Tournament of Champions 2k8 Comprehensive Caselist
Bellarmine DR – Affirmative – MEDFLAGS
Download 2.81 Mb.
|
- Navigate this page:
- Politics Link Turns
Bellarmine DR – Affirmative – MEDFLAGSContention 1 – the Status Quo A MEDFLAG was recently deployed to Nigeria Melancon 2006 [Dave, Special to American Forces Press Service, “Medflag ’06 clinics see 2,000 beninese patients,” September 19] Medical Task Force...Ghana and Senegal. However a lack of long-term commitment and follow-up procedures prevents efficacy Pruden 2006 [Paul W., Lieutenant Commander, Medical Service Corps, United States Navy, “Should Medical Humanitarian and Civic Assistance Activities Focus on Building Public Health Capacity in Africa to Better Influence Theater Security Cooperation Objectives?” 2/13]
Thus the Plan: The United States Department of Defense should establish a prolonged Medical Conflagration exercise with follow-up protocol in the Federal Republic of Nigeria. Contention 2 – Hegemony First, A US military presence in Africa is inevitable Berrigan 10/6 [Frida, “The New Military Frontier: Africa,” 2007] Most Americans have...human rights abuses. Scenario 1 is Nigerian instability – The country is on the verge of collapse Pham 2007 [J. Peter Ph.D., World Defense Review columnist, “Decision Time in Nigeria,” Strategic Interest, April 19]
And this would force the hand of America, necessitating large-scale military intervention Kern 2006 [Soren, Senior Analyst, the US and Transatlantic Dialogue, Elcano Royal Insitutute, “How the Demand for Oil Drivers American Foreign Policy,” June 23]
And humanitarian interventions devastate military readiness Spencer 2K [Jack, Policy Analyst – Heritage Foundation, “The Facts About Military Readiness”, 9-15]
Scenario 2 is basing – Nigeria is moving to block a US lily pad in the Gulf of Guinea – suspicions of American motives abound Taiwo 9/14 [Juliana, “Nigeria Moves to Halt US Military,” This Day Online, 2007]
Halvorsen 2005 [Lieutenant Peter, US Naval Institute Proceedings, “Making a Case for Naval Lily Pads,” Vol. 131, Issue 3, March 20, p. 84-86, Proquest] Ongoing U.S. military...in the region. And hegemony is the gateway for all positive externalities – a world of primacy is comparatively a world of stability Thayer 2006 [Bradley, professor of security studies at Missouri State, The National Interest, “In Defense of Primacy”, December, p. 32-37]
Contention 3 – Bird Flu First, a global avian pandemic is inevitable and imminent Chicago Daily Herald 2006 [August 21, “Expert: Massive Flu Pandemic Is Imminent”] Sometime in the...kind of transmission. And Nigeria is the new hot spot – mutations are on the brink CNN 2006 [“Nigeria fights bird flu with blunt knives, bare hands,’ February 17]
We’ll isolate 2 impacts – First, an avian pandemic would kill half the world in days Barnes 2005 [Ethne, Research Assistant in Paleopathology, Wichita State, 2005, Disease and human evolution, p 427-8]
Second, an avian pandemic collapses the global economy Branswell 2005 [Helen Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, http://www.cbc.ca/cp/business/050816/b081692.html]
And that causes extinction Beardon 2K (TE, Director, Association of Distinguished American Scientists, 'The Unnecessary Energy Crisis", 6-24)
Contention 4 – Solvency A MEDFLAG operation would stabilize Nigerian public health capacity, reducing the probability of otherwise inevitable larger U.S. interventions Fox 1998 [C. William, M.D., Command Surgeon – Joint Readiness Training Center, “Phantom Warriors”, Parameters, Winter] The absence of...to such challenges. And MEDFLAGs resonate with African governments and generate goodwill that spills over Henk 1998 (Dan, member of USAF Institute for National Security Studies and professor of African Affairs at USMA/Army War College, March, “Uncharted Paths, Uncertain Vision: US Military Involvements in sub-Saharan Africa in the Wake of the Cold War,” March]
Sisk 1996 [Timothy, Brookings Institute Program Officer, “Future U.S. Engagement in Africa. Opportunities and Obstacles for Conflict Management,” July] Several participants suggested...internationally acceptable behavior. And a MEDFLAG would provide crucial health assistance for preventing a bird flu outbreak in Nigeria Campbell 2006 (John, US AMB Nigeria, http://abuja.usembassy.gov/sp_09042006.html)
And an expanded MEDFLAG is a uniquely effective way to spur coordinated approaches to public health Fox 1998 [C. William, M.D., Command Surgeon – Joint Readiness Training Center, “Phantom Warriors”, Parameters, Winter, http://www.carlisle.army.mil/USAWC/PARAMETERS/97winter/fox.htm]
MEDFLAGs cost political capital – partisanship and bureaucracy needs to be pushed to consider “out of area” operations Center for Democracy and Development 1999 [“Conference Report: COLLECTIVE REGIONAL SECURITY IN WEST AFRICA”] In her contribution... among policy makers. Country focus – selecting the host country triggers political battles Carroll 2001 (Colonel Terry, “Engagement or Marriage: The Case for an Expanded Military Medical Role in Africa”, Army War College Strategy Report) More basically, the...our African investment MEDFLAGs cost political capital Carroll 2001 (Colonel Terry, “Engagement or Marriage: The Case for an Expanded Military Medical Role in Africa”, Army War College Strategy Report) We’ve seen... the world’s children. Military medical funding is empirically popular in congress Quigley 2005 (Samantha , "Military Surgeons General Applaud Congress for Helping Advance Care", May 11, http://www.defenselink.mil/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=31678) Military surgeons general.. document that personally." Aid to Nigeria is popular – perceived as stabilizing and contributing to democracy House Committee on Foreign Affairs 2007 (“Lantos, Key Members of Foreign Affairs Committee Urge Nigerian Government to Conduct Free, Fair and Peaceful Elections.”) Chairman Tom Lantos...for all Nigerians.” Bird flu prevention is bipartisan International Herald Tribune 2005 [June 7] At the moment... ability to act. Directory: file -> view view -> Western Europe after wwii view -> Author study: paul fleischman view -> Qpa1 7ela study Guide view -> Arctic Oil/Gas Neg view -> November 1970 Approximately 150,000-500,000 deaths Bhola Cyclone Bangladesh view -> Grade Level: 6 Unit of Study: Caribbean glce view -> Citation: Duffield, Katy view -> Table of Contents Lesson # view -> Chinese Wind Energy Disad Download 2.81 Mb. Share with your friends:
|