10
MANY
|
Replacement of “defendant” by “accused” where it occurs except in the context of a quotation.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.2.1
|
Paragraph heading changed to “Purposes”.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.2.2
|
New paragraph heading “Effect of discharge after committal”.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.2.4
|
New paragraph heading “Joint committal proceedings for adult and child co-accused”.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.2.3
10.2.5
10.2.6
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.2.2.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.2.3.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.2.4.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.2
|
Amended commentary.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.3
|
New paragraph heading “’No case’ procedure”. New cases of R v Vella [2007] VSC 585; Oakley and Anor v Insurance Manufacturers of Australia Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 68 at [3].
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.4
|
New paragraph headed “Sentence indication”. Discussion of DPP v Shoan [2007] VSCA 220 moved from paragraph 10.3.2.
|
27/09/09
|
10
|
10.3.5
|
New paragraph headed “No summary case conference in Children’s Court”.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.6
10.3.7
10.3.8
10.3.9
|
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.3.3.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.3.4.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.3.5.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 10.3.6.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.8
|
New case of R v LFJ [2009] VSCA 134.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.3.9
|
New references to cases of Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509, 518 & 520; PNJ v The Queen [2009] HCA 6; R v Rich (Ruling No.1) [2008] VSC 119; R v Rich (Ruling No.2) [2008] VSC 141; Mokbel v DPP (Vic) & Ors [2008] VSC 433.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.6
|
New section entitled “Unfitness to be tried – Mental impairment”.
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.6.1
|
New sub-section entitled “Unfitness to be tried”. New cases of R v NL [Children’s Court of Victoria, unreported, 06/03/2009] & R v CL [Children’s Court of Victoria, unreported, 18/06/2009].
|
27/07/09
|
10
|
10.6.2
|
New sub-section entitled “Mental impairment”. New case of R v Fitchett [2009] VSCA 150.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6A.12.10
|
Amended Courtlink pro-forma conditions for family violence intervention orders.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6A.18.1
|
Significant change to wording of discussion of whether an application for interim variation of a FV intervention order may be made to an after hours magistrate.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6A.19
|
Added cases of DPP v Mahoney [2009] VSC 249 at [45]; R v Duncan [2007] VSCA 137.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6B.3.4
|
New case of R v Anders [2009] VSCA 7.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6B.3.4.5
|
New paragraph entitled “Stalking by Surveillance”. New case of R v Anders [2009] VSCA 7.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6B.8.4
|
Minor changes to pro-forma conditions for stalking intervention orders.
|
13/07/09
|
6
|
6B.15
|
Added reference to case of R v Duncan [2007] VSCA 137 at [37].
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.4.1
|
New cases of DPP (Cth) v Pasquale Barbaro [2009] VSCA 26; Angelo Venditti v R [2008] VSC 604; DPP v Leon Borthwick [2009] VSC 102; Nikola Andreevski v R/Jovan Ogrizovic v R [2009] VSC 115; Mrnjaus & Ors v R [2009] VSC 147; Garcia & Anor v R [2009] VSC 149; Ante Vucak [2009] VSC 167; R v Rich (Ruling No.19) [2008] VSC 538; DPP v Paul Dale [2009] VSC 107; Re Horty Mokbel [2008] VSC 608; DPP v Morison [2008] VSC 609; Dunne v The Queen [2009] VSC 148.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.4.2
|
New commentary on cases of Pak v R [2008] VSC 529 & Pak v R [2009] VSC 211.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.4.4
|
New cases of Kylie Vickers [2009] VSC 202; David Peter O’Blein v R [2009] VSC 6; Darren Haffner v R [2009] VSC 116; Julie Huynh [2009] VSC 163; Dalibor Dobrosavljevic [2009] VSC 170; Ahmed Chkhaidem [2009] VSC 216; Tilyard v R [2009] VSC 117; DPP v Richardson [2009] VSC 87.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.4.5
|
New case of Kylie Vickers [2009] VSC 202.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.4.10
|
New cases of DPP (Cth) v Pasquale Barbaro [2009] VSCA 26; R v Rich (Ruling No.19) [2008] VSC 538.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.5.1
|
New case of Ante Vucak [2009] VSC 167.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.5.7
|
New case of Dixon v DPP [2009] VSC 224.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
9.5.14
|
New paragraph entitled “Limited bail support program in Children’s Court”.
|
13/07/09
|
9
|
MANY
|
Replacement of “defendant” by “accused” where it occurs except in the context of a quotation.
|
23/06/09
|
3
|
3.1
|
Added quotation from Mehmet Ucar v Nylex Industrial Products Pty Ltd (2007) 17 VR 492; [2007] VSCA 181 at [43]. New case of R v Fisher [2009] VSCA 100. New references to cases of Pantorno v The Queen (1989) 166 CLR 466 at 473; Friend v Brooker [2009] HCA 21; R v Rich (Ruling No.21) [2009] VSC 32.
|
23/06/09
|
3
|
3.5.9
|
Reference to new case of R v Rich (Ruling No.5) [2008] VSC 435.
|
23/06/09
|
3
|
3.7.3
|
Reference to new case of BR v VOCAT [2009] VSC 152.
|
23/06/09
|
3
|
3.9 &
3.9.1
|
New case of NG v IP [2009] VSC 199.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.1
|
Heading of section amended to “The Child Protection Service”.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.2
|
New section entitled “Role of the Children’s Court in Child Protection in Victoria”. This section contains a “thumbnail sketch of the role of the Children’s Court in child protection in Victoria taken from a paper prepared by the President of the Court in June 2009.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.3
4.3.1
4.3.2
|
Renumbered section – formerly 4.2.
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 4.2.1
Renumbered paragraph – formerly 4.2.2
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.4
|
Heading of section changed to “Definitions of ‘child’ & ‘parent’”. The contents of former section 4.3 are incorporated into section 4.4.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.6.2
|
Heading amended to “Trends in notifications/reports 1989 to 2007/2008”. Numbers of Victorian reports in 2007-08 added. Numbers of substantiated Victorian reports from 2000-01 to 2007-08 added.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.6.3
|
Numbers of Australian notifications in 2007-08 added. Numbers of substantiated Australian notifications from 2004-05 to 2007-08 added.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.8.2
|
Commentary on ss.4 & 8 of the Evidence Act 2008 and their relationship to s.215 of the CYFA.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.8.3
|
New case of DOHS v Mr M & Ms H [11/05/2009].
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.8.4
|
New references to cases of R v Cox (Ruling No.1) [2005] VSC 157 at [11] & (Ruling No.2) [2005] VSC 224 per Kaye J; R v Rich (Ruling No.10) [2009] VSC 10 at [26]-[34] per Lasry J.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.8.5
|
New paragraph entitled “Statutory interpretation”. New case of Alinta Asset Management Pty Ltd v Essential Services Commission [2008] VSCA 273 at [70]-[83].
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.12
|
New case of DOHS v Mr M & Ms H [11/05/2009] at sections 25.1, 25.5 & 28.5.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.13
|
New case of DOHS v Mr M & Ms H [11/05/2009] at section 28.4.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.14
|
Added reference to “Contact Irregular: a qualitative analysis of the impact of visiting patterns of natural parents on foster placements”. Added references to ss.10(3)(b) & 10(3)(i) of the CYFA and to Article 9.3 in Part I of the United Convention on the Rights of the Child.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.14.1
|
New paragraph entitled “’Baby on Board’ and research cited therein.
|
09/06/09
|
4
|
4.14.2
|
New paragraph heading “Case law”.
|
08/03/09
|
5
|
5.10.1
|
New references to unreported decisions of Power M in the Children’s Court of Victoria illustrating the application of the “best interest” principle:
-
DOHS v Mr O & Ms B [20/02/2009];
-
DOHS v Mr D & Ms W [07/01/2009];
-
DOHS v Mr D & Ms B [29/09/2008];
-
DOHS v Mr G & Ms B [05/06/2008];
-
DOHS v Mr & Mrs B [17/12/2007].
|
08/03/09
|
5
|
5.15.3
|
New case of DOHS v Mr O & Ms B [Children's Court of Victoria-Power M, unreported, 20/02/2009] and commentary on s.281(2) of the CYFA.
|
08/03/09
|
5
|
5.28
|
Heading of section changed to “Interstate transfer of child protection orders and proceedings”. Discussion of the operation of Schedule 1 of the CYFA together with commentary on the case of DOHS v Mr O & Ms B [Children's Court of Victoria-Power M, unreported, 20/02/2009]. Expanded commentary on ss.334-337 of the CYFA.
|
06/03/09
|
9
|
9.4.1
|
New cases of IMO bail applications by Leanne Elizbaeth Walker & Jamiee Lee Hurle [2008] VSC 493 & 494; R v Wells [2008] VSC 29; Kent v R [2008] CSV 516; R v Maria Christina Clark [2008] VSC 606; Re James Alexander Hipworth [2007] VSC 565; Re Turner [2008] VSC 193; Pak v DPP [2008] VSC 529; Re Daniel Sazdov [2008] VSC 605.
|
06/03/09
|
9
|
9.4.4
|
New cases of Re Lawson Odlum [2008] VSC 319; Re Michael O’Connor [2008] VSC 233; Re Mae Loc Tran [2008] VSC 191; IMO bail application by Mahmoud Kheir [2008] VSC 492; Waleed Haddara v DPP [2008] VSC 298; Watts v DPP [2008] VSC 275; Re George Dickson [2008] VSC 516; R v Kelmendi [2008] VSC 31; Ferman v R [2008] VSC 612.
|
06/03/09
|
9
|
9.4.8
|
New cases of Re DBA [2008] VSCA 138 (Maxwell P & Nettle JA); Re Momsilovic [2008] VSCA 183 (Maxwell P & Weinberg JA).
Case of Re Slobodan Pandevski [2007] VSCA 84 at [17]-[22] (Maxwell ACJ & Eames JA) transferred from para. 9.4.4.
|
06/03/09
|
9
|
9.4.10
|
New case of Re George Dickson [2008] VSC 516.
|
06/03/09
|
9
|
9.5.11
|
New case of DPP v Lipp & Anor [2008] VSC 203.
|
05/03/09
|
1
|
1.3
|
Addition of s.42E to the list of sections contained in the summary describing the object of the Children’s Court (Evidence – Audio Visual and Audio Linking) Rules 1998.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.5.11
|
New paragraph entitled “Appearance or giving evidence in other than the traditional manner”.
|
New sub-paragraphs 3.5.11.1 “Appearance etc. by a person other than an accused”, 3.5.11.2 “Appearance etc. by an accused in a criminal or associated proceeding” & 3.5.11.3 “Alternative arrangements for giving evidence in certain criminal proceedings”.
|
New references to ss.37C, 37CAA, 37D, 41E, 42D to 42T of the Evidence Act 1958. References to cases of R v Cox & Ors (Ruling No.6) [2005] VSC 364 at [7], R v Kim (1998) 104 A Crim R 233, R v Weiss [2002] VSC 15, R v Goldman [2004] VSC 165; R v Strawhorn [2004] VSC 415; DPP v Finn (Ruling No.1) [2008] VSC 303.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.6
|
New section entitled “Statutory interpretation”. New case of Alinta Asset Management Pty Ltd v Essential Services Commission [2008] VSCA 273 at [70]-[83].
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.7
|
Renumbered section – formerly 3.6. Paragraphs renumbered 3.7.1, 3.7.2 & 3.7.3.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.8
|
Renumbered section – formerly 3.7.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.9
|
Renumbered section – formerly 3.8. Paragraphs renumbered 3.9.1, 3.9.2, 3.9.3 & 3.9.4.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.10
|
Renumbered section – formerly 3.9.
|
05/03/09
|
3
|
3.11
|
Renumbered section – formerly 3.10.
|
05/03/09
|
8
|
8.2.4
|
New reference to case of R v Laracy [2007] VSC 19.
|
05/03/09
|
8
|
8.4.3.2
|
New references to cases of at Reid & Tabbitt & Anor [2008] VSC 75 at [10] & [30] and O’Sullivan v Freeman [2003] VSC 45 at [19].
|
02/03/09
|
10
|
10.1
|
New offences of child homicide and defensive homicide included in the list of offences for which the Children’s Court does not have jurisdiction to hear and determine summarily.
New case of Clayton v Hall & Anor [2008] VSC 172 and a related discussion on the issue of how consent to summary jurisdiction, once given, can be withdrawn by an adult. Writer considers the same test is appropriate on the issue of withdrawal of an objection to summary jurisdiction on behalf of a child.
|
02/03/09
|
10
|
10.3.1
|
Reiteration of s.356 of the CYFA.
|
02/03/09
|
10
|
10.3.5
|
New case of R v RGG [2008] VSCA 94 at [4], [5] & [25].
|
28/02/09
|
4
|
4.1.6
|
Reference to new case of Law Institute of Victoria Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2009] VSC 55 at [19].
|
25/02/09
|
11
|
11.1.4
|
New cases of DPP v Weidlich [2008] VSCA 203; H v R & Ors [2008] VSC 369.
|
25/02/09
|
11
|
11.1.4.1
|
New sub-paragraph heading “Principle of proportionality”. New references to cases of R v Samia [2009] VSCA 5; R v McNaughton (2006) 766 NSWLR 556.
|
25/02/09
|
11
|
11.1.4.2
|
New sub-paragraph heading “Principle of totality”. New case of R v Sebborn [2008] VSCA 200 and its references to A-G v Tichy (1982) 30 SASR 84 and Johnson v R (2004) 205 ALR 346. New cases of H v R & Ors [2008] VSC 369; R v Hogan [2008] VSCA 279. References to new cases of R v Rule [2008] VSCA 154; R v Bult [2008] VSCA 227 at [22]-[24]; R v Franklin [2008] VSCA 249 at [34]-[36]; R v Rousetty [2008] VSCA 259 at [50]; R v Brown [2009] VSCA 23 at [19]-[27] & [36]-[41] {see also (2004) 10 VR 328}; R v Wright [2009] VSCA 27 at [45]-[54]; R v Samia [2009] VSCA 5 at [16]-[20].
|
25/02/09
|
|
