Sps supplement Rough Draft-endi2011 Alpharetta 2011 / Boyce, Doshi, Hermansen, Ma, Pirani



Download 0.84 Mb.
Page1/41
Date26.11.2017
Size0.84 Mb.
#35062
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   41

SPS Supplement Rough Draft-ENDI2011 Alpharetta 2011

/ Boyce, Doshi, Hermansen, Ma, Pirani

Table of Contents





Table of Contents 1

Table of Contents 1

Strat Sheet 5

Strat Sheet 5

***AFF*** 6

***AFF*** 6

SPS Solves – 1 Gigawatt 7

SPS Solves – 1 Gigawatt 7

SPS Solves – Needs Development 8

SPS Solves – Needs Development 8

SPS Necessary – Power Low Now 11

SPS Necessary – Power Low Now 11

SPS Solves – Feasible 12

SPS Solves – Feasible 12

SPS Solves – Studies 14

SPS Solves – Studies 14

SPS Solves – Spills Over 17

SPS Solves – Spills Over 17

SPS Solves – Specific Info 18

SPS Solves – Specific Info 18

SPS Solves – Laundry List 19

SPS Solves – Laundry List 19

SPS Spillover – Markets Now 22

SPS Spillover – Markets Now 22

SPS Solves – Long-Term 23

SPS Solves – Long-Term 23

SPS Adaptable 24

SPS Adaptable 24

Action Now Key 26

Action Now Key 26

SPS Solves – Testing 27

SPS Solves – Testing 27

Water Wars Advantage 28

Water Wars Advantage 28

Water Wars Adv – Impact Ext 32

Water Wars Adv – Impact Ext 32

Water Wars Adv – Solvency Ext 36

Water Wars Adv – Solvency Ext 36

Leadership Internal Link 37

Leadership Internal Link 37

Leadership Uniqueness 39

Leadership Uniqueness 39

Leadership Turns DA’s 41

Leadership Turns DA’s 41

Leadership – Aerospace Update 42

Leadership – Aerospace Update 42

Warming – Ocean Acidification Impact 44

Warming – Ocean Acidification Impact 44

Warming – Impact Work 47

Warming – Impact Work 47

Warming – Brink Ev 49

Warming – Brink Ev 49

Warming – Biosphere Loss Impact 51

Warming – Biosphere Loss Impact 51

AT: GEO Orbit 52

AT: GEO Orbit 52

AT: Talent 53

AT: Talent 53

AT: Launcher Shortages 54

AT: Launcher Shortages 54

AT: Generic Spending/Problems 56

AT: Generic Spending/Problems 56

AT: Co-Op DA 57

AT: Co-Op DA 57

AT: Aerostat CP 58

AT: Aerostat CP 58

AT: Weapons/Microwaves 60

AT: Weapons/Microwaves 60

Terrestrial Renewables Add-On 61

Terrestrial Renewables Add-On 61

Prolif Add-On Update 62

Prolif Add-On Update 62

Econ Add-On 63

Econ Add-On 63

Exploration Add-On Update 65

Exploration Add-On Update 65

Plan Popular 66

Plan Popular 66

Spending Link Turn 68

Spending Link Turn 68

SPS Spills Over 69

SPS Spills Over 69

Sino-US Space Race Impact 71

Sino-US Space Race Impact 71

***NEG*** 72

***NEG*** 72

SPS Fails – Barriers 73

SPS Fails – Barriers 73

SPS Not Feasible 74

SPS Not Feasible 74

NSSO Indict 75

NSSO Indict 75

Warming Defense 77

Warming Defense 77

Energy Impacts Inevitable 79

Energy Impacts Inevitable 79

Spending Link 80

Spending Link 80

Co-Op DA – Solves Peace 81

Co-Op DA – Solves Peace 81

Space Debris DA – Link 84

Space Debris DA – Link 84

Space Debris DA – Impact 85

Space Debris DA – Impact 85

AT: Debris Add-On 86

AT: Debris Add-On 86

Launchers Update 89

Launchers Update 89

Politics – Solar Getting Cut 90

Politics – Solar Getting Cut 90

Politics Link – Private Sector Popular 92

Politics Link – Private Sector Popular 92

Politics Link – Solar Unpopular 93

Politics Link – Solar Unpopular 93

GEO Link 95

GEO Link 95

Aerostats CP 1NC 96

Aerostats – Avoids DA 98

Aerostats – Better than SPS 99

Aerostats – Avoids Spending 100

Aerostats – Solves Warming 102

Aerostats -- 2NC Solvency 103

DoD CP 104

DoD CP 104

DoD CP – 2NC Solvency 106

DoD CP – 2NC Solvency 106

DoD CP – Solves Commercial Space 108

DoD CP – Solves Commercial Space 108

Boeing CP 110

Boeing CP 110

CSP CP 112

CSP CP 112

Possible Private CP Stuff 114

Possible Private CP Stuff 114

Leadership Brink Ev 115

Leadership Brink Ev 115

***Weaponization Work*** 118

***Weaponization Work*** 118

SPS Weapons Internal Link 119

SPS Weapons Internal Link 119

Space Mil Inevitable 121

Space Mil Inevitable 121

China ASATs Justify US Development 122

China ASATs Justify US Development 122

US Weaponizing Now 124

US Weaponizing Now 124

Space Weapons Bad – War 125

Space Weapons Bad – War 125

Arms Control Doesn’t Solve 126

Arms Control Doesn’t Solve 126

US Wins Sino War 127

US Wins Sino War 127

China=Superior 128

China=Superior 128

US Needs to Change Policy 129

US Needs to Change Policy 129

Weaponization Good 130

Weaponization Good 130

Dominance Good 134

Dominance Good 134


Strat Sheet



This is the supplement and updates file for the Solar Powered Satellites Aff (SPS). This includes:

- The major questions of feasibility and solvency for the Aff, as well as some more cards for the Neg.

- A new water wars advantage that expands the concept from just an add-on in the previous file. The internal link is based off of the satellites providing power for desalination plants which would solve water problems.

- Updates to the leadership and warming advantages which more brink and solvency evidence.

- Updated Aff answers to popular case arguments which can be included in updated 1AC’s.

- Neg evidence to update DA links and case answers.

- Add-Ons
There are also CP’s:

- Aerostats: Deploys things in different altitude orbits to solve (troposphere) – avoids DA links because it is isn’t going into space and isn’t funded under NASA for politics.

- Boeing: Specific private actor CP that uses Boeing tech to do the plan

- DoD: Agent CP that solves commercial action.

- CSP: Concentrated solar thermal power plants that use ground-based systems.
There is also some space weapons work at the end – and an internal link to an advantage.



Download 0.84 Mb.

Share with your friends:
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   41




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page