Draft regulation Impact Statement for Underrun Protection a draft statement inviting discussion and comments from parties affected by the proposed heavy commercial vehicle safety initiative January 2007 Report Documentation Page



Download 5.27 Mb.
Page37/50
Date05.05.2018
Size5.27 Mb.
#47808
1   ...   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   ...   50

Scenario B1



Rigid Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$14,910,553

$4,266,944

3.494

 

$3,155,691

$6,140,292

0.514

 

$1,912,613

$7,496,245

0.2551

10

5%

0.4000

$14,234,523

$4,266,944

3.336

 

$3,012,615

$6,140,292

0.491

 

$1,825,897

$7,496,245

0.2436

10

6%

0.3823

$13,606,235

$4,266,944

3.189

 

$2,879,643

$6,140,292

0.469

 

$1,745,305

$7,496,245

0.2328

10

7%

0.3659

$13,021,570

$4,266,944

3.052

 

$2,755,904

$6,140,292

0.449

 

$1,670,309

$7,496,245

0.2228

10

12%

0.2988

$10,634,561

$4,266,944

2.492

 

$2,250,714

$6,140,292

0.367

 

$1,364,121

$7,496,245

0.1820

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$20,531,446

$4,266,944

4.812

 

$4,345,305

$6,140,292

0.708

 

$2,633,619

$7,496,245

0.3513

15

5%

0.5396

$19,204,027

$4,266,944

4.501

 

$4,064,368

$6,140,292

0.662

 

$2,463,348

$7,496,245

0.3286

15

6%

0.5059

$18,005,757

$4,266,944

4.220

 

$3,810,764

$6,140,292

0.621

 

$2,309,643

$7,496,245

0.3081

15

7%

0.4755

$16,921,626

$4,266,944

3.966

 

$3,581,317

$6,140,292

0.583

 

$2,170,579

$7,496,245

0.2896

15

12%

0.3600

$12,810,248

$4,266,944

3.002

 

$2,711,179

$6,140,292

0.442

 

$1,643,202

$7,496,245

0.2192

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$23,465,134

$4,266,944

5.499

 

$4,966,195

$6,140,292

0.809

 

$3,009,931

$7,496,245

0.4015

20

5%

0.6093

$21,683,824

$4,266,944

5.082

 

$4,589,196

$6,140,292

0.747

 

$2,781,438

$7,496,245

0.3710

20

6%

0.5649

$20,105,580

$4,266,944

4.712

 

$4,255,174

$6,140,292

0.693

 

$2,578,992

$7,496,245

0.3440

20

7%

0.5255

$18,702,765

$4,266,944

4.383

 

$3,958,280

$6,140,292

0.645

 

$2,399,050

$7,496,245

0.3200

20

12%

0.3825

$13,611,926

$4,266,944

3.190

 

$2,880,848

$6,140,292

0.469

 

$1,746,035

$7,496,245

0.2329

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$24,304,779

$4,266,944

5.696

 

$5,143,898

$6,140,292

0.838

 

$3,117,634

$7,496,245

0.4159

25

5%

0.6283

$22,361,274

$4,266,944

5.241

 

$4,732,572

$6,140,292

0.771

 

$2,868,336

$7,496,245

0.3826

25

6%

0.5803

$20,653,371

$4,266,944

4.840

 

$4,371,109

$6,140,292

0.712

 

$2,649,259

$7,496,245

0.3534

25

7%

0.5380

$19,146,670

$4,266,944

4.487

 

$4,052,229

$6,140,292

0.660

 

$2,455,991

$7,496,245

0.3276

25

12%

0.3870

$13,771,913

$4,266,944

3.228

 

$2,914,707

$6,140,292

0.475

 

$1,766,557

$7,496,245

0.2357














































Articulated Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$21,928,922

$1,035,584

21.175

 

$3,674,179

$2,494,539

1.473

 

$1,767,718

$1,819,333

0.9716

10

5%

0.4000

$20,934,684

$1,035,584

20.215

 

$3,507,595

$2,494,539

1.406

 

$1,687,571

$1,819,333

0.9276

10

6%

0.3823

$20,010,662

$1,035,584

19.323

 

$3,352,776

$2,494,539

1.344

 

$1,613,085

$1,819,333

0.8866

10

7%

0.3659

$19,150,798

$1,035,584

18.493

 

$3,208,706

$2,494,539

1.286

 

$1,543,770

$1,819,333

0.8485

10

12%

0.2988

$15,640,228

$1,035,584

15.103

 

$2,620,512

$2,494,539

1.050

 

$1,260,778

$1,819,333

0.6930

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$30,195,558

$1,035,584

29.158

 

$5,059,250

$2,494,539

2.028

 

$2,434,102

$1,819,333

1.3379

15

5%

0.5396

$28,243,325

$1,035,584

27.273

 

$4,732,154

$2,494,539

1.897

 

$2,276,730

$1,819,333

1.2514

15

6%

0.5059

$26,481,031

$1,035,584

25.571

 

$4,436,883

$2,494,539

1.779

 

$2,134,669

$1,819,333

1.1733

15

7%

0.4755

$24,886,601

$1,035,584

24.031

 

$4,169,737

$2,494,539

1.672

 

$2,006,140

$1,819,333

1.1027

15

12%

0.3600

$18,840,007

$1,035,584

18.193

 

$3,156,633

$2,494,539

1.265

 

$1,518,717

$1,819,333

0.8348

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$34,510,126

$1,035,584

33.324

 

$5,782,153

$2,494,539

2.318

 

$2,781,905

$1,819,333

1.5291

20

5%

0.6093

$31,890,357

$1,035,584

30.795

 

$5,343,212

$2,494,539

2.142

 

$2,570,722

$1,819,333

1.4130

20

6%

0.5649

$29,569,236

$1,035,584

28.553

 

$4,954,310

$2,494,539

1.986

 

$2,383,613

$1,819,333

1.3102

20

7%

0.5255

$27,506,120

$1,035,584

26.561

 

$4,608,636

$2,494,539

1.847

 

$2,217,303

$1,819,333

1.2187

20

12%

0.3825

$20,019,033

$1,035,584

19.331

 

$3,354,178

$2,494,539

1.345

 

$1,613,759

$1,819,333

0.8870

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$35,744,990

$1,035,584

34.517

 

$5,989,054

$2,494,539

2.401

 

$2,881,448

$1,819,333

1.5838

25

5%

0.6283

$32,886,682

$1,035,584

31.757

 

$5,510,146

$2,494,539

2.209

 

$2,651,037

$1,819,333

1.4571

25

6%

0.5803

$30,374,872

$1,035,584

29.331

 

$5,089,294

$2,494,539

2.040

 

$2,448,556

$1,819,333

1.3459

25

7%

0.5380

$28,158,970

$1,035,584

27.191

 

$4,718,020

$2,494,539

1.891

 

$2,269,930

$1,819,333

1.2477

25

12%

0.3870

$20,254,325

$1,035,584

19.558

 

$3,393,601

$2,494,539

1.360

 

$1,632,727

$1,819,333

0.8974


Download 5.27 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   ...   50



The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message
    Main page
australian government does