Cdl core Files 2015-2016 cdl core Files



Download 1.69 Mb.
Page1/75
Date18.10.2016
Size1.69 Mb.
#2993
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   75

CDL Core Files 2015-2016

2015-2016


CDL Core Files
Researched by Hanna Nasser, Alix Dahl and Mike Baxter-Kauf (with contributions from Cydney Edwards, Roman Motley, Travis Ormsby, and David Song)

Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially curtail its domestic surveillance



Core Files Table of Contents 1/4

*** Stingray Affirmative 3

Stingray Affirmative Summary 4

*** Stingray Negative 29

*** National Security Letters Affirmative 40

National Security Letters Summary 41

1AC 1/6: Inherency 42

1AC 3/6: Privacy 44

1AC 5/6: Racism 46

Answers to: Crime Disadvantage 51

2AC Extensions: Privacy 53

2AC Extensions: Racism 55

*** National Security Letters Negative 57

1NC Solvency 58

1NC Racism Harms 59

1NC Privacy Harms 60

1NC Privacy Harms 61

*** Drone Affirmative 62

1AC 63

2AC Advantage Frontlines 72

2AC Inherency 73

2AC Inherency- ANSWERS TO: Obama Regulations 74

2AC Civil Liberties 75

2AC Credibility 76

2AC Innovation 77

2AC Solvency 78

ANSWERS TO: Drones Bad Disadvantage 79

2AC Drones Bad Disadvantage 80



ANSWERS TO: Ban Drones Counterplan 82

2AC Ban Drones Counterplan 83



*** Drone Negative 85

1NC Advantage Frontlines 86

1NC Inherency FRONTLINE 87

1NC Civil Liberties FRONTLINE 88

1NC Credibility FRONTLINE 90

1NC Innovation FRONTLINE 92

1NC Solvency FRONTLINE 94



2NC/1NR Advantage Frontline Extensions 95

2NC/1NR Inherency 96

2NC/1NR Civil Liberties 97

2NC/1NR Credibility 98

2NC/1NR Innovation 100

2NC/1NR Solvency 101



Advantage Frontline Extensions 102

ANSWERS TO: Inherency- Extensions 103

ANSWERS TO: Civil Liberties- Impact Framing 104

ANSWERS TO: Civil Liberties- Alternate Causalities 105

ANSWERS TO: Credibility- Global Warming Impact 106

ANSWERS TO: Credibility- Hegemony Impact 107

ANSWERS TO: Solvency- Extensions 108

Drones Bad Disadvantage 109

1NC Drones Bad Disadvantage 110



**Uniqueness- Drones Bad Disadvantage 113

2NC/1NR ANSWERS TO: Non-Unique 114

2NC/1NR Uniqueness Wall- Drones Bad Disadvantage 115

**Link- Drones Bad Disadvantage 116

2NC/1NR ANSWERS TO: No Link 117

2NC/1NR Link Wall- Drones Bad Disadvantage 118

**Impact- Drones Bad Disadvantage 120

ANSWERS TO: Drones Solve Terrorism 121

ANSWERS TO: No Impact to Terrorism 122

Ban Drones Counterplan 123

1NC Ban Drones Counterplan 124



2NC/1NR Ban Drones Counterplan 126

2NC/1NR Ban Drones COUNTERPLAN- Overview 127

2NC/1NR- ANSWERS TO: Perm Do Both 128

2NC/1NR- ANSWERS TO: No Solvency 129

2NC/1NR- ANSWERS TO: Add-On 130

**Critical Surveillance- Affirmative 132

1AC 133

2AC ANSWERS TO: Safety Disadvantage 139

2AC ANSWERS TO: Framework 140

2AC On-Case Frontline 142

**Critical Surveillance- Neg 143

1NC Framework 144

**Safety Disadvantage 147

1NC On-Case Frontline 149

***Topicality Negative 151

1NC Violations 152

**Federal Government 153

1NC Drone Surveillance- “Federal Government” Violation 154

1NC Stingray- “Federal Government” Violation 156

1NC Critical Security- “Federal Government” Violation 158

**Curtail ≠ Abolish 159

1NC Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish 160

2NC/1NR/1NR Blocks 161

**2NC/1NR/1NR Competing Interpretations 162

2NC/1NR- ANSWERS TO: Reasonability 163



***”Federal Government” Violation 164

2NC/1NR/2NR- “Federal Government”- Extensions 165

2NC/1NR/2NR- “Its”- Extensions 166

**2NC/1NR/1NR Drone Affirmative 167

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Overview 168

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Violation 169

**2NC/1NR/1NR Stingray Affirmative 170

2NC/1NR Drone Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Overview 171

2NC/1NR Stingray Affirmative- “Federal Government”- Violation 172

**2NC/1NR/1NR Critical Security Affirmative 173

2NC/1NR Critical Security Affirmative- Overview 174

2NC/1NR Critical Security Affirmative- Education DA 175

***Curtail ≠ Abolish 176

**2NC/1NR/1NR Security Letters Affirmative 177

2NC/1NR Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish – Overview 178

2NC/1NR Security Letters- Curtail ≠ Abolish – Interpretation Extensions 179

**Topicality Affirmative 180

**2AC Blocks 181

2AC- Drone Affirmative- T “Federal Government” 182

2AC- Stingray Affirmative- T “Federal Government” 183

2AC- Critical Security- T “Federal Government” 184

2AC Security Letters 185

Crime Disadvantage 186

Crime DA 1NC 187

Crime DA 1NC 188

Crime DA 1NC 189

Crime DA 1NC 190

2NC/1NR Link Extensions: General 191

2NC/1NR Extensions: National Security Letters Link 192

2NC/1NR Link Extensions - Drone Surveillance 194

2NC/1NR Uniqueness Extensions – Crime Low Now 196

2NC/1NR Impacts Turns Case - Surveillance 198

2NC/1NR Impacts Turns Case – Racism 199

2NC/1NR Impacts – Economy 200

2NC/1NR Impact – Poverty/Structural Violence 204



Crime Disadvantage Affirmative Answers 205

Non-unique: Crime High Now 206

No Link - Surveillance doesn’t reduce crime 208

Answers to: Crime Hurts Economy 210



Terrorism Disadvantage 212

2NC/1NR Extensions: National Security Letters Link 218

2NC/1NR Extension: Impact (Nuclear Terrorism) 242

Terrorism DA Affirmative Answers 263

**Elections Disadvantage Negative 280

1NC Hillary Good 281

**Uniqueness- Hillary Good 284

Uniqueness- Hillary Good- ANSWERS TO: Bernie Sanders 285

Uniqueness- Hillary Good- ANSWERS TO: Too Early 286

2NC/1NR- Uniqueness Wall- Hillary Good 287

**Link- Hillary good 289

2NC/1NR- Link Wall- Drone Affirmative 290

2NC/1NR- Link Wall- Stingray Affirmative 292

2NC/1NR- Link Wall- Security Letters Affirmative 294

**Impact- Hillary Good 295

2NC/1NR Impact- Hillary Good- ANSWERS TO: Hillary Bad- Iran 296

2NC/1NR Impact- Hillary Good- ANSWERS TO: Hillary Bad- Economy 297

**Elections Disadvantage Affirmative 299

**2AC Blocks 300

2AC Hillary Good- Link Turn Strategy 301

2AC Hillary Good – Impact Turn Strategy 305

**A2- Hillary Good- No Link 308

2AC Hillary Good- Drone Affirmative- No Link 309

2AC Hillary Good- Stingray Affirmative- No Link 310

2AC Hillary Good- Security Letters - No Link 311



**States COUNTERPLAN Negative 312

1NC States Counterplan 313

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Overview 314

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Drone Aff 315

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Security Letters 316

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency- Stingray Affirmative 317

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- ANSWERS TO: Permutation 319

2NC/1NR- States COUNTERPLAN- ANSWERS TO: Fifty State Fiat Bad 320

**States COUNTERPLAN Affirmative 321

2AC- States Counterplan 322

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Drone Affirmative 324

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Security Letters Affirmative 325

2AC- States COUNTERPLAN- Solvency Deficit- Stingray Affirmative 326



**CISA DISADVANTAGE Negative 327

1NC- CISA DISADVANTAGE 328

**Uniqueness 333

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Uniqueness Wall 334



**Link 336

2NC/1NR – CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Drone Affirmative 337

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Stingray Affirmative 339

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Wall- Security Letters 341



**Internal Link 343

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Internal Link- ANSWERS TO: No Spillover 344



**Impact 345

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- ANSWERS TO: Economic Decline /= War 346

2NC/1NR- CISA DISADVANTAGE- ANSWERS TO: CISA Good 347

**CISA DISADVANTAGE Affirmative 349

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Link Turn Strategy 350

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Impact Turn Strategy 353

2AC- CISA DISADVANTAGE- Drone Affirmative- No Link/Link Turn 355






Download 1.69 Mb.

Share with your friends:
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   75




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2022
send message

    Main page