Draft regulation Impact Statement for Underrun Protection a draft statement inviting discussion and comments from parties affected by the proposed heavy commercial vehicle safety initiative January 2007 Report Documentation Page



Download 5.27 Mb.
Page39/50
Date05.05.2018
Size5.27 Mb.
#47808
1   ...   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   ...   50

Scenario D1



Rigid Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$18,922,449

$85,533,505

0.221

 

$4,111,515

$85,533,505

0.048

 

$2,318,347

$150,266,817

0.0154

10

5%

0.4000

$18,064,523

$85,533,505

0.211

 

$3,925,102

$85,533,505

0.046

 

$2,213,235

$150,266,817

0.0147

10

6%

0.3246

$14,660,225

$85,533,505

0.171

 

$3,185,409

$85,533,505

0.037

 

$1,796,146

$150,266,817

0.0120

10

7%

0.3131

$14,140,850

$85,533,505

0.165

 

$3,072,557

$85,533,505

0.036

 

$1,732,513

$150,266,817

0.0115

10

12%

0.2260

$10,206,516

$85,533,505

0.119

 

$2,217,696

$85,533,505

0.026

 

$1,250,485

$150,266,817

0.0083

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$26,055,723

$85,533,505

0.305

 

$5,661,449

$85,533,505

0.066

 

$3,192,303

$150,266,817

0.0212

15

5%

0.5152

$23,268,670

$85,533,505

0.272

 

$5,055,872

$85,533,505

0.059

 

$2,850,838

$150,266,817

0.0190

15

6%

0.4627

$20,897,863

$85,533,505

0.244

 

$4,540,737

$85,533,505

0.053

 

$2,560,371

$150,266,817

0.0170

15

7%

0.4157

$18,775,059

$85,533,505

0.220

 

$4,079,489

$85,533,505

0.048

 

$2,300,289

$150,266,817

0.0153

15

12%

0.3143

$14,194,175

$85,533,505

0.166

 

$3,084,144

$85,533,505

0.036

 

$1,739,046

$150,266,817

0.0116

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$29,778,761

$85,533,505

0.348

 

$6,470,400

$85,533,505

0.076

 

$3,648,444

$150,266,817

0.0243

20

5%

0.6015

$27,165,476

$85,533,505

0.318

 

$5,902,579

$85,533,505

0.069

 

$3,328,268

$150,266,817

0.0221

20

6%

0.5491

$24,799,841

$85,533,505

0.290

 

$5,388,568

$85,533,505

0.063

 

$3,038,435

$150,266,817

0.0202

20

7%

0.5024

$22,692,593

$85,533,505

0.265

 

$4,930,700

$85,533,505

0.058

 

$2,780,258

$150,266,817

0.0185

20

12%

0.3674

$16,595,364

$85,533,505

0.194

 

$3,605,880

$85,533,505

0.042

 

$2,033,236

$150,266,817

0.0135

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$30,844,324

$85,533,505

0.361

 

$6,701,928

$85,533,505

0.078

 

$3,778,995

$150,266,817

0.0251

25

5%

0.6263

$28,285,095

$85,533,505

0.331

 

$6,145,852

$85,533,505

0.072

 

$3,465,442

$150,266,817

0.0231

25

6%

0.5767

$26,045,454

$85,533,505

0.305

 

$5,659,218

$85,533,505

0.066

 

$3,191,045

$150,266,817

0.0212

25

7%

0.5330

$24,070,569

$85,533,505

0.281

 

$5,230,110

$85,533,505

0.061

 

$2,949,086

$150,266,817

0.0196

25

12%

0.3842

$17,350,708

$85,533,505

0.203

 

$3,770,003

$85,533,505

0.044

 

$2,125,780

$150,266,817

0.0141














































Articulated Trucks

Front

 

Side

 

Rear

Period

Rate

Multiplier

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

PV Benefits

Cost

BCR

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

10

4%

0.4190

$27,829,209

$27,402,434

1.016

 

$4,787,047

$66,007,629

0.073

 

$2,144,691

$48,141,095

0.0446

10

5%

0.4000

$26,567,458

$27,402,434

0.970

 

$4,570,007

$66,007,629

0.069

 

$2,047,453

$48,141,095

0.0425

10

6%

0.3823

$25,394,815

$27,402,434

0.927

 

$4,368,294

$66,007,629

0.066

 

$1,957,082

$48,141,095

0.0407

10

7%

0.3659

$24,303,591

$27,402,434

0.887

 

$4,180,587

$66,007,629

0.063

 

$1,872,985

$48,141,095

0.0389

10

12%

0.2988

$19,848,454

$27,402,434

0.724

 

$3,414,236

$66,007,629

0.052

 

$1,529,645

$48,141,095

0.0318

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15

4%

0.5769

$38,320,101

$27,402,434

1.398

 

$6,591,640

$66,007,629

0.100

 

$2,953,184

$48,141,095

0.0613

15

5%

0.5396

$35,842,592

$27,402,434

1.308

 

$6,165,471

$66,007,629

0.093

 

$2,762,252

$48,141,095

0.0574

15

6%

0.5059

$33,606,129

$27,402,434

1.226

 

$5,780,765

$66,007,629

0.088

 

$2,589,896

$48,141,095

0.0538

15

7%

0.4755

$31,582,694

$27,402,434

1.153

 

$5,432,704

$66,007,629

0.082

 

$2,433,958

$48,141,095

0.0506

15

12%

0.3600

$23,909,178

$27,402,434

0.873

 

$4,112,742

$66,007,629

0.062

 

$1,842,589

$48,141,095

0.0383

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

20

4%

0.6593

$43,795,565

$27,402,434

1.598

 

$7,533,503

$66,007,629

0.114

 

$3,375,157

$48,141,095

0.0701

20

5%

0.6093

$40,470,910

$27,402,434

1.477

 

$6,961,612

$66,007,629

0.105

 

$3,118,939

$48,141,095

0.0648

20

6%

0.5649

$37,525,259

$27,402,434

1.369

 

$6,454,915

$66,007,629

0.098

 

$2,891,929

$48,141,095

0.0601

20

7%

0.5255

$34,907,032

$27,402,434

1.274

 

$6,004,540

$66,007,629

0.091

 

$2,690,152

$48,141,095

0.0559

20

12%

0.3825

$25,405,437

$27,402,434

0.927

 

$4,370,122

$66,007,629

0.066

 

$1,957,900

$48,141,095

0.0407

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

25

4%

0.6829

$45,362,686

$27,402,434

1.655

 

$7,803,072

$66,007,629

0.118

 

$3,495,929

$48,141,095

0.0726

25

5%

0.6283

$41,735,310

$27,402,434

1.523

 

$7,179,108

$66,007,629

0.109

 

$3,216,381

$48,141,095

0.0668

25

6%

0.5803

$38,547,662

$27,402,434

1.407

 

$6,630,784

$66,007,629

0.100

 

$2,970,721

$48,141,095

0.0617

25

7%

0.5380

$35,735,540

$27,402,434

1.304

 

$6,147,056

$66,007,629

0.093

 

$2,754,002

$48,141,095

0.0572

25

12%

0.3870

$25,704,038

$27,402,434

0.938

 

$4,421,485

$66,007,629

0.067

 

$1,980,912

$48,141,095

0.0411


Download 5.27 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   ...   50



The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message
    Main page
australian government does