Foundation Briefs Advanced Level Sept/Oct 2013 Brief


should vote. The present approach would not justify his voting



Download 0.95 Mb.
View original pdf
Page101/186
Date16.12.2020
Size0.95 Mb.
#54643
1   ...   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   ...   186
174826514-Foundation-Briefs-compulsory-voting
should vote. The present approach would not justify his voting. In this respect, the present rationale differs from both the Kantian and expressivist approaches, which presumably urge people to vote under all circumstances. I do not regard it as a defect of the current rationale that it has this qualified aspect. I am unconvinced that a person ought to vote, or has a duty to vote, even when he is both uninformed and no longer has time to become informed. (209)


Sept/Oct 2013

Neg: Voting Against Own Interests

foundationbriefs.com

Page 56 of 104
A dearth of informed voters turns elections into exercises of random probability, DAT
Jakee, Keith, and Martin Kenneally. Increasing Voter Turnout What Difference Can
Compulsory Voting Make Florida Atlantic University, 2009.
If abstainers are less interested and less informed about the political process, as per Jakee & Sun (2006), Lacy and Burden (1999), or Lassen (2005), then it is even less clear that increasing their presence in the election is a desirable objective. The reason is that their votes can effectively be treated as random (Jakee and Sun 2006) and, if this is an accurate assumption, forcing them to vote causes the CVR outcome to become increasingly random, as the percentage of involuntary voters (P) increases. Indeed, this specific scenario of a very high abstention rate and low voter turnout is one, according to our analysis, in which a CVR can make a difference compared to a VVR. However, implementing a CVR in this case may turn the election outcome into
something akin to a coin toss because of the large percentage of purely random votes. Determining an election by a random coin toss surely implies an electoral result that is wholly unreflective of any underlying community preferences further weakening the argument in favor of imposing a CVR.
A CVR is a compulsory voting rule a VVR is a voluntary voting rule. The authors of the study used
statistical analysis of multiple election scenarios, altering variables for turnout, whether a seat was safe,

Download 0.95 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   97   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   ...   186




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page