Chicago Debate League 2013/14 Core Files
NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [4/4] 429
Download 3.16 Mb.
|
- Navigate this page:
- 2NC Extension: A/t 4 “Other Words Check” 430
- 2NC Extension: A/t 5 “No Extra Topicality” 431
- Topicality Affirmative 432
2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [4/4] 4295) Specifically in the context of debating immigration, requiring the Affirmative to defend government action that they may not strictly believe in creates room for clash that enables new ideas to form. Debate is only educational if the resolution forces us to disagree with each other. STEINBERG AND FREELY, 8 [David, Lecturer in Communication at University of Miami; Austin, Civil Rights Attorney; Argumentation and Debate: Critical Thinking for Reasoned Decision Making; p45] Debate is a means of settling differences, so there must be a difference of opinion or a conflict of interest before there can be a debate. If everyone is in agreement on a tact or value or policy, there is no need for debate: the matter can be settled by unanimous consent. Thus, for example, it would be pointless to attempt to debate "Resolved: That two plus two equals four," because there is simply no controversy about this statement. (Controversy is an essential prerequisite of debate. Where there is no clash of ideas, proposals, interests, or expressed positions on issues, there is no debate. In addition, debate cannot produce effective decisions without clear identification of a question or questions to be answered. For example, general argument may occur about the broad topic of illegal immigration. How many illegal immigrants are in the United States? What is the impact of illegal immigration and immigrants on our economy? What is their impact on our communities? Do they commit crimes? Do they take jobs from American workers? Do they pay taxes? Do they require social services? Is it a problem that some do not speak English? Is it the responsibility of employers to discourage illegal immigration by not hiring undocumented workers? Should they have the opportunity to gain citizenship? Does illegal immigration pose a security threat to our country? Do illegal immigrants do work that American workers are unwilling to do? Are their rights as workers and as human beings at risk due to their status? Are they abused by employers, law enforcement, housing, and businesses? How are their families impacted by their status? What is the moral and philosophical obligation of a nation state to maintain its borders? Should we build a wall on the Mexican border, establish a national identification card, or enforce existing laws against employers? Should we invite immigrants to become U.S. citizens? Surely you can think of many more concerns to be addressed by a conversation about the topic area of illegal immigration. Participation in this "debate" is likely to be emotional and intense. However, it is not likely to be productive or useful without focus on a particular question and identification of a line demarcating sides in the controversy. To be discussed and resolved effectively, controversies must be stated clearly. Vague understanding results in unfocused deliberation and poor decisions, frustration, and emotional distress, as evidenced by the failure of the United States Congress to make progress on the immigration debate during the summer of 2007. 2NC Extension: A/t #4 “Other Words Check” 4301) Topicality is an all-or-nothing proposition. You don’t get to meet 90% of the words in the resolution and win, because any advantages you claim off the other words are unfair and uneducational. If we win that they violate Resolved, you should vote Negative. 2) There is no objective way to measure whether a team is topical enough, only whether they are within or outside of the bounds of the topic formed by each word of the resolution. 3) Their interpretation is much larger than they are letting on. Multiply every possible form of economic assistance to all 3 countries by every different identity group that could be affected by each plan by every debater who will have a different story to tell, and that’s the number of different Harms we would have to prepare for. There is no evidence on any of those speeches, which means we have to rely on bad generic arguments. 2NC Extension: A/t #5 “No Extra Topicality” 4311) Extra Topicality is a voting issue. The Affirmative gets to claim unpredictable advantages that are not tied to the resolution and that we will never have evidence to argue against. This puts them a step ahead of all our generic arguments, and we will never be able to win impact calculus. 2) There is a difference between a policy-based advantage and a representations advantage. The plan text is a necessary step in stopping the nuclear war from happening, but the demand made by their Affirmative is not a necessary step for solving their narratives arguments. If you removed the plan from their 1AC, they would still tell you to vote Affirmative based on the discourse they used. That proves they are Extra Topical. Topicality Affirmative 432Mexico Security Affirmative 4 1 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 5 1 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 6 2 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 7 3 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 8 4 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 9 5 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 10 6 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 11 7 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 12 8 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 13 9 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 14 10 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 15 11 1AC: Mexico Security Affirmative 16 12 2AC Inherency 17 1 2AC Harms: A/t - #1 “Cooperation Now” [1/2] 18 1 2AC Harms: A/t - #1 “Cooperation Now” [2/2] 19 3 2AC Harms: A/t - #2 “No Nuclear Terrorism” [1/3] 20 4 2AC Harms: A/t - #2 “No Nuclear Terrorism” [2/3] 21 6 2AC Harms: A/t - #2 “No Nuclear Terrorism” [3/3] 22 7 2AC Harms: A/t - #3 “Violence is Decreasing” [1/3] 23 8 2AC Harms: A/t - #3 “Violence is Decreasing” [2/3] 24 9 2AC Harms: A/t - #3 “Violence is Decreasing” [3/3] 25 10 2AC Harms: A/t - #4 “Drugs are Decreasing” [1/2] 26 11 2AC Harms: A/t - #4 “Drugs are Decreasing” [2/2] 27 12 2AC Solvency: A/t - #1 “Immigration From Everywhere” 28 1 2AC Solvency: A/t - #2 “Mexico Won’t Reform” [1/2] 29 2 2AC Solvency: A/t - #2 “Mexico Won’t Reform” [2/2] 30 3 2AC Solvency: A/t - #3 “Economy is Biggest Factor” 31 4 2AC Solvency: A/t - #4 “Geography Prevents Cooperation” 32 5 Mexico Security Negative 33 1 1NC Frontline: Inherency 34 1 1NC Frontline: Harms [1/3] 35 1 1NC Frontline: Harms [2/3] 36 2 1NC Frontline: Harms [3/3] 37 3 2NC Extension Harms - #1 “Cooperation Now” [1/2] 38 1 2NC Extension Harms - #1 “Cooperation Now” [2/2] 39 2 2NC Extension Harms - #2 “No Nuclear Terror” 40 3 2NC Extension Harms - #3 “Violence is Decreasing” 41 4 2NC Extension Harms - #4 “Drugs Are Decreasing” 42 5 1NC Frontline: Solvency [1/3] 43 1 1NC Frontline: Solvency [2/3] 44 2 1NC Frontline: Solvency [3/3] 45 3 2NC Extension Solvency - #1 “Immigration from Everywhere” 46 4 2NC Extension Solvency - #2 “Mexico Won’t Reform” 47 5 2NC Extension Solvency - #3 “Economy is Biggest Factor” 48 6 2NC Extension Solvency - #4 “Geography prevents cooperation” 49 7 Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 50 1 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 51 1 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 52 2 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 53 3 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 54 4 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 55 5 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 56 6 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 57 7 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 58 8 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 59 9 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 60 10 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 61 11 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 62 12 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 63 13 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 64 14 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 65 15 1AC: Venezuela Democracy Affirmative 66 17 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #1 “Advantage Contradicts” [1/2] 67 1 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #1 “Advantage Contradicts” [2/2] 68 2 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #2 “No More Ties to Iran” [1/2] 69 3 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #2 “No More Ties to Iran” [2/2] 70 4 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #3 “Iran is Peaceful” [1/2] 71 5 2AC Harms – Iran: A/t - #3 “Iran is Peaceful” [2/2] 72 6 2AC Harms – Democracy: A/t - #1 “Elections are Fair” [1/2] 73 1 2AC Harms – Democracy: A/t - #1 “Elections are Fair” [2/2] 74 2 2AC Harms – Democracy: A/t - #2 “Democracy Turn” [1/2] 75 4 2AC Harms – Democracy: A/t - #2 “Democracy Turn” [2/2] 76 5 2AC Harms – Democracy: A/t - #3 “Empirically Denied” 77 6 2AC Solvency: A/t - #1 “Anti-Democracy Backlash” [1/3] 78 1 2AC Solvency: A/t - #1 “Anti-Democracy Backlash” [2/3] 79 2 2AC Solvency: A/t - #1 “Anti-Democracy Backlash” [3/3] 80 3 2AC Solvency: A/t - #2 “Conditioning fails” [1/2] 81 4 2AC Solvency: A/t - #2 “Conditioning fails” [2/2] 82 5 2AC Solvency: A/t - #3 “Democracy Promotion Fails” [1/3] 83 6 2AC Solvency: A/t - #3 “Democracy Promotion Fails” [2/3] 84 7 2AC Solvency: A/t - #3 “Democracy Promotion Fails” [3/3] 85 8 2AC Solvency: A/t - #4 “Elections Aren’t Enough” 86 9 Venezuela Democracy Negative 87 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Iran 88 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Iran 89 2 2NC Extension Harms: #1 “Harm scenarios contradict” 90 1 2NC Extension Harms: #2 “No More Ties to Iran” 91 2 2NC Extension Harms: #3 “Iran is Peaceful” [1/2] 92 3 2NC Extension Harms: #3 “Iran is Peaceful” [2/2] 93 4 1NC Frontline: Harms – Democracy 94 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Democracy 95 2 2NC Extension Harms - #1 “Elections are Fair” 96 1 2NC Extension Harms - #2 “Democracy turn” [1/2] 97 2 2NC Extension Harms - #2 “Democracy turn” [2/2] 98 3 2NC Extension Harms - #3 “Empirically Denied” 99 4 1NC Frontline: Solvency 100 1 1NC Frontline: Solvency 101 2 2NC Extension Solvency - #1 “Anti-Democracy Backlash” 102 1 2NC Extension Solvency - #2 “Conditioning Fails” 103 2 2NC Extension Solvency - #3 “Democracy promotion fails” 104 3 2NC Extension Solvency - #4 “Elections aren’t enough” [1/2] 105 4 2NC Extension Solvency - #4 “Elections aren’t enough” [2/2] 106 5 Cuba Ethanol Affirmative 107 1 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 108 1 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 109 3 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 110 4 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 111 5 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 112 6 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 113 7 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 114 8 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 115 9 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 116 10 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 117 11 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 118 12 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 119 13 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 120 14 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 121 15 1AC: Cuban Ethanol Affirmative 122 16 2AC Extension Harms – Environment: A/t #1 “Species Are Resilient” 123 1 2AC Extension Harms – Environment: A/t #2 “Corn is Clean” 124 2 2AC Extension Harms – Environment: A/t #3 “No Trade-off” [1/2] 125 3 2AC Extension Harms – Environment: A/t #3 “No Trade-off” [2/2] 126 4 2AC Extension Harms – Environment: A/t #4 “Developing Countries are Key” 127 5 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t # 1 “Midwest Economies Turn” [1/3] 128 1 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t # 1 “Midwest Economies Turn” [2/3] 129 2 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t # 1 “Midwest Economies Turn” [3/3] 130 3 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #2 “Ethanol Isn’t Enough” [1/4] 131 5 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #2 “Ethanol Isn’t Enough” [2/4] 132 6 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #2 “Ethanol Isn’t Enough” [3/4] 133 7 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #2 “Ethanol Isn’t Enough” [4/4] 134 8 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #3 “No Market” [1/2] 135 9 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #3 “No Market” [2/2] 136 10 2AC Extension Harms – Economy: A/t #4 “Economy is Resilient” 137 11 2AC Extension Solvency – A/t #1 “No Political Will” 138 1 2AC Extension Solvency – A/t #2 “Bad Business Climate” [1/2] 139 3 2AC Extension Solvency – A/t #2 “Bad Business Climate” [2/2] 140 4 2AC Extension Solvency – A/t #3 “Brazil Solves Investment” 141 5 Cuba Ethanol Negative 142 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Environment 143 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Environment 144 3 1NC Frontline: Harms – Environment 145 4 2NC Extension Harms – Environment #1 “Species are Resilient” 146 1 2NC Extension Harms – Environment #2 “Corn is Clean” 147 2 2NC Extension Harms – Environment #3 “No Crop Trade-off” 148 3 2NC Extension Harms – Environment #4 “Developing Countries are Key” 149 4 1NC Frontline: Harms – Economy 150 1 1NC Frontline: Harms – Economy 151 2 1NC Frontline: Harms – Economy 152 3 2NC Extension Harms – Economy #1 “Midwest Economies Turn” 153 1 2NC Extension Harms – Economy #2 “Ethanol Isn’t Enough” 154 2 2NC Extension Harms – Economy #3 “No Market” 155 3 2NC Extension Harms – Economy #4 “Economy is Resilient” 156 4 1NC Frontline – Solvency 157 1 1NC Frontline – Solvency 158 2 2NC Extension Solvency - #1 “No Political Will” 159 1 2NC Extension Solvency - #2 “Bad Business Climate” 160 2 2NC Extension Solvency - #3 “Brazil Solves Investment” 161 3 Critical Immigration Affirmative 162 1 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 163 1 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 164 2 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 165 3 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 166 4 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 167 6 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 168 7 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 169 8 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 170 9 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 171 10 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 172 11 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 173 12 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 174 13 1AC: Critical Immigration Affirmative 175 15 2AC Harms: A/t - #1 “Law Does Not Matter” 176 1 2AC Harms: A/t - #2 “Federal Government Isn’t Key” [1/2] 177 2 2AC Harms: A/t - #2 “Federal Government Isn’t Key” [2/2] 178 3 2AC Harms: A/t - #3 “Other Immigrants Face Discrimination” 179 4 2AC Harms: A/t - #4 “Representations Don’t Shape Policy” [1/3] 180 5 2AC Harms: A/t - #4 “Representations Don’t Shape Policy” [2/3] 181 6 2AC Harms: A/t - #4 “Representations Don’t Shape Policy” [3/3] 182 7 2AC Harms: A/t - #5 “Race isn’t Most Important Issue” [1/2] 183 8 2AC Harms: A/t - #5 “Race isn’t Most Important Issue” [2/2] 184 9 2AC Harms: A/t - #6 “Movement Succeeding Now” [1/2] 185 10 2AC Harms: A/t - #6 “Movement Succeeding Now” [2/2] 186 11 2AC Solvency: A/t #1 “Alternate Causality” 187 1 2AC Solvency: A/t #2 “Law Fails to Protect Minorities” 188 2 2AC Solvency: A/t #3 “Narratives Fail” 189 3 2AC Solvency: A/t #4 “Exploitation Turn” [1/4] 190 4 2AC Solvency: A/t #4 “Exploitation Turn” [2/4] 191 5 2AC Solvency: A/t #4 “Exploitation Turn” [3/4] 192 6 2AC Solvency: A/t #4 “Exploitation Turn” [4/4] 193 7 A/t: “We aren’t Immigrants” 194 8 2AC Framework: Disadvantages [1/3] 195 1 2AC Framework: Disadvantages [2/3] 196 2 2AC Framework: Disadvantages [3/3] 197 3 Critical Immigration Negative 198 1 1NC Frontline: Harms 199 1 1NC Frontline: Harms 200 2 1NC Frontline: Harms 201 3 1NC Frontline: Harms 202 4 1NC Frontline: Harms 203 6 2NC Extensions: Harms #1 “Law Does Not Matter” 204 1 2NC Extensions: Harms #2 “Federal Government Isn’t Key” 205 2 2NC Extensions: Harms #3 “Other Immigrants Face Discrimination” 206 3 2NC Extensions: Harms #4 “Representations Don’t Shape Policy” 207 4 2NC Extensions: Harms #5 “Race isn’t Most Important Issue” 208 5 1NC Frontline: Solvency 209 1 1NC Frontline: Solvency 210 2 1NC Frontline: Solvency 211 3 2NC Extension Solvency: #1 “Alternate Causality” 212 1 2NC Extension Solvency: #2 “Law Fails To Protect Minorities” 213 2 2NC Extension Solvency: #3 “Narratives Fail” 214 3 2NC Extension Solvency: #4 “Exploitation Turn” 215 4 2NC Frontline: Disadvantage Framework 216 1 2NC Frontline: Disadvantage Framework 217 3 2NC Frontline: Disadvantage Framework 218 4 2NC Frontline: Disadvantage Framework 219 5 Corruption Disadvantage Negative 220 1 1NC Shell: Corruption Disadvantage 221 1 1NC Shell: Corruption Disadvantage 222 2 1NC Shell: Corruption Disadvantage 223 3 2NC Extensions: A/t – #1 “No Link” [1/2] 224 1 2NC Extensions: A/t – #1 “No Link” [2/2] 225 2 2NC Extensions: A/t – #2 “Many Causes of Corruption” 226 3 2NC Extensions: A/t – #3 “Case Outweighs” 227 4 2NC Extensions: A/t – #4 “Corruption is High” 228 5 2NC Extensions: A/t – #5 “Aid Solves Corruption” [1/2] 229 6 2NC Extensions: A/t – #5 “Aid Solves Corruption” [2/2] 230 7 2NC Extensions: A/t – #6 “Evidence Isn’t Causal” 231 8 2NC Extensions: A/t – #6 “Evidence Isn’t Causal” 232 9 2NC Extensions: A/t – #7 “Businesses Cause Corruption” [1/2] 233 10 2NC Extensions: A/t – #7 “Businesses Cause Corruption” [2/2] 234 11 2NC Extensions: A/t – #8 “Plan Solves Corruption” [1/3] 235 12 2NC Extensions: A/t – #8 “Plan Solves Corruption” [2/3] 236 13 2NC Extensions: A/t – #8 “Plan Solves Corruption” [3/3] 237 14 Country-specific Uniqueness: Mexico [1/2] 238 15 Country-specific Uniqueness: Mexico [2/2] 239 16 Country-specific Uniqueness: Venezuela 240 17 Country-specific Uniqueness: Cuba 241 18 A/t: “The Plan doesn’t give money” 242 19 Corruption Disadvantage Affirmative 243 1 2AC Frontline: Corruption Disadvantage 244 1 2AC Frontline: Corruption Disadvantage 245 2 2AC Frontline: Corruption Disadvantage 246 3 Country-specific Non-Unique: Mexico 247 1 Country-specific Non-Unique: Venezuela [1/2] 248 2 Country-specific Non-Unique: Cuba 249 3 Country-specific Turn: Mexico 250 4 Country-specific Turn: Venezuela 251 5 Country-specific Turn: Cuba [1/2] 252 6 Country-specific Turn: Cuba [2/2] 253 7 Country-specific Turn: Critical Immigration 254 8 Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage Negative 255 1 1NC Shell: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 256 1 1NC Shell: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 257 2 2NC Extensions: A/t – #1 “Empirically Denied” [1/2] 258 1 2NC Extensions: A/t – #1 “Empirically Denied” [2/2] 259 2 2NC Extensions: A/t – #2 “Obama Isn’t Focused” 260 3 2NC Extensions: A/t – #3 “Case Outweighs” 261 4 2NC Extensions: A/t – #4 “Winners Win” [1/2] 262 5 2NC Extensions: A/t – #4 “Winners Win” [2/2] 263 6 2NC Extensions: A/t – #5 “Peace Talks Will Fail” [1/3] 264 7 2NC Extensions: A/t – #5 “Peace Talks Will Fail” [2/3] 265 8 2NC Extensions: A/t – #5 “Peace Talks Will Fail” [3/3] 266 9 2NC Extensions: A/t – #6 “Foreign Aid is Declining” 267 10 2NC Extensions: A/t – #7 “No Trade-off” 268 11 2NC Extensions: A/t – #8 “Plan Clears Small Issues” 269 12 2NC Extensions: A/t – #9 “Talks Will Fail” 270 13 Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage Affirmative 271 1 2AC Frontline: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 272 1 2AC Frontline: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 273 2 2AC Frontline: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 274 3 2AC Frontline: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 275 4 2AC Frontline: Diplomatic Capital Disadvantage 276 5 Politics Disadvantage Negative 277 1 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 278 1 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 279 2 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 280 3 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 281 4 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 282 5 1NC Shell: Politics Disadvantage 283 6 2NC Extensions: A/t - #1 “Obama Won’t Push” [1/2] 284 1 2NC Extensions: A/t - #1 “Obama Won’t Push” [2/2] 285 2 2NC Extensions: A/t - #2 “Congress Isn’t Involved” 286 3 2NC Extensions: A/t - #3 “Regulations Won’t Solve” [1/2] 287 5 2NC Extensions: A/t - #3 “Regulations Won’t Solve” [2/2] 288 6 2NC Extensions: A/t - #4 “Republicans Will Win” [1/2] 289 7 2NC Extensions: A/t - #4 “Republicans Will Win” [2/2] 290 9 2NC Extensions: A/t - #5 “Link Turn” 291 10 2NC Extensions: A/t - #6 “Political Capital is a Myth” [1/2] 292 11 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Rules Do Not Go Far Enough” [1/2] 293 12 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Rules Do Not Go Far Enough” [2/2] 294 13 2NC Extensions: A/t - #8 “Winners Win” 295 14 2NC Extensions: A/t - #9 “Obama Won’t Push” 296 15 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/T - #1 “Politics is privileged” [1/2] 297 16 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/T - #1 “Politics is privileged” [2/2] 298 18 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/T #2 “Latina/o Activism” 299 19 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #3 “Obama Won’t Push” [1/2] 300 20 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #3 “Obama Won’t Push” [1/2] 301 21 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #4 “Congress isn’t involved” 302 22 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #5 “Regulations won’t solve” 303 24 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #5 “Regulations won’t solve” 304 25 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #6 “Political Capital is a myth” [1/2] 305 26 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #6 “Political Capital is a myth” [2/2] 306 27 Plan-specific Link: Mexico 307 28 Plan-specific Link: Venezuelan Democracy 308 29 Plan-specific Link: Cuban Ethanol [1/3] 309 30 Plan-specific Link: Cuban Ethanol [2/3] 310 31 Plan-specific Link: Cuban Ethanol [3/3] 311 32 Plan-specific Link: Critical Immigration [1/2] 312 33 Plan-specific Link: Critical Immigration [2/2] 313 34 Politics Disadvantage Affirmative 314 1 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [1/6] 315 1 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [2/6] 316 2 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [3/6] 317 3 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [4/6] 318 4 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [5/6] 319 5 2AC Frontline: Politics Disadvantage [6/6] 320 6 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [1/6] 321 7 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [2/6] 322 8 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [3/6] 323 9 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [4/6] 324 10 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [5/6] 325 11 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Politics Disadvantage [6/6] 326 12 Link Turn: Latin America [1/2] 327 1 Link-Turn: Latin America [2/2] 328 2 Plan-specific Link Turn: Cuban Ethanol [1/2] 329 3 Plan-specific Link Turn: Cuban Ethanol [2/2] 330 4 Plan-specific Link Turn: Critical Immigration 331 5 China Disadvantage Negative 332 1 1NC Shell: China Disadvantage 333 1 1NC Shell: China Disadvantage 334 3 1NC Shell: China Disadvantage 335 4 1NC Shell: China Disadvantage 336 6 2NC Extensions: A/t - #1 “Latin America Isn’t Key” 337 1 2NC Extensions: A/t - #2“U.S. Outspends China” 338 2 2NC Extensions: A/t - #3 “No Link” [1/2] 339 3 2NC Extensions: A/t - #3 “No Link” [2/2] 340 4 2NC Extensions: A/t - #4 “Hegemony Turn” [1/3] 341 5 2NC Extensions: A/t - #4 “Hegemony Turn” [2/3] 342 6 2NC Extensions: A/t - #4 “Hegemony Turn” [3/3] 343 7 2NC Extensions: A/t - #5 “No Escalation” 344 8 2NC Extensions: A/t - #6 “Chinese Investment is Unsustainable” 345 9 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Chinese Aggression Turn” [1/4] 346 11 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Chinese Aggression Turn” [2/4] 347 12 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Chinese Aggression Turn” [3/4] 348 13 2NC Extensions: A/t - #7 “Chinese Aggression Turn” [4/4] 349 14 2NC Extensions: A/t - #8 “Corruption Turn” 350 15 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #1 “Self-fulfilling prophecy” [2/2] 351 16 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #2 “Colonialism” [2/2] 352 18 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #2 “Colonialism” [2/2] 353 19 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #3 “U.S. Outspends China” 354 20 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #4 “No Link” [1/2] 355 21 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #4 “No Link” [2/2] 356 22 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #5 “No Escalation” 357 23 2NC Extensions [Critical Immigration]: A/t - #6 “Chinese Investment is Unsustainable” 358 24 Plan-specific Link: Mexico 359 26 Plan-specific Link: Cuba 360 27 China Disadvantage Affirmative 361 1 2AC Frontline: China Disadvantage [1/5] 362 1 2AC Frontline: China Disadvantage [2/5] 363 2 2AC Frontline: China Disadvantage [3/5] 364 4 2AC Frontline: China Disadvantage [4/5] 365 5 2AC Frontline: China Disadvantage [5/5] 366 6 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: China Disadvantage [1/5] 367 7 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: China Disadvantage [2/5] 368 8 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: China Disadvantage [3/5] 369 9 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: China Disadvantage [4/5] 370 10 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: China Disadvantage [5/5] 371 11 European Union Counterplan Negative 372 1 1NC Shell: European Union Counterplan 373 1 Plan-specific Texts 374 3 2NC Extensions: A/t #1 “Permutation” 375 1 2NC Extensions: A/t #2 “Solvency Deficit” 376 2 Plan-specific Solvency: Mexico Security [1/2] 377 3 Plan-specific Solvency: Mexico Security [2/2] 378 4 Plan-specific Solvency: Venezuela Democracy 379 5 Plan-specific Solvency: Cuba Ethanol [1/2] 380 6 Plan-specific Solvency: Cuba Ethanol [2/2] 381 7 Plan-specific Solvency: Critical Immigration 382 8 2NC Extensions: A/t #3 “International Actor Fiat” 383 9 2NC Extensions: A/t #4 “economic Crisis Prevents Solvency” 384 10 2NC Extensions: A/t #5 “No Timeframe for Solvency” 385 11 2NC Extensions: A/t #6 “European Leadership Turn” 386 12 European Union Counterplan Affirmative 387 1 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 388 1 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 389 2 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 390 3 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 391 4 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 392 5 2AC Frontline: European Union Counterplan 393 6 Plan-specific Solvency Deficit: Mexican Security 394 7 Plan-Specific Solvency Deficit: Venezuelan Democracy 395 8 Plan-Specific Solvency Deficit: Cuban Ethanol 396 9 Plan-Specific Solvency Deficit: Critical Immigration 397 10 Topicality 398 1 1NC Shell: Topicality – Mexico 399 1 2NC Extension: A/t - #1 “We Meet” 400 3 2NC Extension: A/t - #2 “Counter-Interpretation” 401 4 2NC Extension: A/t - #3 “Counter Standards” 402 5 2NC Extension: A/t - #4 “No Abuse – U.S.A.I.D.” 403 6 2NC Extension: A/t - #5 “Mixing Burdens” 404 7 2NC Extension: A/t - #6 “Reasonability” 405 8 1NC Shell: Topicality – Venezuela 406 1 2NC Extension: A/t - #1 “We Meet” 407 1 2NC Extension: A/t - #2 “Counter-Interpretation” 408 2 2NC Extension: A/t - #3 “Counter-Standards” 409 3 2NC Extension: A/t - #4 “Only Positive Conditions” 410 4 2NC Extension: A/t - #5 “No Case Meets” 411 5 2NC Extension: A/t - #6 “Reasonability” 412 6 1NC Shell: Topicality – Cuba 413 1 2NC Extension: A/t #1 “We Meet” 414 1 2NC Extension: A/t #2 “Counter-interpretation” 415 2 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter Standards” 416 3 2NC Extension: A/t #4 “Effects Inevitable” 417 4 2NC Extension: A/t #5 “Affirmative Ground” 418 5 2NC Extension: A/t - #6 “Reasonability” 419 6 1NC Shell: Topicality – Critical Immigration 420 1 1NC Shell: Topicality – Critical Immigration 421 2 1NC Shell: Topicality – Critical Immigration 422 3 1NC Shell: Topicality – Critical Immigration 423 4 2NC Extension: A/t #1 “We Meet” 424 1 2NC Extension: A/t #2 “Counter-interpretation” 425 2 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [1/4] 426 3 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [2/4] 427 4 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [3/4] 428 5 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Counter standards” [4/4] 429 6 2NC Extension: A/t #4 “Other Words Check” 430 7 2NC Extension: A/t #5 “No Extra Topicality” 431 8 Topicality Affirmative 432 1 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Mexico Security 433 1 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Mexico Security 434 2 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Venezuela Democracy 435 1 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Venezuela Democracy 436 2 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Venezuela Democracy 437 4 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Venezuela Democracy 438 5 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Cuba Ethanol 439 1 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Cuba Ethanol 440 2 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Cuba Ethanol 441 3 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Critical Immigration 442 1 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Critical Immigration 443 3 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Critical Immigration 444 4 2AC Frontline: Topicality – Critical Immigration 445 5 Neo-colonialism Kritik 446 1 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 447 13 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 448 14 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 449 16 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 450 17 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 451 18 1NC Shell: Neo-Colonialism Kritik 452 19 2NC Extension: A/t #1 “No Link” 453 1 2NC Extension: A/t #2 “Permutation” 454 2 2NC Extension: A/t #3 “Fiat Theory” 455 3 2NC Extension: A/t #4 “Alternative Fails” [1/2] 456 4 2NC Extension: A/t #4 “Alternative Fails” [2/2] 457 6 2NC Extension: A/t #5 “Consequentialism” 458 7 2NC Extension: A/t #6 “Globalization Solves War” 459 9 2NC Extension: A/t #7 “Extinction Outweighs” 460 10 2NC Extension: A/t #8 “Sustainability” 461 11 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #1 “Role of the Ballot” 462 12 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #2 “Deconstruction fails” [1/3] 463 13 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #2 “Deconstruction fails” [2/3] 464 14 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #2 “Deconstruction fails” [3/3] 465 15 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #3 “Racism is root cause” 466 16 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #4 “No link” 467 17 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #5 “Permutation” 468 18 2NC Extension [Critical Immigration]: A/t #6 “Alternative fails” 469 19 Plan-specific Impact Module: Mexico Security 470 20 Plan-specific Impact Module: Venezuela Democracy [1/2] 471 21 Plan-specific Impact Module: Venezuela Democracy [2/2] 472 22 Plan-specific Impact Module: Cuba Ethanol [1/2] 473 23 Plan-specific Impact Module: Cuba Ethanol [2/2] 474 24 Neo-colonialism Kritik Affirmative 475 1 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [1/6] 476 12 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [2/6] 477 13 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [3/6] 478 14 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [4/6] 479 15 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [5/6] 480 16 2AC Frontline: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [6/6] 481 17 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [1/6] 482 18 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [2/6] 483 19 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [3/6] 484 20 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [4/6] 485 21 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [5/6] 486 22 2AC Frontline [Critical Immigration]: Neo-Colonialism Kritik [6/6] 487 23 Directory: wp-content -> uploads -> 2011 2011 -> Voices of the Old Sea Norman Lewis 2011 -> Malevil Robert Merle 2011 -> The Elephant Keeper’s Children Peter Hoeg 2011 -> Jv packet •Mars Colonization Affirmative •Mars Colonization Negative 2011 -> Registration Form (Rev. 8-86) omb no. 1024-0018 2011 -> All America Looks Up to Virginia;” Virginia and the Declaration of Independence 2011 -> Rao bulletin 2011 -> Christopher Columbus was born between 25 August and 31 October 1451 in 2011 -> The Battle of Frenchtown (1855), Washington Territory: the Political and Demographic Context rev 9/4/11 2011 -> Seti aff •seti neg •Asteroids Aff Download 3.16 Mb. Share with your friends:
|