01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.16
|
New case of R v Ibrahim [2010] VSC 333.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.17
|
New case of R v Hasan [2010] VSCA 352.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.18
|
New case of R v Markovic & Pantelic [2010] VSCA 105. New reference to DPP v Bourozikas [2009] VSCA 29.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.22.1
|
New case of DPP v Samson-Rimoni (Sentence) [2010] VSC 111; R v Reglis [2010] VSC 58; R v John Likiardopoulos [2010] VSCA 344. New references to R v Kulla Kulla [2010] VSC 60; DPP v Sazdov [2010] VSC 118; DPP v Akotou [2010] VSC 364; R v Reid [2010] VSCA 234; R v Nghia Nguyen; R v Andreevski & Ors [2010] VSC 618; R v Freeman [2010] VSC 346; R v Docking [2010] VSC 566.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.22.2
|
New reference to R v Middendorp [2010] VSC 202.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.22.3
|
New case of R v Hudson; DPP v Hudson [2010] VSCA 332.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.22.4
|
New case of DPP v Dunne [2010] VSC 220. New reference to R v McIntosh – R v Hargraves [2009] VSC 629.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.23
|
New references to R v Clark [2010] VSCA 64; DPP v Chaplin [2010] VSCA 145; R v Harris [2009] VSCA 287.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24
|
Heading of section amended to “Sentencing for intentionally / recklessly / negligently causing serious injury, affray/riot & reckless endangerment”.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24.1
|
New cases of DPP v RSP [2010] VSC 128; DPP v Bogtstra, Kontoklotsis & Karazisis [2010] VSCA 350. New references to R v Papworth [2010] VSC 422;R v Emery [2010] VSC 478; R v Rossi [2010] VSC 602; R v Dimitrakis [2010] VSC 614; R v Stone [2010] VSC 616;R v Ludeman, Thomas & French [2010] VSCA 333.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24.2
|
New cases of R v Winch [2010] VSCA 141; DPP v Aslan [2010] VSC 518. New reference to R v Willis [2010] VSCA 235.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24.3
|
New reference to DPP v Albert [2010] VSCA 75.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24.5
|
New section entitled “Sentencing for causing injury to ex-partner”. New cases of R v Saltalamacchia [2010] VSCA 83; R v Kane [2010] VSCA 213.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.24.6
|
New section entitled “Sentencing for reckless endangerment”. New case of R v Hennessy [2010] VSCA 297.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.25
|
New cases of R v Power [2010] VSCA 139; R v Bala [2010] VSCA 78; R v Doan [2010] VSCA 250; R v Chandler & Paksoy [2010] VSCA 338. New references to Ngyuen v The Queen [2010] VSCA 127; R v Chhim, R v Arslanov [2010] VSCA 347; R v Hanks [2011] VSCA 7; R v Vasic [2010] VSCA 89; R v Velevski [2010] VSCA 90; R v Duncan [2010] VSCA 92; DPP v Fleiner [2010] VSCA 143; R v Bui [2010] VSC 342.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.26
|
New reference to DPP v Rizkalla [2010] VSC 535.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.27
|
Heading of section amended to “Sentencing for burglary / aggravated burglary”. New cases of R v Saltalamacchia [2010] VSCA 83; R v Le [2010] VSCA 199; R v McCarthy [2010] VSCA 87. New references to R v Stanbury [2010] VSCA 49; R v Secombe and Butkovic [2010] VSCA 58.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.2.28
|
New cases of R v Daniel Roy Simon [2010] VSCA 66; R v Gill [2010] VSCA 64; R v Hasan [2010] VSCA 352. New reference to R v Balassis [2010] VSCA 296.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.3.1
|
New reference to R v Hasan [2010] VSCA 352.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.3.2
|
Heading of section amended to “Use of sentencing statistics and sentencing snapshots”. New case of R v Hasan [2010] VSCA 352.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.3.4
|
New references to R v Barrett [2010] VSCA 133 at [39]-[53]; R v Broad [1999] 3 VR 31; DPP v TY [2009] VSCA 226; R v Ciantar and Rose [2010] VSCA 313.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.3.5
|
New references to dpp v najjar [2009] VSCA 246; DPP (Cth) v Parfrey [2010] VSCA 212 at [33].
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.4.1
|
New case of R v O’Blein [2009] VSCA 159.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.4.4
|
New case of R v AMP [2010] VSCA 48.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.7
|
Addition of 2005, 2006 & 2007 statistics to Table and associated updating of commentary.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.8.1
|
New case of R v Tin Yu Ng and R v Yik Lun Siu [2009] VSCA 218.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.16.1
|
New cases of DPP v CPD (2009) 22 VR 533; [2009] VSCA 114; R v OAA [2010] VSCA 155; R v PDA [2010] VSCA 94; R v FD [2011] VSCA 8. New references to R v NJD [2010] VSCA 84; R v MG [2010] VSCA 97 at [93]; R v Barry Hall [2010] VSCA 349 with reference to Ibbs v The Queen (1987) 163 CLR 447.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.6.3
|
New section headed “Possession/production of child pornography”. New cases of R v Fullop [2009] VSCA 296; R v SLJ (No.2) [2010] VSCA 32; DPP (Cth) v D’Alessandro [2010] VSCA 60; DPP v Smith [2010] VSCA 215. New references to Legal Services Board v McGrath [2010] VSC 332; R v EDM [2010] VSCA 308.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.6.4
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 11.6.3. New case of R v James & Witbeck [2010] VSCA 341.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.6.5
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 11.6.4.
|
01/02/11
|
11
|
11.6.6
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 11.6.5. Delete references to judgment of Cummins J in DPP v Farquharson (appeal allowed and retrial ordered).
|
31/01/11
|
3
|
3.1
|
Added reference to R v Sonnet [2010] VSCA 315 at [15]-[27].
|
31/01/11
|
3
|
3.3.3
|
Added references to MDC [unreported, Children’s Court of Victoria-Levine M, 08/12/2010], Prestia v Machok [unreported, Sunshine Magistrates’ Court-Jones M, 28/10/2010], PG v R [2010] VSCA 298.
|
31/01/11
|
3
|
3.5.15
|
New paragraph entitled “The hearsay rule and exceptions thereto”. Added references to ss.59 & 65 Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) and related sections. New cases of DPP v BB & QN [2011] VSCA 211 per Bongiorno JA (with whom Harper & Hansen JJA agreed); Sajanesh Easwaralingham v DPP [2010] VSCA 353 at [32]-[44] per Tate JA (with whom Buchanan JA agreed) dismissing on this issue an appeal from Pagone J [2010] VSC 437 at [13]-[19]; R v Rossi (Ruling No.1) [2010] VSC 459 per Lasry J.
|
31/01/11
|
10
|
10.3.8
|
New case of R v OAA [2010] VSCA 155.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.5
5.5.6
5.11.10
5.13
5.14.2
5.15.1
5.16.12
5.17.1
5.20.6
5.22.7
5.27.3
5.23.8
|
Addition of statistics for 2008/09. In some instances small consequential changes have been made to the commentary to reflect updated statistics.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.10.1
5.17.2
5.17.8
5.18.1
5.18.5
5.18.7
5.21
5.22.2
5.24.13
5.28
5.29.4
|
Inclusion of VChC references to certain previously unreported cases.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.11.3
|
Change to text on IAO types (a), (b) & (c) as a consequence of amendments to s.263 of the CYFA.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.11.8
|
Change to duration of IAO types (c) & (d) as a consequence of amendments to s.264 of the CYFA.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.25.1
|
Substantial amendments to the first page of the blue form.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.25.2
|
Very minor amendments to the mauve form.
|
01/01/11
|
5
|
5.27.1
|
Removal of reference to s.247(1) of the CYFA not being proclaimed.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
MANY
|
Replacement of “defendant” by “accused” where it occurs except in the context of a quotation. This is to reflect the change in terminology introduced by the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.1.3
|
Additional examples of summary/indictable offences.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.2
|
Addition of child homicide & defensive homicide to the list of indictable offences which the Children’s Court cannot hear and determine summarily.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.2.1
|
Major rewriting of text in this paragraph.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.2.4
|
Paragraph heading amended to “Age of ‘child’ for breach, variation & revocation proceedings”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.3
|
Section heading amended to “Juvenile and adult offending in 2008/09 & 2009/10”. Replacement of 1998/99 statistics with table of alleged juvenile & adult criminal offence statistics 2008/09 & 2009/10. New commentary added together with statistics for Principal Proven Offences 2004/05 to 2008/09.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.4
|
Replacement of 1998/99 cautioning statistics with 2008/09 statistics.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5
|
Section heading amended to “Commencement of ordinary process – Securing attendance of child”. Major changes to text in each associated paragraph to reflect the changes introduced by the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5.1
|
Paragraph heading amended to “Charge-sheet”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5.2
|
New paragraph entitled “Time limits for filing a charge-sheet”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5.3
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 7.5.2.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5.4
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 7.5.3. Paragraph heading amended to “Securing attendance of accused”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.5.5
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 7.5.4. Paragraph heading amended to “Amendment of charge-sheet”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.6
|
Added reference to s.11 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.7
|
CAYPINS statistics for 2008/09 added.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.8.2
|
Added reference to ss.80(1)(b) & 81(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.11
|
Significant amendment to text in relation to The Children’s Koori Court (Criminal Division).
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.11.4
|
Paragraph heading amended to “Sitting times and limited availability”.
|
31/12/10
|
7
|
7.13
|
Added reference C19 – paper of Judge Paul Grant on “The Children’s Court of Victoria – November 2010”.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6.6
|
Addition of Children’s Court intervention order statistics for 2008/2009.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.3.4
|
Amendment to definition of “property” in s.4 of the FVPA.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.8.1
|
Amendment to manner of service on the Attorney-General in s.202 of the FVPA.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.9.6
|
Addition of ss.30 & 31 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) to the list of provisions in that Act preserved by s.65(2) of the FVPA.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.9.7
|
Amendment to s.66 of the FVPA providing that evidence by affidavit or sworn statement may not be admitted if contrary to any provision of the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.10.1
|
New s.53(3) of the FVPA clarifying the extra-territoriality operation of the provisions relating to the making of an interim order.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.11.1
|
Slight alteration to the test in s.74(1) of the FVPA for the making of a final intervention order. New s.74(3) of the FVPA clarifying the extra-territoriality operation of the provisions relating to the making of an final order. Added references to Director of Public Prosecutions (on behalf of Michael Jay Pena) v Brian Andrew Sutcliffe [2001] VSC 43; Brian Andrew Sutcliffe v Director of Public Prosecutions (On behalf of Michael Jay Pena) [2003] VSCA 34.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.14.2
|
Correction of error in s.78(5) of the CFVA.
|
14/12/10
|
6
|
6A.22
|
New provisions clarifying that nothing in ss.118 or 120 prevent an appeal on the basis of a jurisdictional error.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.1
|
Added reference to CL (a minor) v Tim Lee and Ors [2010] VSC 517 at [66] per Lasry J.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.2.4
|
Very minor amendment to text.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.3.8
|
Added reference to R v AMP [2010] VSCA 48 at [47].
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.3.9
|
Added reference to R v Wells [2010] VSCA 100.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.6
|
Minor modification to text.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.6.1
|
Major rewriting of text in this paragraph. References to new case of CL (a minor) v Tim Lee and Ors [2010] VSC 517.
|
01/12/10
|
10
|
10.6.2
|
Minor modification to text and added reference to CL (a minor) v Tim Lee and Ors [2010] VSC 517 at [25] & [29].
|
01/07/10
|
6
|
6A.9.14
|
New section entitled “Assessments reports in proceedings in the Children’s Court”.
|
01/07/10
|
6
|
6A.9.15
|
New section entitled “Applications under the FVPA and the SIOA may be heard together”.
|
01/07/10
|
6
|
6A.10.2
|
New section entitled “Protection of children on court’s own initiative”.
|
01/07/10
|
6
|
6A.10.3
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 6A.10.2.
|
