Gonzaga Debate Institute 2011 Mercury China Coop Aff



Download 0.99 Mb.
Page1/93
Date18.10.2016
Size0.99 Mb.
#2396
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   93

Gonzaga Debate Institute 2011

Mercury China Coop Aff

China Coop Aff



China Coop Aff 1

*** 1AC 2

1AC – Contention 1 – No Sino-US Space Coop Now 2

1AC – Plan Drafts 3

1AC – Miscalculation Advantage Draft 4

1AC – Cooperation Advantage Draft 9

1AC – Solvency Draft 13



*** Inherency 14

Inherency – No Coop Now 15

Inherency – No Coop Now – ISS 16

Inherency – No Coop Now – Wolf Clause (1/4) 17

Inherency – No Coop Now – Wolf Clause (2/4) 18

Inherency – No Coop Now – Wolf Clause (3/4) 19

Inherency – No Coop Now – Wolf Clause (4/4) 20

Inherency – AT – Status Quo Solves – Wolf Clause Expires 21



*** Space Race Advantage 22

Space Race Now (1/2) 23

Space Race Now (2/2) 24

US Losing Space Competitiveness To China 25

China Rising Now – Space 26

China Rising Now – Tech 27

Chinese Space Power High – General (1/2) 28

Chinese Space Power High – General (2/2) 29

Chinese Space Power High – China Would Win 30

China Weaponizing Now – General (1/3) 31

China Weaponizing Now – General (2/3) 32

China Weaponizing Now – General (3/3) 33

Space Race – US Posture Key (1/4) 34

Space Race – US Posture Key (2/4) 35

Space Race – US Posture Key (3/4) 36

Space Race – US Posture Key (4/4) 37

Space Race – US Exclusion Policy Drives Chinese Policy (1/2) 38

Space Race – US Exclusion Policy Drives Chinese Policy (2/2) 39

Space Race – Containment 40

Space Race – Space Conflict Inevitable Now 41

Space Race – Causes Miscalc (1/2) 42

Space Race – Causes Miscalc (2/2) 43

Space Race – Quick Attack 44

Space Race – Cyber Attacks 45

Space War – Escalates (1/2) 46

Space War – Escalates (2/2) 47

Space Race – Hegemony 48

Space Race – Hegemony 49

Space Primacy Good – Key To Hegemony 50

Space Race – Taiwan Scenario (1/4) 51

Space Race – Taiwan Scenario (2/4) 52

Space Race – Taiwan Scenario (3/4) 53

Space Race – Taiwan Scenario (4/4) 54

Space Race – CCP Collapse Scenario 55

Coop Solves – Space Race (1/3) 56

Coop Solves – Space Race (2/3) 57

Coop Solves – Space Race (3/3) 58

*** ASATs Advantage 59

Space Race – US Drives Chinese ASAT Acquisition (1/2) 60

Space Race – US Drives Chinese ASAT Acquisition (2/2) 61

Chinese Space Power High – ASATs 62

China Weaponizing Now – ASAT (1/2) 63

China Weaponizing Now – ASAT (2/2) 64

ASATs Bad – Impact Laundry List 65

ASATs Bad – US Retaliation/ War 66

ASATs Bad – US Retaliation/ War 67

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – China Asymmetrical Advantage (1/2) 68

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – China Asymmetrical Advantage (2/2) 69

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – China Will Take Space (1/2) 70

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – China Will Take Space (2/2) 71

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – US Hard Power (1/3) 72

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – US Hard Power (2/3) 73

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – US Hard Power (3/3) 74

ASATs Bad – Miscalc 75

ASATs Bad – Taiwan Scenario 76

ASATs Bad – Hegemony – Turns East Asian Allies 77

ASATs Bad – Causes ASAT Prolif 78

ASATs Bad – Space Debris – No Future Missions 79

Coop Solves – ASATs (1/2) 80

Coop Solves – ASATs (2/2) 82

*** Cooperation Advantage 83

China – Wants To Go To Space 84

China – Wants Coop With The US (1/2) 85

China – Wants Coop With The US (2/2) 86

US – Wants Coop (1/2) 87

US – Wants Coop (2/2) 88

Now Key – General (1/2) 89

Now Key – General (2/2) 90

Space Key To Cooperation (1/3) 91

Space Key To Cooperation (2/3) 92

Space Key To Cooperation (3/3) 93

Coop Good – Spill Over To Other Areas (1/3) 94

Coop Good – Spill Over To Other Areas (2/3) 95

Coop Good – Spill Over To Other Areas (3/3) 96

Coop Good – AT – China Is A Bad Partner (1/2) 97

Coop Good – AT – China Is A Bad Partner (2/2) 98

Coop Good – Laundry List (1/2) 99

Coop Good – Laundry List (2/2) 100

Coop Good – Miscalc 101

Coop Good – Space Peace 102

Coop Good – Space Peace 103

Coop Good – Peaceful China Rise 104

Coop Good – China Threat 105

Coop Good – Space Race 106

Coop Good – Space Tensions 107

Coop Good – Space Tensions 108

Coop Good – Chinese Militarization 109

Coop Good – Chinese Militarization 110

Coop Good – Chinese Militarization 111

Coop Good – Solves Trust 112

Coop Good – Solves Trust 113

Coop Good – Leadership 114

Coop Good – AT – Containment Good 115

Coop Good – Cost 116

Coop Good – Cost 117

Coop Good – NASA Benefits 118

Coop Good – Exploration (1/2) 119

Coop Good – Exploration (2/2) 120

Coop Good – Space Science (1/2) 121

Coop Good – Space Science (2/2) 122

Coop Good – Competitiveness (1/2) 124

Coop Good – Competitiveness (2/2) 125

Coop Good – Environment 126

Coop Good – Environment & Econ 127

Coop Good – Environment & Prolif 128

Coop Good – Energy 129

Coop Good – Energy, Relations & Economy 130

Coop Good – Prolif 131

Coop Good – North Korea 132

Coop Good – East Asia Peace 133



*** Relations Advantage 134

Relations Low Now – ASATs 135

Relations Low Now – ASATs 136

Relations Good – Extinction 137

Relations Good – Miscalc 138

Relations Good – Trade 139

Coop Solvency – Relations 140

Coop Solves Relations – Empirics 141

Coop Solves Relations – Space Key 142

Coop Solves Relations – Tech 143

Coop Solves Relations – Tech 144

Coop Key to Relations – Tension 145



*** US Soft Power Advantage 146

US Space Leadership Down – General (1/3) 147

US Space Leadership Down – General (2/3) 148

US Space Leadership Down – General (3/3) 149

US Soft Power Low – Coop Key 150

Coop Solves – Leadership 151

Coop Solves – Soft Power 152

Space Exploration Good – US Leadership 153

Space Exploration Good – Soft Power 154

Space Exploration Good – Soft / Hard Power 155



*** Solvency – ISS Mechanism 156

ISS – China Excluded Now (1/2) 157

ISS – China Excluded Now (2/2) 158

ISS – China Says Yes (1/4) 159

ISS – China Says Yes (2/4) 160

ISS – China Says Yes (3/4) 161

ISS – China Says Yes (4/4) 162

ISS – ESA Says Yes 163

ISS – ISS Says Yes 164

ISS – Other Countries Say Yes 165

ISS – Solves Small Steps Key 166

ISS – Solves Cost And Satellites 167

ISS – Solves Security Concerns & Costs 168

ISS – Solves Transparency 169

ISS – Solves Coop 170

ISS – Solves Relations (1/4) 171

ISS – Solves Relations (2/4) 172

ISS – Solves Relations (3/4) 173

ISS – Solves Relations (4/4) 174

ISS – Solves Innovation 175

ISS – Solves Laundry List (1/3) 176

ISS – Solves Laundry List (2/3) 177

ISS – Solves Laundry List (3/3) 178

*** Solvency – Mars Mechanism 179

Mars – Now is Key 180

Mars – US Wants To Coop With China 181

Mars – China Wants To Go 182



*** Solvency – General 183

Mission Planning – China Capabilities 184

Mission Planning – Key To Coop 185

Solvency – AT – Coop Fails – Common Standards – Key To Coop 186

Solvency – Coop – General – Lots Of Options 187

Solvency – 4 Step Plan – Coop 188

Solvency – Dialogue – Coop (1/2) 189

Solvency – Dialogue – Coop (2/2) 190

Solvency – Data Sharing – Solves Coop 191

China Say Yes (1/3) 192

China Say Yes (2/3) 193

China Say Yes (3/3) 194

China Say Yes – Staffed Missions 195

Coop Feasible 196

Coop Feasible – Empirically 197

Coop Feasible – AT – NASA Won’t Coop 198

Coop Feasible – AT – Suspicions (1/2) 199

Coop Feasible – AT – Suspicions (2/2) 200

Coop Solves – Spills Over To Relations 201

Coop Solvency – Now Key to Influence Chinese Space Policy (1/2) 202

Coop Solvency – Now Key to Influence Chinese Space Policy (2/2) 203

Now Key – Space Dragons (1/2) 204

Now Key – Space Dragons (2/2) 205

***AT – Coop Bad – Militarization Turn 206

Non Unique – Espionage Now 207

Can’t Spy Through Coop 208

Can’t Spy Through Coop – Military and Civilian Separated 209

Can’t Spy Through Coop – No Disclosure 210

Won’t Militarize – Private Sector 211

Won’t Militarize – Tech Incompatible 212



***AT – Off Case Args 213

Topicality – Space Exploration/Development 214

Topicality – Space Exploration 215

Topicality – Space Development (1/2) 216

Topicality – Space Development (2/2) 217

Security/Pan K Link Turn (1/3) 218

Security/Pan K Link Turn (2/3) 219

Security/Pan K Link Turn (3/3) 220

Status Quo Uses Security Logic (1/2) 221

Status Quo Uses Security Logic (2/2) 222

Coop Alt Actor CP Answer – China Key 223

Treaty CP Answers 224

Arms Control/Treaty CP Answer –No Verification And Constrains The US (1/2) 225

Arms Control/Treaty CP Answer –No Verification And Constrains The US (1/2) 226

China Soft Power Bad Answer – Coop Solves 227

Spending Answer – Burden-Sharing 228

Politics Aff – Plan Would Be a Win 229

Politics Aff – Wolf Link Trick (1/2) 230

Politics Aff – Wolf Link Trick (2/2) 231

Politics Aff – China Bashing Now (1/2) 232

Politics Aff - China Bashing Now (2/2) 233

Rollback/Wolf Clause Answer (1/2) 234

Rollback/Wolf Clause Answer (2/2) 235

Regime Legitimacy Bad Answer 236




*** 1AC





Download 0.99 Mb.

Share with your friends:
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   93




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page