Reordering of material in this paragraph. New case of Mansbridge v Nichols & Anor [2004] VSC 530 at [32]-[33] and its citations from Perkins v County Court of Victoria (2000) 2 VR 246.
|
10/02/05
|
7
|
7.6.4
|
New material on amending charges. References to s.50 Magistrates' Court Act 1989 and to the cases of Kennett v Holt [1974] VR 644; Thomson v Lee [1935] VLR 360 & Ciorra v Cole [2004] VSC 416.
|
10/02/05
|
8
|
8.2
|
New cases of R v Marks [2004] VSC 476, R v Mohammed (Ruling) [2004] VSC 408 & R v Hassan [2004] VSC 85.
|
10/02/05
|
10
|
10.2
|
New sub-headings in relation to Committal proceedings: 10.2.1 Purpose 10.2.2 Nature 10.2.3 Test 10.2.4 "Basha" inquiry
|
10/02/05
|
10
|
10.2.1
10.2.4
|
New case of Williams, Brincat and Traglia v DPP [2004] VSC 516.
|
10/02/05
|
10
|
10.2.2
|
Reference to case of Henderson v The Magistrates' Court of Victoria [2004] VSC 544.
|
10/02/05
|
10
|
10.3.4
|
New paragraph entitled "Duplicity, Uncertainty & Unanimity". Reference to cases of R v Walsh [2002] VSCA 98, Mainsbridge v Nichols & Anor [2004] VSC 530, R v Ginies [1972] VR 49 at 400 and Romeyko v Samuels (1972) 2 SASR 529 at 552..
|
10/02/05
|
10
|
10.3.5
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 10.3.4.
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.4.1
|
New references to cases of DPP v Tong [2000] VSC 451, Re Moloney [SCV-Vincent J, 31/10/1990]; Nicola Docmanov [SCV-Hampel J, 13/05/1998]; Michael Sullivan [SCV-Young CJ, 11/02/1983].
New cases of MacDonald v DPP [2004] VSC 431; DPP v Waters [2004] VSC 303; Tran v DPP [2004] VSC 296; Re Michael Barbaro [2004] VSC 404.
Added references to the Western Australian cases of Fawcett v R [2002] WASC 285; Outman v R [2000] WASC 303 & Pinkston v R (2000) 119 A Crim R 462.
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.4.3
|
New cases of DPP v Waters [2004] VSC 303; Azzopardi [SCV-Gillard J, 23/07/2003].
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.4.4
|
Additional material included in relation to the cases of Michael Kanfouche [SCV-Smith J, 04/04/1991]; R v Ilsley [2003] VSC 332; Harry Buckle [2003] VSC 352; Ian David Peter Dauer [SCV-Nathan J, 23/02/1985].
New cases of Williamson v DPP (Qld) [1999] QCA 356; DPP v Stewart [2004] VSC 405; DPP v Nathan Fallon [2001] VSC 136; DPP v Hop Nguyen [2004] VSC 302; Wiiliam Archibald Smith [SCV-Coldrey J, 25/03/1997]; Dorothy Marie Skura [2003] VSC 207; Mario Rocco Condello [2004] VSC 409;
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.4.8
|
New paragraph entitled "Bail pending appeal against conviction or sentence". Reference to cl.4(2) sch.6 of the Magistrates' Court Act 1989. References to cases of Chamberlain v R [No 1] (1983) 153 CLR 514 at 519]; R v Quoc Kinh Phung [2001] VSCA 81; Kathleen MacBain v DPP [200[2004] VSCA 32; 2] VSC 321; Re Pinkstone's Application [2003] HCA 46;
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.5.1
|
New cases of Re Michael Barbaro [2004] VSC 404; DPP v Yaakov Shentzer [2002] VSC 217.
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.5.5
|
New reference to case of DPP v Harika [2002] VSC 237.
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.5.6
|
Added references to cases of Mokbel v DPP [No 1] [2002] VSC 127 & Mokbel v DPP [No 2] [2002] VSC 312.
|
24/01/05
|
9
|
9.5.8
|
Added case of R v Fernandez [2002] VSCA 115.
|
21/01/05
|
10
|
10.3.4
|
Added case of R v Beary [2004] VSCA 229 at [11]-[14] disapproving dicta in R v Carver [Court of Appeal, unreported, 03/06/1996].
|
17/01/05
|
3
|
3.1
|
Added references to text & cases involving bias/apprehended bias.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.1.4
|
Added case of R v Jongsma [2004] VSCA 218. Added commentary on the sentencing principles of proportionality and totality, plus references to cases including Veen v The Queen [No.1] (1979) 143 CLR 458; Veen v The Queen [No 2] (1988) 164 CLR 465; DPP v Grabovac [1998] 1 VR 664; R v Izzard (2004) 7 VR 480; R v MDB [2003] VSCA 181.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.1.8
|
New case of DPP v Esso Australia Pty Ltd [2004] VSC 440.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.1
|
New cases of R v Hennen [2004] VSCA 42; R v Lawrence [2004] VSCA 154; R v PSJ [2004] VSC 502.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.4
|
New case of R v Sa [2004] VSCA 182.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.6
|
Added cases of Lovelock v The Queen (1978) 33 FLR 132; R v Merceica [2004] VSCA 170; R v QMN; R v WD [2004] VSCA 32; R v Gleenslade [2004] VSCA 213.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.7
|
New case of DPP v Collins [2004] VSCA 172. New reference to case of Pearce v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 610. New references to a large number of cases on "double punishment" including R v Langdon [2004] VSCA 205; R v Ly & Others [2004] VSCA 45; R v Zaydan & Others [2004] VSCA 245.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.8
|
New cases of R v Tasker & Tasker (2003) 7 VR 128; R v Ly [2004] VSCA 45; R v Taing [2004] VSCA 46; R v Kittikhoun [2004] VSCA 194; R v Makin [2004] VSC 485; R v Nikojdevic [2004] VSCA 222; R v QMN; R v WD [2004] VSCA 32; R v Pividor & Dale [2002] VSCA 174.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.9
|
New case of R v Sa [2004] VSCA 182.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.10
|
New cases of R v Izzard (2004) 7 VR 480; R v McDonald [2004] VSCA 186.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.11
|
New case of R v Rajinder Kumar [2004] VSC 527.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.12
|
New paragraph entitled "Effect of delay".
New cases of R v Nikodjevic [2004] VSCA 222; R v MWH [2001] VSCA 196. New references to cases of R v Miceli [1998] 4 VR 588; R v Cockerell (2001) A Crim R 444; R v Todd [1982] 2 NSWLR 517; Mill v The Queen (1988) 166 CLR 59.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.13
|
Former paragraph 11.2.13 entitled "Method of accumulation of sentences of detention" has been deleted and the contents added to an expanded paragraph 11.1.4.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.13
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.12.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.14
|
New paragraph entitled "Relevance of hardship on offender's family". New cases of R v Michael Close [2004] VSCA 188; R v Roberta Williams [2004] VSC 429. Reference to R v Stanisavljevic [2004] VSCA 144.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.15
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.14. Change of title to "Sentencing for manslaughter / causing injury".
Added cases of R v Stavreski [2004] VSC 16; R v Winter [2004] VSC 329; R v Sherman Calvin White [2004] VSC 428; R v Paul Jedson [2004] VSC 345; R v Close [2004] VSCA 188.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.16
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.15.
New cases of R v Paul Harold Walker [2004] VSC 412; R v Carl Williams & Walter Foletti [2004] VSC 424; R v Pablo Foletti [2004] VSC 277; R v Chinh Quang Do [2004] VSC 203; R v Burgess [2004] VSCA 187.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.2.17
|
New paragraph entitled "Sentencing for armed robbery".
New cases of R v Kittikhoun [2004] VSCA 194; DPP v Gardner & Coates [2004] VSCA 119; R v Winslett [2004] VSC 426; R v Roy {2001] VSCA 61; R v Cotry [2002[ VSCA 13; R v Pratt [2003] VSCA 186.
|
17/01/05
|
11
|
11.3
|
New case of Le v Collins & Anor [2004] VSC 524.
|
20/08/04
|
5
|
5.8.6
|
Added reference to case of DPP v Haidy [2004] VSC 247 as an analogy for the test of unacceptable risk of harm to child.
|
20/08/04
|
5
|
5.19
|
Added reference to case of DPP v Haidy [2004] VSC 247 as an analogy for the test of unacceptable risk of harm to child.
|
20/08/04
|
9
|
9.4.4
|
New case of DPP v Haidy [2004] VSC 247 re test of unacceptable risk.
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.1
|
Reference to new case of R v Huynh & Others [2004] VSCA 128 at [47] & [50].
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.11
|
New paragraph entitled "Effect of intellectual disability". References to cases R v Williams [2000] VSCA 174; R v Roadley (1990) 51 A Crim R 336; R v Bux [2002] VSCA 126 & R v Ulla [2004] VSCA 130.
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.12
|
New paragraph entitled "Relevance of gambling addiction". Reference to case R v Huynh & Others [2004] VSCA 128 at [58].
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.13
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.11.
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.14
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.12.
|
20/08/04
|
11
|
11.2.15
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.13.
|
30/06/04
|
2
|
2.7
|
New cases of Herald & Weekly Times Ltd v Magistrates' Court of Victoria [2004] VSC 194; R v Goldman [2004] VSC 167 and DPP v Carl Williams & Ors [2004] VSC 209.
|
30/06/04
|
3
|
3.5.6
|
New case of R v Parsons & Stocker [2004] VSCA 92.
|
30/06/04
|
11
|
11.1.9
|
Added reference to the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) and the cases of R v Tran [2004] VSC 218; R v Galek (1993) 70 A Crim R 252 at 258; R v Wealand (2002) A Crim R 159; Taylor v Attorney General of South Australia (1991) 53 A Crim R 166 at 175-179.
|
30/06/04
|
11
|
11.2.7
|
New cases of R v Gruber, Ridgeway & Rowley [2004] VSCA 100 and R v El-Kotob (2002) 4 VR 546.
|
30/06/04
|
11
|
11.2.8
|
New case of DPP v Bennett [2004] VSC 207.
|
30/06/04
|
11
|
11.2.10
|
New cases of R v Sebalj [2004] VSC 212; R v Hill [2004] VSCA 116; R v Rendle [2004] VSC 201; R v Hasan Huseyin Alipek & Jason Maxwell Saltmarsh [2004] VSC 206.
|
30/06/04
|
11
|
11.2.12
|
New case of R v Pollock [2004] VSC 189.
|
31/05/04
|
2
|
2.5
|
Added reference to R v Goldman [2004] VSC 165 where Redlich J traced the genesis of Part IIA of the Evidence Act relating to the use of audio-visual & audio links.
|
31/05/04
|
3
|
3.5.5
|
Added reference to R v NRC [1999] 3 VR 537 in relation to use of VATE tapes in contested criminal proceedings.
|
31/05/04
|
3
|
3.8.1
|
New case of Jandreoski and Ors v Colley and Ors [2004] VSC 131 re costs of a successful defendant in criminal proceedings.
|
31/05/04
|
5
|
5.8.1
|
References to P v RM & Ors [2004] VSC 14 and DOHS v W [Children's Court of Victoria, unreported, 20/04/2004] added.
|
31/05/04
|
5
|
5.8.6
|
New case of DOHS v W [Children's Court of Victoria, unreported, 20/04/2004] setting out matters to which the Court must have regard in determining IAO applications.
|
31/05/04
|
5
|
5.8.11
|
New case of DOHS v W [Children's Court of Victoria, unreported, 20/04/2004] in which it was held that an order made after a submissions contest is not to be treated as establishing a status quo in favour of the successful party.
|
31/05/04
|
5
|
5.20.1
|
Correct incorrect reference to s.120.
|
31/05/04
|
9
|
9.2.2
|
Note the repeal as and from 18/05/2004 of s.4(2)(c) which formerly provided that bail shall be refused if the accused person is in custody for failing to answer bail unless the accused person satisfies the court that the failure was due to causes beyond his/her control.
|
31/05/04
|
10
|
10.3.3
|
New paragraph entitled "Plea agreements". Reference to decision of the High Court in GAS v The Queen; SJK v The Queen [2004] HCA 22 at [28]-[32] & [42]-[44].
|
31/05/04
|
10
|
10.3.4
|
New paragraph entitled "Rolled up counts". Reference to R v Jones [2004] VSCA 68 at [13].
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.1
|
Reference to decision of the High Court in GAS v The Queen; SJK v The Queen [2004] HCA 22 dismissing an appeal against a sentence imposed by the Court of Appeal.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.4
|
New case of R v Saw [2004] VSC 117 at [14].
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.8
|
New paragraph entitled "Effect of guilty plea and/or assistance to the authorities". References to cases of R v Duncan [1998] 3 VR 208 at 214-215, R v Saw [2004] VSC 117 at [36] and a number of other cases.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.9
|
New paragraph entitled "Effect of forgiveness of victim". References to cases R v Skura [2004] VSCA 53 and R v Wise [2004] VSCA 88.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.10
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.8.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.10
|
New cases of R v Saw [2004] VSC 117, R v Bendix [2004] VSC 133 & R v Smith [2004] VSC 134. New case of R v Skura [2004] VSCA 53 at [7]-[8], [27] & [33] re relevance to sentencing of personality disorder.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.11
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.9.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.12
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.10.
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.12
|
Added reference to decision of the High Court in GAS v The Queen; SJK v The Queen [2004] HCA 22 at [19]-[20].
|
31/05/04
|
11
|
11.2.13
|
Renumbered paragraph - formerly 11.2.11.
|
28/03/04
|
7
|
7.6.4
|
References added to DPP v Diamond [2004] VSC 35 & Nitz v Evans (1993) 19 MVR 55 on issues relating to issue and service of summons.
|
28/03/04
|
8
|
8.2.11
|
New case of Kelly v The Queen [2004] HCA 12 in relation to the Tasmanian equivalent of s.464H of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) [as amended].
|
28/03/04
|
9
|
9.4.1
|
Note of outcome of bail application in R v Strawhorn (Bolger M, 15/03/2004). New case of Ismail Muhaidat [2004] VSC 17 - bail refused: no exceptional circumstances.
|
28/03/04
|
11
|
11.2.1
|
New cases of R v McConkey [No 2] [2004] VSCA 26 & |
