Name: Deb Caldwell
|
Subject: Social Studies/Phantom Tollbooth
|
Grade Level: Grade 4 (Gifted)
|
Lesson Model:
|
Lesson Title: The Electoral Colleges role in Presidential Elections
|
Date: December 1, 2011
Duration: 4 -45 minutes sessions
|
Context
4th Grade Gifted & Talented
This is a fourth grade gifted and talented program. The population contains 31 students consisting of 18 boys and 13 girls. Seven of the students are new to the school and School District.
Gender
|
Number of Students
|
Percent of Total
|
Boys
|
18
|
58%
|
Girls
|
13
|
42%
|
Total
|
31
|
|
MSP Scores for classroom population
The students MSP scores at the completion of the 2010-2011 school year (third grade) found the majority of the students to have exceeded their level for both Reading and Mathematics.
MSP
|
Math
|
Math %
|
Reading
|
Reading %
|
Exceeded Level
|
27
|
86
|
28
|
90%
|
Met Level
|
4
|
14
|
2
|
7%
|
Below Level
|
0
|
|
1
|
3%
|
Subjects
A survey of the students collected data regarding subjects they enjoy, those that the worry most about and those they find the most challenging.
Subject
|
WA History
|
Writing
|
Reading
|
Science
|
Math
|
Art
|
Nothing
|
Homework
|
Group Work
|
Computers
|
Look forward to learning
|
6
|
1
|
0
|
9
|
13
|
2
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Worried about learning
|
3
|
3
|
0
|
4
|
10
|
0
|
5
|
1
|
2
|
1
|
Hardest subject
|
2
|
12
|
2
|
3
|
10
|
0
|
1
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Themes of Interest to the students
Writing and writing techniques
Animals and birds
Art
Space and Astronomy
Greek Mythology
Culture
Engineering
History
Ways of Learning
We have not evaluated any of the students to determine their preferred learning style in our classroom. My CT and I have discussed the intelligences but this is a low priority for my CT while she tries to build community. Looking at the data collected for each of the students, as well as my personal observations, I can make some assumptions. The majority of the class seem to prefer the Logical/Mathematical and interpersonal ways of learning. They are a very social group. A very small percentage prefers Verbal/Linguistic and Intrapersonal.
It will be most helpful to find out each students preferred method so accommodations and considerations can be made when designing curriculum.
Equity Pedagogy
As a teacher, “Self-understanding and knowledge of the histories, modal characteristics, and intragroup differences of ethnic groups are important competencies required for teachers to implement equity pedagogy. They provide a foundation for teachers to identify, create, and implement teaching strategies that enhance the academic achievement of students from both gender groups and from diverse racial, ethnic, and cultural groups. Equity pedagogy is not embodied in specific strategies. It is a process that locates the student at the center of schooling. When effectively implemented, equity pedagogy enriches the lives of both teachers and students and enables them to envision and to help create a more humane and caring society.”
We do not currently have the actual ethnic diversity of our classroom though we have a diverse population of students. We do know the English language is not the primary language for all our students. We are just beginning to assess some of these students literacy, especially those who were just at or below standard. We are currently working with the school resource educator to have these children appropriately assessed so we can begin to help them improve their literacy skills for fluency and comprehension.
Areas Where Students May Struggle
When analyzing information, students with little experience or practice with this higher-order skill may find the process challenging.
Pre-teach skill lessons on strategizes used for analyzing data
Unless students have experience or practice in analyzing primary documents, they may find this process challenging, as answers are not always evident. Students must gather evidence, make assumptions, and reach conclusions.
Pre-teach skill lesson on strategies used for an inquiry process: analyzing data, collecting evidence, synthesizing data, and reaching conclusions
Students are required to read and summarize information. Struggling readers and ELL students may be challenged by this requirement.
Minimize reading material, locate and present the same information at a lower reading level, assign helpful student partners, explain information and scaffold students with oral directions, provide tape-recorded information, and/or allow students to study the reading material at home before the lesson.
Differentiating Instruction
Reading: Consider accommodating special need students when creating the reading list. Try to create a subset of the main reading list that will still provide these students with an understanding of the time period.
Grouping: Grouping could provide a venue for accommodation by pairing stronger students with special needs students for reading, analyzing documents, discussion assumptions, and drawing conclusions.
Comprehension: Might try orally explaining the background information and instructions to special needs students, or students could take the information home to read/study a day or two before the lesson is taught.
Content Big Idea and Learning Targets
Subject: Social Studies, Grade 4 (Gifted)
This lesson will be taught to 4th grade challenge students as part of the thematic, interdisciplinary unit using Phantom Tollbooth.
|
Washington State Standards: Science: 4th and 5th Grade
The student understands and applies knowledge of government, law, politics, and the nation’s fundamental documents to make decisions about local, national, and international issues and to demonstrate thoughtful, participatory citizenship.
EALR 1.0: Civics
Big Idea: 1.4 Understand civic involvement
Core Content: 1.4.1 Understands that civic participation involves being informed about public issues and voting in elections
|
Description of Standard for Grade 4-5
In fourth grade, students use their understanding of social studies concepts and skills to
explore Washington State in the past and present. Students learn about the state’s unique
geography and key eras in early Washington State history, particularly the treaty-making
period. They use this historical perspective to help them make sense of the state’s geography, economy, and government today. The cognitive demand of many GLEs begins to include analysis and asks students to look at issues and events from multiple perspectives.
|
Essential Understandings: (Content/ Big Idea)
Democratic governments must balance the rights of individuals with the common good.
|
Essential Questions: (Objectives/Learning Targets)
How does the United States balance the rights of individuals with the common good?
Who should decide?
|
Understand what the Electoral College is
Understand importance of swing states
Understand importance of battleground states
Why it is important to participate in government
Understand what campaign issues are
Understand different perspectives of citizens
|
Content Standards (What student’ will be able to do & demonstrate)
Forecast the electoral vote count for the presidential election.
Describe campaign issues, the Electoral College, the role of swing states, and the importance of political participation.
Label a US map with all of the electoral votes.
Color each state the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Label swing states with their prediction.
Tally the electoral votes for each state.
|
Computers with Internet access or printouts of chart listing electoral votes per state (optional)
U.S. outline map
USA Outline Maps (Houghton Mifflin)
Xpeditions Atlas (National Geographic)
Outline Maps of the United States (NationalAtlas.gov)
Electoral College Data
Historical Election Results
2008 Presidential Election
Interactive Electoral Map
Electoral College Calculator
Lesson Plan – Electing a President
Instructional Elections Guide for Elementary3
Paper maps of United States
|
Academic Language
Vote
Election
Map
Electoral College
color key
citizenship
Battleground state
Swing State
Primary
Caucus
Convention
Popular vote
Political Party
Republican
Democrat
|
Differentiating Instruction
Reading: Consider accommodating special need students when creating the reading and vocabulary list. Try to create a subset of the main reading list that will still provide these students with an understanding of the lesson.
Grouping: Grouping could provide a venue for accommodation by pairing stronger students with special needs students for reading, analyzing documents, discussion assumptions, and drawing conclusions.
Comprehension: Might try orally explaining the background information and instructions to special needs students, or students could take the information home to read/study a day or two before the lesson is taught.
Assessment of Student Learning
Formative: As students work in small groups, the teacher will be circulating specifically listening and watching for the assessment criteria below. This will allow the teacher to adjust, modify, and clarify student understandings. During this phase, the teacher will be specifically doing the following:
Teacher will be monitoring students’ knowledge and ability to correctly use their new civic and political academic language by listening as they work in groups.
Teacher will be monitoring students’ knowledge and ability discuss and gather facts for describing past electoral results.
During my lessons formative assessment is embedded to gauge if students are/are not learning my intended lesson. Think-pair-share, small group, and large group are included to allow students to develop positive peer interactions, socially construct knowledge and learn different ways or perspectives about ways of knowing. When students verbally share as a teacher I am monitoring students discussions, work activities, and inquiring about their thinking.
When students are listening to my direct instruction, however, often prior to their ‘doing’ hands-on activities I gauge student understanding in several ways. It can be a mixture of ‘thumbs up’ for it is clear ‘thumbs down’ for not clear, or ‘hand flat with a rocking motion’ sort of get it but not confident. Other times I may elicit several students ideas/comments or alternative ways of thinking, to measure if they are thinking about what I am instructing.
Exit and/or entry tickets are also another method of gathering student feedback. What do they now before I teach a lesson, did they leave the classroom with what I hope they had from the lesson. I don’t choose to grade these because I believe they are an additional instructional tool for my reflection on my teaching and how to modify for the next lesson.
|
Summative: What is the eventual summative assessment
The teacher will be looking at the following and specifically looking for:
Table
Clearly compares the swing states on the following: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, and demographic breakdown.
Contains a column indicating which way you think the state will vote.
A paragraph is included for each swing state explaining your decision
Graphic organizer is neat and easy to read.
Graphic organizer columns are labeled as follows: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, demographic breakdown, and decision.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
Electoral Map
Each of the fifty states is labeled in its correct location.
All electoral votes are correctly labeled.
States are colored the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Swing states are colored according to your decision.
Electoral votes are tallied and listed for each party.
An appropriate legend is included.
The title indicates the content of the map.
The title is clearly distinguishable using 16 font and underlining.
The map is neatly drawn. Lines are drawn with a ruler.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
| Performance Task: (Looking at …)
By entering the Phantom Tollbooth, Milo and his friends had the opportunity to visit many distinct lands.
Along with diverse terrains, our country’s makeup of fifty states varies in opinions, wants, and needs. Therefore key campaign issues and the different perspectives of the citizens of the fifty states will vary enormously. It is important to understand the Electoral College and the importance of swing/battleground states.
You will take on the role of a political analyst, forecasting the electoral vote count for the presidential election. You will need to learn about campaign issues, the Electoral College, the role of swing states, and the importance of political participation. For each swing state:
You are to create a table addressing the following: number of electoral votes, the state’s pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, and demographic breakdown. Visit the website, http://www.270towin.com/states/
Decide whether the swing state will be carried by the Democrats or Republicans, and give a brief explanation for your reasoning.
Using a map of the US, label all of the electoral votes. Color the state the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Label your swing states with your prediction.
Tally the electoral votes for each state.
Title the map with your prediction:
Republican Candidate _____votes
Democratic Candidate= _____ votes.
After the election compare your predictions to actual votes.
Your swing state table, prediction decision, and map will need to meet all the criteria on the rubrics your teacher will give you.
| Other Evidence |
Accommodations/Modifications: So all students can show progress toward learning targets
For the two students that are challenged by the English language, yet do not qualify for ELL, they will be provided with instructional support. For any reading and writing, they will receive one-on-one assistance from myself or my master teacher. When appropriate, we will substitute different vocabulary words and/or readings with the same overarching goals yet at an appropriate level for their reading/writing. When writing they will receive extra time to complete their written assignments and have one-on-one assistance during class sessions. When having group discussions and/or activities, the students will be placed with stronger skilled students to allow them group work without them losing the context of what is being taught. If doing any jigsaw activities, consider what is being jig sawed to ensure they are successful with this activity.
|
Student Voice:Student self-assessment
Piaget, Vgotsky, and Dewey all teach us that students learn best through meaningful experiences and when these experiences are shared, knowledge is socially constructed providing for higher level learning that as an individual.
As teachers, it is easy to fall into a routine of delivering content, testing on what you want the students to know and fail to ask what the students believe they learned. As teachers, failing to ask questions of our students fails to provide us invaluable information about our own teaching. Did the students learn what we had hoped they would learn? What questions do they still wonder about? What did they enjoy about the lesson, and what was challenging and/or frustrating? If they were to design the lesson, what may they have done differently and why?
These types of questions help us reflect on our own teaching and ways of delivering our lessons to each of our students. We must also remember, however, that these big questions do not necessarily happen with very lesson but should definitely occur for those large learning goals. With the above in mind, for this unit plan, I envision asking these questions at the end of each lesson after student presentations of their projects.
A curriculum of identify asks students to reflect on their skills and interests as they relate to the discipline being studied. Since learning requires experiences in order to have a base to build upon, knowing what value they place on what was learned tells me something about the base they have developed with my instruction. (See Appendix D)
|
Instruction and Engagement to Support Student Learning Introduction
Tell Students what you want them to be able to do
By entering the Phantom Tollbooth, Milo and his friends had the opportunity to visit many distinct lands.
Along with diverse terrains, our country’s makeup of fifty states varies in opinions, wants, and needs. Therefore key campaign issues and the different perspectives of the citizens of the fifty states will vary enormously. It is important to understand the Electoral College and the importance of swing/battleground states.
You will take on the role of a political analyst, forecasting the electoral vote count for the presidential election. You will need to learn about campaign issues, the Electoral College, the role of swing states, and the importance of political participation. For each swing state:
You are to create a table addressing the following: number of electoral votes, the state’s pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, and demographic breakdown. Visit the website, http://www.270towin.com/states/
Decide whether the swing state will be carried by the Democrats or Republicans, and give a brief explanation for your reasoning.
Using a map of the US, label all of the electoral votes. Color the state the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Label your swing states with your prediction.
Tally the electoral votes for each state.
Title the map with your prediction:
Republican Candidate _____votes
Democratic Candidate= _____ votes.
After the election compare your predictions to actual votes.
Your swing state table, prediction decision, and map will need to meet all the criteria on the rubrics your teacher will give you.Tell Students how you will know they got there
Table
Clearly compares the swing states on the following: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, and demographic breakdown.
Contains a column indicating which way you think the state will vote.
A paragraph is included for each swing state explaining your decision
Graphic organizer is neat and easy to read.
Graphic organizer columns are labeled as follows: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, demographic breakdown, and decision.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
Electoral Map
Each of the fifty states is labeled in its correct location.
All electoral votes are correctly labeled.
States are colored the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Swing states are colored according to your decision.
Electoral votes are tallied and listed for each party.
An appropriate legend is included.
The title indicates the content of the map.
The title is clearly distinguishable using 16 font and underlining.
The map is neatly drawn. Lines are drawn with a ruler.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
Tells Students how you will help get them there
At the end of this lesson students will be able to analyze vote counts from each state to determine which candidate got the most popular votes in each state. Correctly color and label an electoral map of the United States as follows:
All electoral votes are correctly labeled.
States are colored the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Swing states are colored according to your decision.
Electoral votes are tallied and listed for each party.
An appropriate legend is included.
Direct Instruction
Overview4
Predicting the electoral vote count for the presidential election
Objectives
Students will be able to:
Students analyze vote counts from each state to determine which candidate got the most popular votes in each state.
Create electoral map with a color key to show the popular vote results.
Use the electoral map and a chart to determine how many electoral votes each candidate received.
Materials
Computers with Internet access or printouts of chart listing electoral votes per state (optional)
U.S. outline map
Online Resources
USA Outline Maps (Houghton Mifflin)
Xpeditions Atlas (National Geographic)
Outline Maps of the United States (NationalAtlas.gov)
Electoral College Data
Historical Election Results
2008 Presidential Election
Interactive Electoral Map
Electoral College Calculator
Lesson Plan – Electing a President
Instructional Elections Guide for Elementary5
Off-line resources
Paper maps of United States
Instruction
Teacher Does
|
Student Does
|
Phase 1: Introduction
Teacher tells students that by entering the Phantom Tollbooth, Milo and his friends had the opportunity to visit many distinct lands.
Teacher tells students that along with the Unites States diverse terrains, our country’s makeup of fifty states varies in opinions, wants, and needs.
Tells students key campaign issues and the different perspectives of the citizens of the fifty states vary enormously.
Tells students it is important to understand the Electoral College and the importance of swing/battleground states.
Tells students they will take on the role of a political analyst, forecasting the electoral vote count for the presidential election.
Tells students they will be learning about campaign issues, the Electoral College, the role of swing states, and the importance of political participation.
|
Students listen
|
Phase 2: Demonstration, modeling, passing of information (I do it)
Teacher opens and displays the website: “Ben’s Guide to US Government for kids: http://bensguide.gpo.gov/index.html
Teacher tells students to take out their social studies journals.
Teacher demonstrates selecting 3-5 grade link on the Ben’s Guide. System displays topics on screen.
Teacher demonstrates selecting Election Process on 3-5 subject menu
Teacher demonstrates selecting President & Vice President Link
Teacher distributes the handout for explaining the process of electing a president. Tells them they will tape the handouts in their journals at the end of the lesson.
Teacher explains vocabulary to students:
Vote
Election
Map
Electoral College
color key
citizenship
Battleground state
Swing State
Primary
Caucus
Convention
Popular vote
Political Party
Republican
Democrate
Teacher reads aloud the handout, stopping to explain terms as she reads.
Teacher demonstrates how to open the interactive electoral map: http://www.270towin.com/
Teacher demonstrates how to identify the following on the map selecting 1988.
Electoral votes
Colors for party affiliation and w
How to identify swing/battleground states
The electoral votes for each party.
How to read the legend
|
Students place social studies journal and pencil on their desks.
Students write step to open 3-5 grade level link.
Students write step to open election process link
Students write notes for selecting President and Vice President Link
Students listen
Students write down vocabulary words in social studies journal, the definitions provided by the teacher, and write one sentence using the word.
Students take notes on handout
Students write notes for accessing the interactive electoral map
Students take notes for working with the interactive electoral map.
|
Phase3: Guided Practice (We do it)
Teacher then guides students and together they identify for the 1992 presidential election: electoral votes, party affiliations, swing/battleground states, electoral votes for each party and interpret the legend.
|
Students, listen, question, take notes.
|
Phase 4: Monitoring, providing feedback (They do it)
Teacher has students count off in sets of 4.
Teacher tells students they will now get a laptop out of the tech tools cart for working as a group.
Teacher tells students to logon to their computers
Teacher tells students they will not go to the electoral college interactive map at: http://www.270towin.com/
Teacher tells students to explore the 2008 campaign results. As they do talk about what they see and share questions, concerns, opinions.
As students work, teacher observes and monitors the discussions. The teacher is answering question, noting whether students are on task, and asking them to share their ideas and strategies. The teacher is also looking to see if the activity is intriguing, boring, and/or if students need further instruction and clarification allowing the teacher to plan, assist and/or adjust the lesson as necessary.
At the end of 15 minutes, the teacher calls the class back together.
|
Students count off
Students checkout laptop for each group and return to their group tables.
Students logon using appropriate security
Students open browser and surf to http://www.270towin.com/
Students begin exploring the 2008 results in their small groups for 15 minutes.
Students are prepared for large group directions.
|
Phase 5: Students work independently
Teacher tells students they will each create an electoral map, and graphic organizer (table) for the 2012 presidential elections. Students will need to make predictions.
Teacher distributes the two rubrics for this assignment found at the end of this document.
Teacher reviews the rubrics with the students and answers any questions.
|
|
Conclusion
Teacher posts all maps in the classroom.
|
Some of the students share their predictions and maps with the class.
|
Assessment
The teacher will be looking at each students table and electoral map, looking for the following:
Table
Clearly compares the swing states on the following: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, and demographic breakdown.
Contains a column indicating which way you think the state will vote.
A paragraph is included for each swing state explaining your decision
Graphic organizer is neat and easy to read.
Graphic organizer columns are labeled as follows: electoral votes, pertinent issues, key groups, voting history, demographic breakdown, and decision.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
Electoral Map
Each of the fifty states is labeled in its correct location.
All electoral votes are correctly labeled.
States are colored the appropriate color for their party affiliation.
Swing states are colored according to your decision.
Electoral votes are tallied and listed for each party.
An appropriate legend is included.
The title indicates the content of the map.
The title is clearly distinguishable using 16 font and underlining.
The map is neatly drawn. Lines are drawn with a ruler.
Final document has been edited for correct spelling, grammar, capitalization, and use of punctuation.
Share with your friends: |