The International Correspondence Chess Federation 2014 Congress Sydney, Australia Table of Contents



Download 1.23 Mb.
Page12/34
Date14.07.2017
Size1.23 Mb.
#23286
1   ...   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   ...   34





Special Applications



The QC Commissioner presented 3 special applications for Congress to consider. (Note: a reminder that ICCF policy states that if an active Member Federation has not formally applied for an award of a title on behalf of a player, the title will not be awarded).

UKR


940932

Lesko, Andrei (IM)
Andrei Lesko has achieved 2 IM Norms as follows:

- 2013-12-14 WCCC36PR03 (Category 3) with 10½ out of 14.

- 2014-09-01 FINJUB-50, Semi Final, group 04 (Category 3) with at least 7 out of 10.

He is therefore fully qualified for the IM Title. Ukraine has an active CC federation, but player is not a member of NF. No application from ND, the more ND is against because of his bad behaviour.


An extended discussion took place regarding this special application. The Ukrainian delegate read a letter prepared by the President of CCFU (Mr. Koshmak) especially for this application. Mr. Koshmak presented the letter as the URK Delegate Designee:

fzshu2


ФЕДЕРАЦІЯ ЗАОЧНИХ ШАХІВ УКРАЇНИ

CORRESPONDENCE CHESS FEDERATION of UKRAINE

02222 м.Київ, пр-т Маяковcького 32, к.166. Тел. (098) 361-80-83, факс (044) 541-22-04


e-mail: fzcu.prezident@ukr.net www.ccfu.org.ua
To: President ICCF Eric Ruch
Dear mr. Eric Ruch,

Correspondence Chess Federation of Ukraine (CCFU) having great respect for the ICCF, asks to refrain from bestowing any title to Lesko, Andrei (ID 940932) and to disqualify him for the life term due to below presented facts.

Lesko, Andrei has been the member of CCFU until November 8, 2013.

Beginning from July 2013, he has started to lie away the activity of CCFU and the reputation of its leaders at various internet chess sites and in personal e-mail messages.

There is no doubt that during the same period he has made numerous hacker attacks of CCFU site www.ccfu.org.ua, cracked mailboxes of chess players, deleted accounts at internet forums, falsified e-mail messages on behalf of different chess players.

More over, beginning from this August he has started to spread misinformation about the activity of the ICCF, indicating, in particular, that the ICCF cashes in on retired persons, agitating against participation in the ICCF tournaments, etc. The above is realized by means of mass-scale personal e-mail messages.

In 2013-2014 CCFU revealed 5 cases of unauthorized tampering in the play of chess players Yeremenko(940056), Yaroshenko(511731), Koshmak(940981) Dudyev (940089), Gudok( 940097). We are sure that the above was made by Lesko.

In all cases, the TDs canceled the moves made by intruder, except for the case of Y.Yaroshenko in Slav Cup IV. As a result, our team got 4 undeserved losses, thus losing any chance to fight for medal place, due to TD’s decision not to cancel illegal moves. Our Federation made respective appeal.

Besides, we would like to focus your attention at the following facts of disgraceful and immoral behavior of A.Lesko.


  1. In 2012 in his first tournament (EU/WS/M/031) he had a conflict with Ilken Zafer (ID 490182) and got a warning.

  2. In the same year in WCCC36pr03 his opponent Eckert (ID 510672) committed a stupid 37th move leading to a loss. At first, the American player made a statement about unauthorized intrusion in the game but then changed his mind. In this tournamentA.Lesko achieved IM title.

  3. In 2013 A.Lesko deceived organizers of Dick van Geet Memorial and Silvian Zinser Memorial(B), having included himself in both tournaments instead of players nominated by our Federation. The fraud was discovered in 2 weeks and A.Lesko was excluded from both tournaments.

  4. In 2014 he hacked the site of Russian Association of Correspondence Chess (www/rcca-ru.com). Representatives of Russian Association may provide more detailed information about this.

  5. On July 12, 2013 A.Lesko presented anti-Semitic assaults against leaders of CCFU at www:Ukraine-chess. This information is still on the site.

Materials about criminal activities of A.Lesko were taken to court and law-enforcement authorities at his place of residence.
Yours sincerely,

I.Koshmak,

President of CCFU

Other official participants discussed code of conduct aspects of the case. In conclusion, although there is a preponderance of evidence against Mr. Lesko, it was determined that bad behaviour, in itself, is not cause for the withholding of a title; however, clear evidence of misconduct through intentionally altering games would be. In the end, it was decided that two votes would be taken (provisionally). The first vote would be to determine if Congress was to decide on this special application as is. If approved, the second vote would be to approve/disapprove the special application. The first vote by Congress was not to decide, i.e., postpone any decision. Nine delegates abstained from this vote, thus deciding not to vote to not vote. The voting record shows that Congress decided to postpone making a decision and will wait for further evidence of possible wrongdoing from either the Ukrainian law enforcement authorities or elsewhere.




UKR


940827

Podgursky, Artur, IM

Artur Podgursky has achieved 2 IM Norms as follows: - 2011-02-27 Vsevolod Rauzer Memorial (Category 5) with 8½ out of 12. 2011-06-07 WCCC34SF11 (Category 8) with 7 out of 12. He is therefore fully qualified for the IM Title. Application submitted by NF. Player was suspended until 2014-06-05 because of unacceptable behaviour towards an ICCF officer (3 years). However, there is no formal obstacle to award international title after penalty quarantine.


A good discussion ensured as to whether past bad behaviour was sufficient cause to prevent award of a title. It was noted that Mr. Podgursky served his two-year suspension and the quarantine period is now over.

SWE


451416

Johansson, Thomas, IM

Thomas Johansson has achieved 2 IM Norms as follows:

- 2010-10-19 Champions League 2010 C Group 2 (Category 1) with 10 out of 12.

- 2013-12-06 Champions League 2012 B2 (Category 9) with 7 out of 12.



He is therefore fully qualified for the IM Title. Sweden has an active CC federation, but player is not a member of the NF (SSKK). No application was submitted from the delegate. The delegate claimed that he was against the title because the player made very bad statements about his federation.
The delegate from Sweden spoke on this issue and clearly said it is the policy of the Swedish Federation that if a Swedish player does not join the Swedish Chess Federation (SSKK), then those players will (a) not be nominated for any ICCF titles. As a reminder to all Swedish players, the Swedish Federation will also not allow any Swedish player that has not joined the Swedish Federation to use the ICCF Direct Entry system. The delegate from Sweden strongly recommended that Congress not accept this special application.



Download 1.23 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   ...   34




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page