Gonzaga Debate Institute 2011 Mercury Scholars International Brain Drain da



Download 425.95 Kb.
Page1/36
Date conversion05.08.2017
Size425.95 Kb.
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   36

Gonzaga Debate Institute 2011

Mercury Scholars International Brain Drain DA




1NC Brain Drain 1/ 7

1NC Brain Drain 1/ 7

1NC Brain Drain 2/ 9



1NC Brain Drain 2/ 9

**Uniqueness** 10



**Uniqueness** 10

Uniqueness – NASA Hiring Declining 11



Uniqueness – NASA Hiring Declining 11

Uniqueness – NASA Budget Cuts 1/2 12



Uniqueness – NASA Budget Cuts 1/2 12

Uniqueness – NASA Budget Cuts 2/2 13



Uniqueness – NASA Budget Cuts 2/2 13

Uniqueness – Retirement 14



Uniqueness – Retirement 14

Uniqueness – Retirement 15



Uniqueness – Retirement 15

Uniqueness – Jobs Low Now 16



Uniqueness – Jobs Low Now 16

**Links** 17



**Links** 17

Link – Recruit Overseas 1/2 18



Link – Recruit Overseas 1/2 18

Link – Recruit Overseas 2/2 19



Link – Recruit Overseas 2/2 19

Link – Satellites 20



Link – Satellites 20

Link – Commercial Space Development 21



Link – Commercial Space Development 21

Link – Launch Vehicles and Space Travel 22



Link – Launch Vehicles and Space Travel 22

Link – Remote Sensing 23



Link – Remote Sensing 23

AT: No Link – Domestic Workforce Solves 24



AT: No Link – Domestic Workforce Solves 24

AT: No Link – Domestic Workforce Solves 25



AT: No Link – Domestic Workforce Solves 25

AT: No Link – Security Restrictions – Apply to Domestic Hires 26



AT: No Link – Security Restrictions – Apply to Domestic Hires 26

AT: No Link – Export Controls 27



AT: No Link – Export Controls 27

AT: Link Turn – Spurs Student enter Aerospace field 28



AT: Link Turn – Spurs Student enter Aerospace field 28

**Impacts** 29



**Impacts** 29

Israel - AT: Brain Drain Now 30



Israel - AT: Brain Drain Now 30

Israel - Impact Uniqueness 31



Israel - Impact Uniqueness 31

Israel - take jobs in the US 32



Israel - take jobs in the US 32

Israel - AT: Brain Circulation 33



Israel - AT: Brain Circulation 33

Israel - Scientific Brain Drain Hurts Military 34



Israel - Scientific Brain Drain Hurts Military 34

Israel - Scientific Brain Drain Hurts Military 35



Israel - Scientific Brain Drain Hurts Military 35

Israel - Space Program Key to Military 36



Israel - Space Program Key to Military 36

Israel – Economy 37



Israel – Economy 37

Israel - Economy 38



Israel - Economy 38

South Africa 1/2 39



South Africa 1/2 39

South Africa 2/2 40



South Africa 2/2 40

South Africa - Brain Drain hurts Economy 41



South Africa - Brain Drain hurts Economy 41

South Africa - Internal Link – Economy 43



South Africa - Internal Link – Economy 43

South Africa – African Econ key to US Econ 44



South Africa – African Econ key to US Econ 44

South Africa - Now Key 45



South Africa - Now Key 45

**India Poverty Scenario** 46



**India Poverty Scenario** 46

**India Conflict Scenario 1/2** 47



**India Conflict Scenario 1/2** 47

**India Conflict Scenario 2/2** 48



**India Conflict Scenario 2/2** 48

India – Uniqueness 49



India – Uniqueness 49

Uniqueness 50



Uniqueness 50

India – Space key to Military 51



India – Space key to Military 51

India – economic decline bad 52



India – economic decline bad 52

India - AT: No Nuclear War 53



India - AT: No Nuclear War 53

India - AT: No Extinction 54



India - AT: No Extinction 54

India - AT: Deterrence Solves 55



India - AT: Deterrence Solves 55

**Russia Scenario** 56



**Russia Scenario** 56

Russians take jobs in the US 1/2 58



Russians take jobs in the US 1/2 58

Russians take jobs in the US 2/2 59



Russians take jobs in the US 2/2 59

Russia – Human Missions key to Industry 60



Russia – Human Missions key to Industry 60

Russia – Aerospace Key 61



Russia – Aerospace Key 61

Russia – Space Leadership 62



Russia – Space Leadership 62

Russia – Space Leadership 63



Russia – Space Leadership 63

Russia - Now Key 64



Russia - Now Key 64

Russia - AT: Deterrence Solves 65



Russia - AT: Deterrence Solves 65

Russia AT – No US/Russia war 66



Russia AT – No US/Russia war 66

Russia - AT: Russia Has No Nukes 67



Russia - AT: Russia Has No Nukes 67

Russia’s Military Expanding 68



Russia’s Military Expanding 68

Russia’s Military Expanding 69



Russia’s Military Expanding 69

**AT Brain Drain Good** 70



**AT Brain Drain Good** 70

AT: Strengthens US Space Industry 70



AT: Strengthens US Space Industry 70

AT: Brain Circulation 71



AT: Brain Circulation 71

AT: Brain Circulation 72



AT: Brain Circulation 72

AT: Brain Circulation 73



AT: Brain Circulation 73

AT: Brain Circulation – No India 74



AT: Brain Circulation – No India 74

***Aff*** 75



***Aff*** 75

Non Unique – Hiring Now 76



Non Unique – Hiring Now 76

No Link – Security Restrictions 77



No Link – Security Restrictions 77

No Link – Export Controls 78



No Link – Export Controls 78

No Link – No Visas 79



No Link – No Visas 79

No Link - Domestic Workers Solve 80



No Link - Domestic Workers Solve 80

Link Turn – Plan Increases Workforce 81



Link Turn – Plan Increases Workforce 81

Alt Cause of Brain Drain 82



Alt Cause of Brain Drain 82

No Impact – General 83



No Impact – General 83

No Impact - Brain Circulation 84



No Impact - Brain Circulation 84

Brain Circulation Good - Research 85



Brain Circulation Good - Research 85

Brain Circulation Good – Research 86



Brain Circulation Good – Research 86

Brain Circulation Good – Research 87



Brain Circulation Good – Research 87

Brain Circulation Good – Economy 88



Brain Circulation Good – Economy 88

Brain Circulation Good – Economy 89



Brain Circulation Good – Economy 89

Impact Turn - Economy 90



Impact Turn - Economy 90

Impact Turn– Leadership 91



Impact Turn– Leadership 91

**South Africa Scenario** 92



**South Africa Scenario** 92

South Africa - Non -Unique – Brain Drain Now 92



South Africa - Non -Unique – Brain Drain Now 92

**India Scenario** 93



**India Scenario** 93

India - Brain Drain Good – Economy 93



India - Brain Drain Good – Economy 93

India - Brain Drain Good – Technology 94



India - Brain Drain Good – Technology 94

India - No Impact – Brain Drain Normal 95



India - No Impact – Brain Drain Normal 95

India - No Impact – Economy Resilient 96



India - No Impact – Economy Resilient 96

India - Impact Non-Unique – Econ Low Now 97



India - Impact Non-Unique – Econ Low Now 97

India – AT: Economy 98



India – AT: Economy 98

**Russia Scenario** 99



**Russia Scenario** 99

Russia - Space Not key to Econ 99



Russia - Space Not key to Econ 99

Russia - Space has been cut before 100



Russia - Space has been cut before 100

Russia - Alt Causes – Econ 101



Russia - Alt Causes – Econ 101

Russia - Brain Drain Non unique 102



Russia - Brain Drain Non unique 102

Russia – No Brain Drain 103



Russia – No Brain Drain 103

**Israel Scenario** 104



**Israel Scenario** 104

Israel - Non Unique – Brain Drain Now 105



Israel - Non Unique – Brain Drain Now 105

Israel - No Impact – Economy Resilient 106



Israel - No Impact – Economy Resilient 106

Israel – No Space Brain Drain 107



Israel – No Space Brain Drain 107

Israel - Military Power Bad – Nuclear War 108



Israel - Military Power Bad – Nuclear War 108

Non Unique – China 109



Non Unique – China 109

Non Unique – UK 110



Non Unique – UK 110

Non Unique - Greece 111



Non Unique - Greece 111





  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   36


The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2016
send message

    Main page