Draft regulation Impact Statement for Underrun Protection a draft statement inviting discussion and comments from parties affected by the proposed heavy commercial vehicle safety initiative January 2007 Report Documentation Page



Download 5.27 Mb.
Page38/50
Date05.05.2018
Size5.27 Mb.
#47808
1   ...   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   ...   50

Scenario C1



Rigid Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$16,913,336

$4,266,944

3.964

 

$3,633,603

$6,140,292

0.592

 

$2,112,465

$7,496,245

0.2818

10

5%

0.4000

$16,146,501

$4,266,944

3.784

 

$3,468,859

$6,140,292

0.565

 

$2,016,688

$7,496,245

0.2690

10

6%

0.3823

$15,433,821

$4,266,944

3.617

 

$3,315,749

$6,140,292

0.540

 

$1,927,675

$7,496,245

0.2572

10

7%

0.3659

$14,770,625

$4,266,944

3.462

 

$3,173,270

$6,140,292

0.517

 

$1,844,842

$7,496,245

0.2461

10

12%

0.2988

$12,062,993

$4,266,944

2.827

 

$2,591,572

$6,140,292

0.422

 

$1,506,661

$7,496,245

0.2010

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$23,289,226

$4,266,944

5.458

 

$5,003,377

$6,140,292

0.815

 

$2,908,810

$7,496,245

0.3880

15

5%

0.5396

$21,783,508

$4,266,944

5.105

 

$4,679,894

$6,140,292

0.762

 

$2,720,747

$7,496,245

0.3629

15

6%

0.5059

$20,424,287

$4,266,944

4.787

 

$4,387,883

$6,140,292

0.715

 

$2,550,981

$7,496,245

0.3403

15

7%

0.4755

$19,194,535

$4,266,944

4.498

 

$4,123,688

$6,140,292

0.672

 

$2,397,386

$7,496,245

0.3198

15

12%

0.3600

$14,530,918

$4,266,944

3.405

 

$3,121,772

$6,140,292

0.508

 

$1,814,903

$7,496,245

0.2421

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$26,616,966

$4,266,944

6.238

 

$5,718,297

$6,140,292

0.931

 

$3,324,443

$7,496,245

0.4435

20

5%

0.6093

$24,596,391

$4,266,944

5.764

 

$5,284,204

$6,140,292

0.861

 

$3,072,074

$7,496,245

0.4098

20

6%

0.5649

$22,806,157

$4,266,944

5.345

 

$4,899,596

$6,140,292

0.798

 

$2,848,475

$7,496,245

0.3800

20

7%

0.5255

$21,214,917

$4,266,944

4.972

 

$4,557,740

$6,140,292

0.742

 

$2,649,730

$7,496,245

0.3535

20

12%

0.3825

$15,440,277

$4,266,944

3.619

 

$3,317,136

$6,140,292

0.540

 

$1,928,481

$7,496,245

0.2573

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$27,569,391

$4,266,944

6.461

 

$5,922,913

$6,140,292

0.965

 

$3,443,400

$7,496,245

0.4594

25

5%

0.6283

$25,364,836

$4,266,944

5.944

 

$5,449,294

$6,140,292

0.887

 

$3,168,053

$7,496,245

0.4226

25

6%

0.5803

$23,427,527

$4,266,944

5.490

 

$5,033,089

$6,140,292

0.820

 

$2,926,084

$7,496,245

0.3903

25

7%

0.5380

$21,718,447

$4,266,944

5.090

 

$4,665,916

$6,140,292

0.760

 

$2,712,621

$7,496,245

0.3619

25

12%

0.3870

$15,621,753

$4,266,944

3.661

 

$3,356,124

$6,140,292

0.547

 

$1,951,147

$7,496,245

0.2603














































Articulated Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$24,874,410

$1,035,584

24.020

 

$4,230,613

$2,494,539

1.696

 

$1,953,196

$1,819,333

1.0736

10

5%

0.4000

$23,746,627

$1,035,584

22.931

 

$4,038,801

$2,494,539

1.619

 

$1,864,640

$1,819,333

1.0249

10

6%

0.3823

$22,698,490

$1,035,584

21.919

 

$3,860,535

$2,494,539

1.548

 

$1,782,338

$1,819,333

0.9797

10

7%

0.3659

$21,723,129

$1,035,584

20.977

 

$3,694,647

$2,494,539

1.481

 

$1,705,750

$1,819,333

0.9376

10

12%

0.2988

$17,741,021

$1,035,584

17.131

 

$3,017,374

$2,494,539

1.210

 

$1,393,066

$1,819,333

0.7657

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$34,251,419

$1,035,584

33.074

 

$5,825,445

$2,494,539

2.335

 

$2,689,500

$1,819,333

1.4783

15

5%

0.5396

$32,036,963

$1,035,584

30.936

 

$5,448,813

$2,494,539

2.184

 

$2,515,616

$1,819,333

1.3827

15

6%

0.5059

$30,037,958

$1,035,584

29.006

 

$5,108,824

$2,494,539

2.048

 

$2,358,650

$1,819,333

1.2964

15

7%

0.4755

$28,229,364

$1,035,584

27.259

 

$4,801,220

$2,494,539

1.925

 

$2,216,635

$1,819,333

1.2184

15

12%

0.3600

$21,370,592

$1,035,584

20.636

 

$3,634,688

$2,494,539

1.457

 

$1,678,068

$1,819,333

0.9224

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$39,145,519

$1,035,584

37.800

 

$6,657,828

$2,494,539

2.669

 

$3,073,796

$1,819,333

1.6895

20

5%

0.6093

$36,173,863

$1,035,584

34.931

 

$6,152,412

$2,494,539

2.466

 

$2,840,455

$1,819,333

1.5613

20

6%

0.5649

$33,540,970

$1,035,584

32.388

 

$5,704,613

$2,494,539

2.287

 

$2,633,714

$1,819,333

1.4476

20

7%

0.5255

$31,200,736

$1,035,584

30.129

 

$5,306,588

$2,494,539

2.127

 

$2,449,954

$1,819,333

1.3466

20

12%

0.3825

$22,707,985

$1,035,584

21.928

 

$3,862,150

$2,494,539

1.548

 

$1,783,083

$1,819,333

0.9801

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$40,546,249

$1,035,584

39.153

 

$6,896,063

$2,494,539

2.764

 

$3,183,785

$1,819,333

1.7500

25

5%

0.6283

$37,304,014

$1,035,584

36.022

 

$6,344,627

$2,494,539

2.543

 

$2,929,197

$1,819,333

1.6100

25

6%

0.5803

$34,454,818

$1,035,584

33.271

 

$5,860,039

$2,494,539

2.349

 

$2,705,472

$1,819,333

1.4871

25

7%

0.5380

$31,941,276

$1,035,584

30.844

 

$5,432,538

$2,494,539

2.178

 

$2,508,102

$1,819,333

1.3786

25

12%

0.3870

$22,974,881

$1,035,584

22.185

 

$3,907,543

$2,494,539

1.566

 

$1,804,041

$1,819,333

0.9916


Download 5.27 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   ...   50



The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message
    Main page
australian government does