UNIVERSITY OF CAPE COAST
CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION IN COLLEGES OF EDUCATION IN GHANA: AN EXPLORATORY STUDY OF THE PERCEPTIONS OF TEACHER TRAINEES AND TUTORS OF SOCIAL STUDIES
KANKAM BOADU
2012
UNIVERSITY OF CAPE COAST
C
ITIZENSHIP EDUCATION IN COLLEGES OF EDUCATION IN GHANA: AN EXPLORATORY STUDY OF THE PERCEPTIONS OF STUDENT TEACHERS AND TUTORS OF SOCIAL STUDIES
BY
KANKAM BOADU
THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE INSTITUTE FOR DEVELOPMENT STUDIES, FACULTY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, UNIVERSITY OF CAPE COAST, IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AWARD OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DEGREE IN DEVELOPMENT STUDIES
JUNE 2012
DECLARATION
Candidate’s Declaration
I hereby declare that this thesis is the result of my original work and that no part of it has been presented for another degree in this university or elsewhere.
Candidate’s Signature………………. Date………….………...
Name: Kankam Boadu
Supervisors’ Declaration
We hereby declare that the preparation of the thesis was supervised with the guidelines on supervision of thesis laid down by the University of Cape Coast.
Principal Supervisor’s Signature …………… Date…..……………..…
Name: Prof. S. B. Kendie
Co-Supervisor’s Signature………………..…. Date……………………
Name: Prof. J. V. Mensah
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study was to explore the perception of social studies teacher trainees and their tutors in the colleges of education in Ghana with regards to the meaning and teaching methods that are most appropriate to teach citizenship education. The research drew upon social capital, ecological, and cognitive psychological theories to generate the conceptual framework for analysing the quantitative and qualitative data. The perceptions of tutors and teacher trainees of social studies in their final year from eight colleges of education were surveyed, and small samples of the respondents were interviewed to further understand both groups’ perceptions of citizenship education.
The major findings were: (i) Tutors and teacher trainees generally agreed on the components of citizenship education, chi-square test test showed that there was a difference in perceptions between tutors and teacher trainees (ii) Both tutors and trainees generally agreed on the characteristics of a good citizen. (iii) There was general agreement between the tutors and trainees that various classroom activities are important in the teaching of citizenship education and are being taught effectively. There were some differences between the groups on certain specific teaching methods and the effectiveness of the teaching of those activities. The study has made a significant contribution to the existing literature on citizenship education issues in the contemporary Ghanaian colleges of education. The study concludes with the recommendations to policy makers and stakeholders of education to consider the need to improve the quality of citizenship education materials.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I wish to record my profound appreciation and gratitude to my Principal Supervisor, Prof. S. B. Kendie of Institute for Development Studies, University of Cape Coast and Prof. J. V. Mensah, my Co-supervisor, also at the Institute for Development Studies, University of Cape Coast, for their scrutiny of this work, which has given it better focus. I am also thankful to Dr. Dan Dellow of the University of South Florida, United State of America, who mentored my work when I was a Ghanaian Scholar in America.
I am deeply indebted to Drs. Nana N. K. T. Ghartey and Dr. Enu-Kwesi for their concern and encouragement during the course of writing the thesis. My sincere thanks are due to Prof. S. N. Oden, Dr. H. O. Owulabi, Dr. Musa Wakhungo Olaka, Ben Osongo, Mr. E. Tawiah-Dadzie, Isaac Atta Kwenin, Peter Partey Anti and all members of staff of the Department of Arts and Social Sciences Education in particular and the entire University for the role they played in making my dream a reality.
My heartfelt gratitude goes to my father, mother, brothers and sisters, my wife, my children and all my family members who have been the constant source of inspiration and support to my work.
DEDICATION
To my wife Gloria and children
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Content Page
DECLARATION 2
ABSTRACT iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv
DEDICATION 5
TABLE OF CONTENTS vi
LIST OF TABLES v
LIST OF FIGURES
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1
Background of the study 1
Statement of the problem 22
Objective of the study 25
Research questions 25
Scope 26
Significance of the study 26
Organisation of the study 27
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
Introduction 30
Theories of citizenship 30
Theories of citizenship education and development 32
Places and developmental context in citizen education 36
Emerging issues in citizenship 36
Core elements of citizenship 39
Citizenship in an African context 42
Citizenship in the Ghanaian context 53
The role of National Commission on Civic Education
In Citizenship Education in Ghana 58
Curricular dimensions of citizenship education 60
The need for citizenship education 60
Subject matter of citizenship education 63
Learning experiences in citizenship education 64
Approaches to citizenship education 66
Teaching and learning interactions in citizenship education 70
Evaluation of citizenship education 73
Citizenship education practices in schools and colleges 75
Challenges of citizenship education 79
Conceptual issues 81
Origin of the terms “citizens” and “citizenship” 81
The rights and obligations of citizens 84
The concept of citizenship education 86
Broad and narrow concepts of citizenship education 93
Citizenship education and social studies 95
EMPIRICAL REVIEW OF LITERATURE 97
Teachers’ Perceptions of citizenship education 95
Students’ perceptions of citizenship education 103
Conceptual framework for citizenship education and development 106
Summary of the chapter 113
CHAPTER THREE: CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION AND SOCIAL
STUDIES PERSPECTIVES WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IN GHANA 114
History of education in Ghana 114
The structure of educational system in Ghana 116
Pre-school and first cycle education in Ghana 114
Junior High schools (JHS) 117
Senior Secondary schools 118
Teacher education development in Ghana 118
Technical and vocational education 121
The historical development of social studies 123
General background of social studies education 123
Development of social studies in the United States of America 124
Development of social studies in the English-speaking African countries 125
Foundation of social studies in Ghana 127
Goals and purposes of social studies 132
Citizenship education in teacher education 135
Summary of the chapter 137
CHAPTER FOUR: RESEARCH METHODOLGY
Overview 139
Research paradigms 139
Positivism 141
Interpretive paradigm 141
Study area 144
Research design 147
Population 152
Sampling procedure 154
Sample size 155
Samples for the research 155
Research Instruments 160
Pre-testing 163
Validity of the instruments 164
Reliability of the instruments 165
Conducting the Interviews 168
Limitations to the Study 169
Data Analysis Technique 170
CHAPTER FIVE: TUTORS’ AND TEACHER-TRAINEES’
PERCEPTIONS OF CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION 173
Introduction 173
Ages of tutors in the colleges of education 173
Tutors and teaching experience 175
Tutors’ perception on citizenship education 179
Teacher trainees’ perceptions of citizenship education 183
Tutors and teacher trainees’ perceptions of citizenship education 192
Tutors’ and teacher trainees’ perceptions on a good Ghanaian citizen 196
CHAPTER SIX: CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION AND ITS PRACTICES IN COLLEGES OF EDUCATION 204
The practice of citizenship education in the colleges of education in Ghana. 204
General approaches of introducing citizenship education 210
Goals of citizenship education 213
CHAPTER SEVEN: STRACTEGIES FOR ACHIEVING CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION 218
Values and skills required for good citizenship 225
Skills developed through citizenship education 236
Challenges of teaching citizenship education 243
CHAPTER EIGHT: REPRESENTATION OF THE INTERVIEW DATA 250
Introduction 250
Interview schedules 251
The analysis of the interviews of the Head of Department and
Teacher trainees (class leaders) of social studies 251
Meaning of ‘good citizen’ 252
The concept of citizenship 253
Development of citizenship through school the school curriculum 255
The importance of citizenship education in Ghana 259
Values and skills to be developed in citizenship education 260
Emerging issues 260
CHAPTER NINE: SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 262
Introduction 262
Summary 262
Teacher trainees’ and tutors' perceptions on citizenship education 265
Teacher trainees' and tutors' perceptions on a good Ghanaian citizen 261
The practice of citizenship education in the colleges of education 262
Methods for teaching citizenship education in the colleges of education 267
Values and skills developed through citizenship education 268
Challenges of teaching citizenship education 268
Conclusions 269
Policy implications recommended 271
Areas for further studies 273
REFERENCES 275
APPENDDICES 312
A: Questionnaire for tutors 317
B: Interview schedule for tutors 332
C: Questionnaire for teacher trainees 334
D: Interview schedule for teacher trainees 349
E: Distribution of population of final year teacher trainees 351
F: Reliability measure on teacher trainees and tutor 353
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
1: Distribution of sampled colleges of education 157
2: Distribution of population and sample selected for teacher trainees 159
3: Ages of tutors in colleges of education 174
4: Tutors teaching experience in colleges 176
5: Tutor’ perception on citizenship education 179
6: Teacher trainees’ perception on citizenship education 184
7: Cross-tabulation of reponses for tutors’ and teacher trainees
by perceptions of citizenship education 192
8: Cross-tabulation of reponses for tutors’ and teacher trainees by
perceptions on characteristics of a good citizen 198
9: Respondents view on how citizenship education is practised in the
colleges of education 205
10: Teacher trainees and tutors views on how citizenship education
be approached 210
11: Goals of citizenship education 214
12: Importance and effectiveness of teaching methods 220
13: Important and effective values in citizenship education 230
14: Important and effective skills in citizenship education 238
15: Challenges of teaching citizenship education 245
LIST OF FIGURE
Figure Page
1: Citizenship education for national development 109
Share with your friends: |