Chapter 1: Property as rights, not thing


Title Proof and registration



Download 1.21 Mb.
Page19/29
Date19.10.2016
Size1.21 Mb.
#4405
1   ...   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   ...   29

Title Proof and registration


  • Main idea of common law property was to keep it in the family – so common law rules of transferring property were difficult. A deed is the creation, transfer, or surrender of interests in land to be made in writing.

  • To avoid fraud, in theory each transaction had to be accounted back to an original grant from the Crown.

    • In the UK, common law required 60 years of unbroken chain of title traced to a document that on it’s face dealt with the whole legal (and equitable) estate. This is called good root title.

    • A purchaser only has to go back as far as is required by the statute of limitations.

    • (Cf. Breathing New life into dead Capital)

Registration of Deed or Registry System: Exists in UK and parts of Canada. Provides a public register of deeds and other “instruments” (documents which record transfer of rights) affecting the land. Fraud and mistakes do happen (ex. Vendor sells something to which he actually did not have legal title to sell).
Title Registration, Land Titles, or Torrens System: A certificate is registered by the government, which is then guaranteed by the government. This becomes “the truth.” Indefeasibility of title: as if on each registration the government issues a new clean title with is said to draw a curtain on all past dealings. There is in theory a state sponsored insurance fund that people can claim if a earlier unregistered claim has been defeated by registration, or if a previously wrongly ousted owner is ousted by new registration (Fraud will still re-instate the original owner, which is an exception to the system). Applies in Ontario, and now also NB and NS.
BC Statute of Frauds (1960): s. 2(1) Agreements concerning interest in land are enforceable by action only in writing. (2) All creations, assignments, surrender of interests must be in writing. (3) The above does not apply to lease of an interest in land for three years or less. S. 3. Trust property assignments/surrender must be held in writing.
Real Property Act (Manitoba): All instruments to pass interest in land under a the new system must be registered.
Land Titles Act (Ontario) 1990: The first person to register under the Act is registered fee simple with all rights and interests, and free from all previous rights and interests except: (1) encumbrances, (2) liabilities (3) if the registered owner is not entitled for the owner’s benefit to the land, then any unregistered estates, rights, interests, or equities to which a person is entitled.
Land Title Act (BC): 20(1) Unregistered instrument does not pass estate unless: 20(1) except as against the person making it is registered in compliance with this Act. (2) everyone person benefitted and every person claiming through or under a person benefited, whether by descent, purchase or otherwise, the right (a) to apply to have the instrument registered, and (b) in incidental or auxiliary proceedings to registration, to use the name of all parties to the instrument (whether or not a party has since died or become legally incapacitated) (3) Subsection (1) does not apply to lease for a term exceeding 3 years.


Jeanne L Schroeder, Chix nix bundle o stix: a feminist critique of the disaggregation of property. 1994. P437.

An example of how complex property rights exist. Historically, and estate was comprised of different persons holding various property rights with respect to a given price of realty. This hasn’t changed.
Setting: A condo owner in a NYC high rise.

  1. Hudson Mews Apartment corp owns the equity in the building and land.

  2. A bank holds their mortgage.

  3. Time warner cable television

  4. Ny telephone

  5. Conedison

  6. Us postal service, have easements to enter into the premises

  7. Corporation has rights of access to hook up water lines

  8. Use of land is subject to state and city restrictions and regulations

  9. Corporation also has a right of way on a narrow strip of land owned by someone else

  10. She owns shares, 625

  11. She is a lessee of a proprietary lease

  12. She has a mortgage with S & L

  13. Corp has security interests in her rights

  14. Corp has intercreditor agreement with her S&L

  15. Her right to alienate shares is subject to the bylaws of the corp and security agreement with the S&L

  16. There are some sublets

  17. Corp granted certain rights to SH and lessees for use of common areas and RoW

  18. Each tenant has exclusive privilege to use a portion of the basement for storage

  19. The corp leases the basement to the superintendant whose lease is coterminous with his employment.

  20. Etc…



Chapter 6 - Easements


Intro/Re-cap:

How Cartography has shaped our understanding of land.

Easements admit troubled uses and shapes of land, that doesn’t conform to the modern rectangle.

Easements sit at the boundary of contract and property.

Runs with the land and burdens the owner

May be paid for initially, may result in a diminution of the value of land.

Relationship to full-blooded owner – when the easement is such a burden to the true owner that the easement is held to not exist.

Culturally determined? How



Relationship to adverse possession – both parties are recognizing that the serviant land owner is not trying to gain ownership, just has a right of use, not trying to exclude the owners,
Introduction

  • Class of rights in land known as “incorporeal hereditaments” or “servitudes”

  • It is the right of one owner to go on the land of another and make some kind of limited use of it (e.g. like a servitude in CVL)

  • Not a natural right doesn’t come with a fee simple and must be created as part of the relationship b/w the 2 landowners (most common easement is a right of way created by express agreement)

  • If an easement is of valid content and has been validly created, it will run with the land (be part of the title) and be available to each successor owner, independently of his identity.

  • Doesn’t attach to person but to the land.

  • Important to distinguish between a contract and an easement: If particular right created by initial K is an easement, it becomes part of the title, part of the fee simple that each successor owner has, it has an existence independent of the identity of the owner of the land at any given time.


Download 1.21 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   ...   29




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page