§ 781)
Venue is the District Court where the ship is and if it is outside territorial waters it is where the Π is.
Suits in Admiralty Act (SAA) Applies to cases (1) where the government vessels and cargo are involved and (2) in cases where if a private person or property were involved, a proceeding in admiralty could be maintained (§§ 742, 743)
Has a 2 year Statute of Limitations
Defenses to Sovereign Immunity
Discretionary Function Exception Government cannot be liable where it gave an agency discretion do something and they exercised discretion negligently
Discretion Is there a statute, regulation, or even silence granting agency discretion
Conduct has to be susceptible to public policy analysis
Conduct of kind that would be evaluated (i.e. navigation aids)
Meant to be in the discretion and policy decisions of the US
Statute of Limitations Has Tolled while Agency Acts
General Average and Salvage General Average Definition
Principle of law in which all parties in a sea venture PROPORTIONALLY share any losses resulting from a voluntary sacrifice of part of the ship or cargo to save the whole in an emergency!
Elements
Peril must endanger both vessel and cargo
The Blackwall Judicial set of criteria to determine what the measure of salvage will be
Courts will look at your effort and determine the amount of salvage you should get based on elements of
Degree of Danger salvage property is rescued from
Salvage Property’s Value
Risk incurred by the Salvors
Salvor’s Promptness, Skill, and Energy
Degree of Skill used by the Slaver to save the vessel (property)
Time and Labor
Statistical Time that took the salvage of the vessel
Value of Salvor’s Propety at Risk
Value of the property that the salver put at risk to save other party’s property
Another factor a Salvor can collect form is for preventing or minimizing damage to the environment
Contractual Salvage negotiated ahead of time
It doesn’t matter if anything of the vessel was saved at all
Flagship Marine Services Implied Salvage Contract was created
One party asked “what will you charge me” and the other answered “we will worry about it later”
This constituted a contract for salvage and prohibited Flagship from recovering under the Voluntary/Pure Rule
Workers Injuries: Maritime Workers Longshoremen Northeast Marine Longshoreman Have to be (1) doing at least quasi-traditional maritime activity (2) near or on navigable waters
Situs Near or on Navigable Waters
Status Doing Quasi-Maritime Activity
LHWCA (Longshore and Harbor Worker’s Compensation Act)
You get 1/3 to 2/3 of your working wage plus cure for medical expenses
Way more than Jones Act Seaman ($22 a day)
CANNOT sue an employer with LHWCA insurance
The only party a longshoreman can sue is the owner of the vessel
Owner CANNOT seek indemnification from the employer even though the employer has a maritime lien that encompasses medical and lost wages
905(b) Actions Against Third Parties Reynolds If you are a maritime worker and (1) your primary purpose is NOT to further the function of the vessel, and (2) you do not spend more than 40% of the time at sea then you are NOT a seaman
If you are a maritime worker who is not a seaman then you are a longshoreman
Hullinghorst Industries If your employee is considered a maritime employee (longshoreman) within the meaning of LHWCA then you are a company that employs longshoreman
Three Duties of Ship Owner to Longshoremen –Scindia!
Turnover Duty to Warn If there is a hidden problem that the average person would not be able to figure out, the ship owner must warn of this to make sure the charter knows about it
Narrowly interpreted
Latent Defects and not Patent Defects are covered because Longshoreman is an expert.
Active Operations/Control If the ship owner actively participates in managing the operations of the charter, then the ship owner has a duty to keep workers safe
Duty to Intervene If the ship owner sees something unsafe happening or if the stevedore is going something that is unsafe, then the ship owner MUST stop it
Insurance Marine insurance should be governed by federal admiralty law provided that there is a well-settled applicable federal statute
Hull Policy Protection against loss or damage to owner’s vessel, not for damages to third parties
At the beginning of the policy the parties come to an agreement as to the value of the vessel
The total value loss will be met if repairs pass the agreed amount
P & I Policy Protection Indemnity
Provides liability insurance for people when they come on the vessel
Covers death, injury, collision, damage to other vessels, and certain shore-side installations, cost of wreck removal, and loss of cargo.
LHWCA Only protects the employer of longshoremen