Article Review Structure and Format Guidelines


Issues (listed by the author)



Download 46.5 Kb.
Page5/5
Date16.02.2023
Size46.5 Kb.
#60671
1   2   3   4   5
article-review-format

8. Issues (listed by the author)


What open questions or issues has the author stated remain unresolved? Discuss each in a separate paragraph of 5-10 sentences. Each issue's paragraph should take the following format:

  • what is the issue?

  • why do you believe this is an important issue?

  • in what way is it unresolved

  • suggestions for resolving it - if you give your own suggestions (instead of or in addition to the authors', then precede each with "I would propose ..." If it has been resolved since the article was written, then state how it was resolved.

Note: If you have any critiques in this section, they most likely belong in the General Critique section instead.

9. Issues (in your opinion)


List several open questions or issues which remain unresolved in your opinion? For example, what possible future research questions could arise from this article? Discuss each in a separate paragraph of 5-10 sentences. Each issue's paragraph should take the following format:

  • what is the issue?

  • why do you believe this is an important issue?

  • in what way is it unresolved

  • suggestions for resolving it

Note: If you have any critiques in this section, they most likely belong in the General Critique section instead.

10. Questions


List three insightful questions of your own, arising from this article. Do not ask definitions, but rather questions that really make one think.

11. Annotated Bibliography


For every item you have cited in your report, you need a full reference and an annotation explaining it. This includes references to any class materials, as well as the three additional citations utilized in sections 6-14.

  1. List the full bibliographic references (authors, title, journal name, volume, issue, year, page numbers, etc.) for anything you have cited in your review.
    IMPORTANT: This is NOT the bibliography listed at the end of the article. It is the bibliographic references for any readings you yourself referred to inside your review.

  2. Write 2-4 sentences describing the article.

  3. Write 2-3 sentences describing why you cited it.

Also, be sure that you have included a bibliographic marker to each (such as [Bieber & Smith, 2001]) in the text of your review.
Download 46.5 Kb.

Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page