Draft regulation Impact Statement for Underrun Protection a draft statement inviting discussion and comments from parties affected by the proposed heavy commercial vehicle safety initiative January 2007 Report Documentation Page



Download 5.27 Mb.
Page36/50
Date05.05.2018
Size5.27 Mb.
#47808
1   ...   32   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   ...   50

Scenario A1



Rigid Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$12,967,282

$4,266,944

3.039

 

$2,611,654

$6,140,292

0.425

 

$1,696,467

$7,496,245

0.2263

10

5%

0.4000

$12,379,357

$4,266,944

2.901

 

$2,493,244

$6,140,292

0.406

 

$1,619,551

$7,496,245

0.2160

10

6%

0.3823

$11,832,953

$4,266,944

2.773

 

$2,383,197

$6,140,292

0.388

 

$1,548,067

$7,496,245

0.2065

10

7%

0.3659

$11,324,487

$4,266,944

2.654

 

$2,280,790

$6,140,292

0.371

 

$1,481,546

$7,496,245

0.1976

10

12%

0.2988

$9,248,574

$4,266,944

2.167

 

$1,862,694

$6,140,292

0.303

 

$1,209,961

$7,496,245

0.161

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$17,855,611

$4,266,944

4.185

 

$3,596,181

$6,140,292

0.586

 

$2,335,992

$7,496,245

0.3116

15

5%

0.5396

$16,701,193

$4,266,944

3.914

 

$3,363,677

$6,140,292

0.548

 

$2,184,963

$7,496,245

0.2915

15

6%

0.5059

$15,659,092

$4,266,944

3.670

 

$3,153,794

$6,140,292

0.514

 

$2,048,628

$7,496,245

0.2733

15

7%

0.4755

$14,716,253

$4,266,944

3.449

 

$2,963,903

$6,140,292

0.483

 

$1,925,280

$7,496,245

0.2568

15

12%

0.3600

$11,140,706

$4,266,944

2.611

 

$2,243,776

$6,140,292

0.365

 

$1,457,502

$7,496,245

0.1944

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$20,406,956

$4,266,944

4.783

 

$4,110,030

$6,140,292

0.669

 

$2,669,776

$7,496,245

0.3561

20

5%

0.6093

$18,857,801

$4,266,944

4.420

 

$3,798,025

$6,140,292

0.619

 

$2,467,105

$7,496,245

0.3291

20

6%

0.5649

$17,485,247

$4,266,944

4.098

 

$3,521,588

$6,140,292

0.574

 

$2,287,538

$7,496,245

0.3052

20

7%

0.5255

$16,265,260

$4,266,944

3.812

 

$3,275,878

$6,140,292

0.534

 

$2,127,931

$7,496,245

0.2839

20

12%

0.3825

$11,837,902

$4,266,944

2.774

 

$2,384,194

$6,140,292

0.388

 

$1,548,714

$7,496,245

0.2066

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$21,137,170

$4,266,944

4.954

 

$4,257,098

$6,140,292

0.693

 

$2,765,307

$7,496,245

0.3689

25

5%

0.6283

$19,446,960

$4,266,944

4.558

 

$3,916,684

$6,140,292

0.638

 

$2,544,183

$7,496,245

0.3394

25

6%

0.5803

$17,961,645

$4,266,944

4.209

 

$3,617,536

$6,140,292

0.589

 

$2,349,864

$7,496,245

0.3135

25

7%

0.5380

$16,651,311

$4,266,944

3.902

 

$3,353,630

$6,140,292

0.546

 

$2,178,437

$7,496,245

0.2906

25

12%

0.3870

$11,977,038

$4,266,944

2.807

 

$2,412,216

$6,140,292

0.393

 

$1,566,917

$7,496,245

0.2090














































Articulated Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$19,070,955

$1,035,584

18.416

 

$3,040,756

$2,494,539

1.219

 

$1,567,575

$1,819,333

0.8616

10

5%

0.4000

$18,206,296

$1,035,584

17.581

 

$2,902,891

$2,494,539

1.164

 

$1,496,503

$1,819,333

0.8226

10

6%

0.3823

$17,402,700

$1,035,584

16.805

 

$2,774,762

$2,494,539

1.112

 

$1,430,450

$1,819,333

0.7862

10

7%

0.3659

$16,654,901

$1,035,584

16.083

 

$2,655,530

$2,494,539

1.065

 

$1,368,983

$1,819,333

0.7525

10

12%

0.2988

$13,601,859

$1,035,584

13.134

 

$2,168,739

$2,494,539

0.869

 

$1,118,032

$1,819,333

0.615

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$26,260,212

$1,035,584

25.358

 

$4,187,042

$2,494,539

1.678

 

$2,158,511

$1,819,333

1.1864

15

5%

0.5396

$24,562,411

$1,035,584

23.718

 

$3,916,338

$2,494,539

1.570

 

$2,018,956

$1,819,333

1.1097

15

6%

0.5059

$23,029,795

$1,035,584

22.238

 

$3,671,971

$2,494,539

1.472

 

$1,892,980

$1,819,333

1.0405

15

7%

0.4755

$21,643,165

$1,035,584

20.899

 

$3,450,880

$2,494,539

1.383

 

$1,779,003

$1,819,333

0.9778

15

12%

0.3600

$16,384,614

$1,035,584

15.822

 

$2,612,434

$2,494,539

1.047

 

$1,346,766

$1,819,333

0.7403

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$30,012,469

$1,035,584

28.981

 

$4,785,318

$2,494,539

1.918

 

$2,466,935

$1,819,333

1.3560

20

5%

0.6093

$27,734,131

$1,035,584

26.781

 

$4,422,050

$2,494,539

1.773

 

$2,279,662

$1,819,333

1.2530

20

6%

0.5649

$25,715,518

$1,035,584

24.832

 

$4,100,194

$2,494,539

1.644

 

$2,113,738

$1,819,333

1.1618

20

7%

0.5255

$23,921,285

$1,035,584

23.099

 

$3,814,114

$2,494,539

1.529

 

$1,966,258

$1,819,333

1.0808

20

12%

0.3825

$17,409,980

$1,035,584

16.812

 

$2,775,923

$2,494,539

1.113

 

$1,431,048

$1,819,333

0.7866

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$31,086,394

$1,035,584

30.018

 

$4,956,550

$2,494,539

1.987

 

$2,555,208

$1,819,333

1.4045

25

5%

0.6283

$28,600,606

$1,035,584

27.618

 

$4,560,205

$2,494,539

1.828

 

$2,350,884

$1,819,333

1.2922

25

6%

0.5803

$26,416,156

$1,035,584

25.508

 

$4,211,907

$2,494,539

1.688

 

$2,171,329

$1,819,333

1.1935

25

7%

0.5380

$24,489,050

$1,035,584

23.648

 

$3,904,641

$2,494,539

1.565

 

$2,012,926

$1,819,333

1.1064

25

12%

0.3870

$17,614,607

$1,035,584

17.009

 

$2,808,549

$2,494,539

1.126

 

$1,447,868

$1,819,333

0.7958


Download 5.27 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   32   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   ...   50



The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message
    Main page
australian government does