Exhibit III (E) 2: Apple’s Valuation using Comparable Analysis
Page 14/53 Date 20.10.2016 Size 7.3 Mb. #5075
Comparable Analysis:
Source: Yahoo Finance , Value Line
PALM
RIMM
CREAF
SNDK
DELL
GTW
NAPS
CNET
MSFT
AVERAGE
AAPL
VALUE ($M)
Shares outstanding (M)
102.09
185.70
83.39
210.85
2230.00
317.75
45.00
149.80
9790.00
862
Price (on 02/16/07)
16.09
138.82
6.50
40.13
24.39
1.94
3.94
9.27
28.74
84.83
Market Value of Equity ($M)
1642.63
25778.87
542.04
8461.41
54389.70
616.44
177.30
1388.65
281364.60
73112.43
Long-term Debt ($M)
0.00
6.90
192.00
1150.00
504.00
300.00
0.00
139.10
0.00
0.00
Cash & cash equivalents ($M)
518.41
893.45
234.41
2810.00
8070.00
490.73
80.90
61.70
26400.00
11870.00
Enterprise Value ($M)
1124.22
24892.32
499.63
6801.41
46823.70
425.71
96.40
1466.05
254964.60
61242.43
Sales ($M)
1540.00
2670.00
1120.00
3260.00
57880.00
3980.00
108.73
387.69
46060.00
20680.00
EBITDA ($M)
133.86
843.34
(0.41)
792.63
4430.00
8.88
(35.16)
66.71
17940.00
3440.00
Book Value/Share ($)
9.85
12.37
5.28
22.59
1.38
0.69
2.02
1.77
3.75
13.05
Book value of Equity ($M)
1005.38
2296.74
439.88
4763.73
3077.40
218.61
90.68
265.30
36683.13
11249.13
EPS ($)
15.08
14.38
13.43
15.46
25.96
12.53
2.42
2.59
4.70
23.99
Enterprise Value/Sales
0.73
9.32
0.45
2.09
0.81
0.11
0.89
3.78
5.54
2.63
2.96
54,469
Enterprise Value/EBITDA
8.40
29.52
(1227.58)
8.58
10.57
47.94
(2.74)
21.98
14.21
20.66
17.80
71,056
Market Value/Book Value
1.63
11.22
1.23
1.78
17.67
2.82
1.96
5.23
7.67
5.69
6.50
64,020
Price/EPS
1.07
9.66
0.48
2.60
0.94
0.15
1.63
3.58
6.11
2.91
3.54
60,241
VALUATION (averages)
ENTERPRISE
$ 62,762 M
EQUITY
$ 62,130 M
Adjustments:
CURRENT PERFORMANCE
PALM
RIMM
SNDK
DELL
GTW
NAPS
CNET
MSFT
Median
AAPL
Diff
Adjustment
REVENUE (TTM)
1,540
2,670
3,260
57,880
3,980
109
388
46,060
2,965
20,680
597.5%
PROFIT MARGIN (TTM)
5.61%
17.43%
6.1%
5.1%
0.2%
-30.10%
2.02%
25.86%
5.36%
11.74%
119.2%
OPERATING MARGIN (TTM)
6.85%
27.22%
17.1%
6.9%
-0.5%
-36.3%
3.15%
36.20%
6.85%
14.63%
113.6%
5%
EPS
0.82
2.45
0.96
1.28
0.08
-0.76
0.05
1.17
0.89
2.76
210.1%
EXPECTED GROWTH
Revenue Forecast '07
1570
3030
4120
57640
4150
109
432.31
50550
3,575
24290
Revenue Forecast '08
1770
4320
4910
59960
4290
150
478.94
56430
4,305
30560
EPS Forecast '07
0.64
3.34
1.19
1.15
0.10
(0.93)
0.16
1.47
0.90
3.21
EPS Forecast '08
0.72
4.59
2.53
1.30
0.12
(0.67)
0.25
1.70
1.01
3.78
REVENUE Growth '07 (YOY)
1.95%
13.48%
26.38%
-0.41%
4.27%
0.02%
11.51%
9.75%
7.01%
17.46%
149.0%
Revenue Growth '08 (YOY)
12.74%
42.57%
19.17%
4.02%
3.37%
37.66%
10.79%
11.63%
12.19%
25.81%
111.8%
10%
EPS Growth '07
-22.0%
36.3%
24.0%
-10.2%
25.0%
22.4%
220.0%
25.6%
24.48%
16.30%
-33.4%
-5%
EPS Growth '08
12.5%
37.4%
112.6%
13.0%
20.0%
-28.0%
56.3%
15.6%
17.82%
17.76%
-0.4%
-5%
0%
Note : Creative (CREAF) has been excluded from the calculations for adjustments since the full information on its revenue forecast for 2007 and 2008 is not available.
Final Valuation:
VALUATION
BY COMPARABLES
ADJUSTMENT
ADJUSTED VALUATION
ENTERPRISE VALUE
$ 62,762 M
5%
$ 62,762 M
EQUITY VALUE
$ 62,130 M
5%
$ 62,130 M
Share with your friends:
The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message