearing expected within two weeks.
"The question of whether the charges against Tobin were legal and whether his sentence was well-founded is coming up for debate again, and somebody obviously would hate to see the case fall to pieces," he said on Ekho Moskvy radio.
Tobin was transferred over the weekend to the Rossosh prison in the Voronezh region to serve out the remaining seven months of his sentence. There, the FSB spokesman said, Tobin is "learning to become a carpenter."
|