Cape Lookout National Seashore
Historic Resource Study
By
David E. Whisnant
and
Anne Mitchell Whisnant
Primary Source History Services
FINAL SUBMISSION
July 1, 2010
Prepared for the Organization of American Historians
under
Cooperative Agreement with the
National Park Service
Table of Contents
Table of Contents 2
2
List of Figures 3
List of Tables 9
Acknowledgments 10
Executive Summary 12
Chapter 1: An Overview of Previous Cultural Resource Studies at Cape Lookout National Seashore and Some New Analytical Possibilities 30
Chapter 2: To and from the Most Remarkable Places: The Communities of Ocracoke Inlet as North Carolina’s Gateway to an Atlantic World 85
Chapter 3: Restless (and Storm-Battered) Ribbons of Sand: Hurricanes and Inlets 153
Chapter 4: An Eye for the Possible: Maritime (and Other) Economic Activities on the Southern Banks 181
Chapter 5: At the Sea’s Edge: Slavery, Race And Class in a Maritime World 241
Chapter 6: The Government Presence: Revenue Cutters, Lighthouses, Life-Savers, Coast Guardsmen, New Dealers and Others 307
Chapter 7: From Regulators to Aviators: Wars and the Southern Banks 352
Chapter 8: Down East, Far West, and Hoi Toide: Thinking About Culture and the Outer Banks 391
Chapter 9: Outer Banks Tourism and the Coming of Cape Lookout National Seashore 426
Chapter 10: Management, Interpretive, and Research Recommendations 482
Bibliography 503
Repositories and Collections Consulted 526
Appendices 529
List of Figures
Fig. Introduction-1: Junk cars abandoned on Cape Lookout National Seashore lands
Fig. Introduction-2: Core Banks Gun Club
Fig. 1-1: Probable location of shore whaling camps
Fig. 1-2: Archeological work at shore whaling camps on Shackleford Banks
Fig. 1-3: Steamer Neuse taking on naval stores in Wilmington, 1870s
Fig. 2-1: Washington Roberts House, Portsmouth
Fig. 2-2: North Carolina’s colonial ports of entry
Fig. 2-3: Map of Ocracoke, 1795, by Jonathan Price
Fig. 2-4: North Carolina Import and Export Tonnage, 1768-1793
Fig. 2-5: John Gray Blount’s Lands North Carolina and Territory South of Ohio River 1783-1796
Fig. 2-6: Two early nineteenth century maps showing the geography of Ocracoke Inlet
Fig. 2-7: An 1897 map of Ocracoke Inlet done by the Army Corps of Engineers
Fig. 2-8: Liverpool-ware pitcher, featuring image of Shell Castle Island
Fig. 2-9: Map showing Caribbean destinations for Blount ships in the late eighteenth century
Fig. 2-10: Map of railroads and plank roads in North Carolina, 1860
Fig. 3-1: Historic Inlets of North Carolina coast
Fig. 3-2: Portsmouth Methodist Church
Fig. 3-3: Shackleford Banks after 1899 hurricane
Fig. 3-4: Selected Hurricane Tracks of the 1950s
Fig. 4-1: Location of nineteenth century windmills on North Carolina coast
Fig. 4-2: Windmill on Harkers Island ca 1904
Fig. 4-3: Thomas Chadwick whaling license, 1726
Fig. 4-4: Whale boat tools
Fig. 4-5: Whale on beach at Beaufort, before 1894
Fig. 4-6: Cutting Blubber on Shackleford Banks, 1894
Fig. 4-7: Trying Out Oil from Whale, 1894
Fig. 4-8: Shackleford Banks whaling communities, 1850-1890
Fig. 4-9: John White, “Indians Fishing” (1585-86)
Fig. 4-10: Menhaden Fishing Steamer, before 1917
Fig. 4-11: Industrial Menhaden Press, before 1917
Fig. 4-12: Menhaden Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-13: Striped or “jumping” mullet
Fig. 4-14: Camp of mullet fishermen on Shackleford Banks, before 1907
Fig. 4-15: Mullet Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-16: Shad
Fig. 4-17: Shad Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-18: Oyster Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-19: North Carolina Clam Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-20: Shrimp Production, 1887-1970
Fig. 4-21: Total pounds of fish harvested in North Carolina coastal waters, 1880-1970
Fig. 4-22: Core Sounder work boat
Fig. 4-23: De Bry Engraving of John White Drawing: The Manner of Makinge Their Boates (1585-86)
Fig. 4-24: John White, Indians Dancing Around a Circle of Posts (1585-86)
Fig. 4-25: Carteret County waterfowl hunters in sink box
Fig. 4-26: Gunners in blind, Carteret County
Fig. 4-27: “Stripping the Wreck” [before 1902]
Fig. 4-28: Attack upon Smugglers by United States Revenue Officers at Masonborough, North Carolina, 1867
Fig. 4-29: Blackbeard fights Royal Navy Lt Robert Maynard at Ocracoke Inlet, 22 November 1718
Fig. 5-1: Preserved and partly rebuilt slave cabins at Ventosa (Walter Clark home) in Halifax County, ca. 1943ovember 1718
Fig. 5-2: Great Dismal Swamp
Fig. 5-3: Negro Baptism at New Bern, ca. 1910
Fig. 5-4: Dismal Swamp Canal
Fig. 5-5: Map of Dismal Swamp Canal in 1839
Fig. 5-6: Clubfoot and Harlowe’s Creek Canal, 1839
Fig. 5-7: Wilmington turpentine distillery, ca. 1850s
Fig. 5-8: Carteret County turpentine distillery, 1876
Fig. 5-9: Freed Negroes Streaming Toward Union Lines, New Bern
Fig. 5-10: Distribution of Captured Rebels’ Clothing to Contrabands, New Bern, 1862
Fig. 5-11: Racist cartoon from Raleigh News and Observer, 30 August 1898
Fig. 5-12: North Carolina’s Womanhood Appeals to the Ballot for Protection, 13 October 1898
Fig. 5-13: A 'White Man's Party' Democrat Normal Institute in Duplin County
Fig. 5-14: Distribution of textile mills in North Carolina, 1896
Fig. 5-15: Distribution of tobacco factories in North Carolina, 1896
Fig. 5-16: Blue Eagle logo of the National Recovery Administration (NRA)
Fig. 5-17: Renovated Portsmouth school building (1927)
Fig. 5-18: Three-teacher Rosenwald School
Fig. 5-19: Logo for the Free the Wilmington Ten campaign
Fig. 5-20 Black and white mullet fishermen
Fig. 5-21: All-Black Pea Island Life-Saving Crew
Fig. 5-22: Henry Pigott at about the age of fourteen (ca. 1910)
Fig. 5-23: Henry Pigott and Walker Styron, 1955
Fig. 5-24: Gravestone of Leah Pigott (1867-1922)
Fig. 5-25: Henry Pigott house, Portsmouth
Fig. 6-1: Brick cistern, Marine Hospital, Portsmouth, 2008
Fig. 6-2: Shell Castle Lighthouse
Fig. 6-3: Orders of Fresnel lenses
Fig. 6-4: Treasury Department notification to Cape Lookout lighthouse keeper
Fig. 6-5: Life-Saving Station on the North Carolina Beach, ca. 1882
Fig. 6-6: Self-righting life-boat
Fig. 6-7: Kinnakeet Life-Saving Station
Fig. 6-8: Thomas Nast [presumably Harper’s Weekly] cartoon in wake of Huron disaster
Fig. 6-9: Outer Banks Life-Saving Stations Built 1878
Fig. 6-10: United States Life-Saving Station on the Eastern Coast.
Fig. 6-11: Outer Banks Life-Saving Stations Built 1880-1888
Fig. 6-12: Life-saving station on the North Carolina beach
Fig. 6-13: Distribution of life-saving stations on the North Carolina coast, 1905
Fig. 6-14: Lyle gun for propelling rescue lines
Fig. 6-15: Motor lifeboat, 1908
Fig. 6-16: Portsmouth Life-Saving Crew in the 1920s
Fig. 6-17: Drawing of Cape Lookout Life-Saving Station
Fig. 6-18: Cape Lookout Life-Saving Station, 1893
Fig. 6-19: Portsmouth Life-Saving Station, ca. 1903-1915
Fig. 6-20: Portsmouth Life-Saving Station in the 1920s
Fig. 6-21: Portsmouth Life-Saving Station after renovation, 2006
Fig. 6-22: Cape Lookout Coast Guard Station, 1917
Fig. 6-23: Drawing of Jesse Babb House
Fig. 6-24: Coast Guard Stations map
Fig. 6-25: North Carolina Highways, ca. 1924
Fig. 7-1: Revolutionary War Campaigns and Battles in North Carolina
Fig. 7-2: Colored troops freeing slaves in Camden County, early 1864
Fig. 7-3: Citizens of Wilmington Taking the Oath of Allegiance
Fig. 7-4: World War II Military Installations in North Carolina
Fig. 8-1: An Eminent Banker
Fig. 9-1: Mountain Sanatarium for Pulmonary Diseases
Fig. 9-2: Advertisement for Brunswick’s Atlantic Hotel, July 1877
Fig. 9-3: Train bringing beach goers from Wilmington to Wrightsville Beach, ca. 1912
Fig. 9-4: Ad for Ocean Retreat Hotel, 1841
Fig. 9-5: Nag’s Head Hotel
Fig. 9-6: The Beach at Nags Head, 1860
Fig. 9-7: Advertisement for Nags Head featuring steamers to Elizabeth City
Fig. 9-8: Principal railroad lines in North Carolina, 1890
Fig. 9-9: Map of Southern Railway system, 1895
Fig. 9-10: Cover of brochure published by Southern Railway to entice hunters to the South, 1895
Fig. 9-11: Advertisement for breech loading shotgun
Fig. 9-12: Carteret County waterfowl hunters in boat
Fig. 9-13: Pilentary Gun Club on Core Banks, December 1913
Fig. 9-14: Interpretive sign for Styron and Bragg House, Portsmouth
Fig. 9-15: Through Train to Wrightsville Beach, 1912
Fig. 9-16: Lumina, Best Dancing Pavilion on the South Atlantic Coast, ca. 1917
Fig. 9-17: Interior of Lumina dancing pavilion at night, ca. 1912
Fig. 9-18: Movies “Over the Waves” at Lumina
Fig. 9-19: Map of Wrightsville Beach showing former site of Lumina Pavilion and railroad/trolley lines that served it
Fig. 9-20: Gaskill-Guthrie House 1939
Fig. 9-21: Cape Lookout Development Company plat, 1915
Fig. 9-22: O’Boyle-Bryant house as it looked in 1939
Fig. 9-23: Cape Lookout Village as it looked in 1942
Fig. 9-24: North Carolina highways as of 1924
Fig. 9-25: Aycock Brown photograph of a bathing beauty and Cape Hatteras lighthouse
Fig. 9-26: National Park Service group embarking at Oregon Inlet for tour of the Outer Banks
Fig. 9-27: 1963 General Development Plan Map, Cape Lookout and Shackleford Banks
Fig. 9-28: Landing strip next to Portsmouth Life-Saving Station, March 2008
Fig. 9-29: Charles M. Reeves, Jr., Master Plan, Proposed Cape Lookout Development, 1964
Fig. 9-30: Antique Model A Ford modified for fishermen’s use, ca.1975
Fig. 9-31: Removing junk cars from Cape Lookout National Seashore
Fig. 10-1: Survey of Roanoke Inlet and Sound, 1829
Fig. 10-2: Historic Period Plan, Portsmouth Village, ca. 1760-1866
Fig. 10-3: Gravestone of Capt. Thomas W. Greene
Fig. 10-4: Portsmouth postmistress Annie Salter ca. 1935
Fig. 10-5: Children of Portsmouth School, 1916
Fig. 10-6: Sadie [?] and Nora Dixon, ca. 1917
Fig. 10-7: Rose Pickett gravestone
Share with your friends: |