Be SpectACTive!:
Towards the future of audience development in performing arts
Preface
In recent years, audience development and active spectatorship have emerged as trend topics in the field of performing arts. This is possibly also due to a (re)new(ed) interest from European cultural programmes, such as Creative Europe 2014-2020. This latter has put active audiences at the centre of its political agenda, stressing the need of including and implementing participatory activities in the programming of cultural institutions, in order to promote new models of European citizenship, shared governance and legitimacy.
Nevertheless, audience development and audience engagement strategies have increasingly been integrated in a spontaneous way into the programming of theatres and festivals, even though with different results and interpretations. At the same time, individuals and communities have started demanding a more active role within the cultural sector, especially since technological and societal changes led to the rise of a new figure: the prosumer.
This is the context in which Be SpectACTive! has been framed, with a view to carry forward a vision of inclusive participation and active citizenship in the field of the performing arts.
ACTivating cultural audiences across Europe
Be SpectACTive! is a European project co-funded by Creative Europe 2014-2020 programme that places active spectatorship in performing arts at its heart. The 4-year initiative took root in 2015, drawing together 9 countries and 12 partners with the aim to develop new models and ideas of participation, accessibility, interaction and social cohesion between artists, audiences and cultural organisations.
The two types of partners involved in the project are respectively:
-
8 performing arts institutions – mainly theatres and festivals - committed to expanding and enhancing audience development activities. Participant organisations are: LIFT Festival (UK), Kulturno Drustvo B-51 (Slovenia), CapoTrave/Kilowatt Festival (Italy), Tanec Praha (Czech Republic), Bakelit Multi Art Center (Hungary), York Theatre Royal (UK), Radu Stanca (Romania) and Domino Udruge (Croatia).
-
3 research centres in charge of overall project monitoring and reporting. The three research centres are two universities – Universitat de Barcelona (Spain) and Université de Montpellier (France) – and one independent centre (Fondazione Fitzcarraldo, Italy).
In addition to these, the project involves the participation of Comune di San Sepolcro (Italy), a local government agency, which is lead partner of Be SpectACTive!.
From an operational point of view, BeSpectACTive! revolves around three main lines of action:
-
Participatory Programming. Throughout the whole duration of the programme, 30 participatory workshops with local audiences will be set up, involving more than 1.000 European citizens in artistic decision-making processes. Participants will thus select and programme 108 shows that will be finally performed in 8 different European cities.
-
Creative residencies. This phase intends to connect audiences to artists' creative process through active participation in open rehearsals and other participatory activities. 12 companies will be working together with local audiences in 54 creative residencies, involving more than 150 artists during 500 days, in order to co-produce 3 live performances per year.
-
Web platform. Artists will have the opportunity to upload performances specifically designed for web use on an online platform, thus facilitating cross-media communication and stimulating a debate with web users. Each video performance is produced after three 15-days creative residencies at three different partners' venues, involving audiences in co-production processes both online and offline. Moreover, through development of an online forum, professionals and communities will be able to meet in a virtual agora, where to discuss about artistic contents and to share viewpoints.
Furthermore, 4 international conferences - one per year - will be held with aims to share project progress; to connect practitioners, performers, cultural organisations and general public with an interest in the subject of active spectatorship; and to reflect on the present and future of audience development and audience engagement in performing arts.
Results and learning outcomes from the project will be finally documented and disseminated through publications, with the purpose of sharing best practice and calling for further research.
ACTion research for ACTive spectatorship
To guarantee the quality of the project, the three research partners - Universitat de Barcelona (Spain), Université de Montpellier (France) and Fondazione Fitzcarraldo (Italy) - have been designated to conduct constant assessment and monitoring of project performance and related outcomes. The evaluation process is carried out through frequent research meetings, internal and public reports, ad hoc studies and field visits to project partners.
The methodology chosen to carry on the overall evaluation and monitoring process is action research, which involves active participation in a change situation, whilst simultaneously conducting research. This approach is particularly suitable for Be SpectACTive! specific themes and purposes, inasmuch as it implies bringing about change in some community/organisation/program, along with increasing understanding on the part of both the researchers and the participants (in this case artists, cultural audiences, local communities...). However, limitations may come from the subjective viewpoint of the participative observer, thus requiring possible integration with other methodologies.
Besides evaluation, research partners are also responsible for supporting performing arts organisations involved in Be SpectACTive! throughout the learning process, by better addressing their activities and enabling inter-group dialogue.
Specific research goals for each line of action are the following:
1. Participatory Programming:
-
To analyze profile and performance of active spectators involved at different levels in the activities;
-
To shed light on the set of expectations (at the beginning of the process), personal perceptions and self-assessment (at the end of the process) of local spectators involved in the project;
-
To assess enhancement of audiences' capacity to understand/follow the artistic process;
-
To assess exchanges and levels of interaction/satisfaction from the artistic perspective;
-
To raise feedbacks about the effectiveness of the program from the organizational viewpoint.
2. Creative residencies:
-
To evaluate how artistic creation is modified through diverse interaction with audiences;
-
To assess to what extent participatory approaches affect and modify the modus operandi of professionals during artistic creation process;
-
To determine effects and changes on professionals' competencies and skills throughout the process;
-
To analyze audience attending the international debut shows (profile, diversification...);
-
To raise feedbacks about the effectiveness of the program from the organizational viewpoint.
3. Web platform:
-
To determine the effectiveness of the web platform;
-
To profile Internet audiences and comparing web users with off-line audiences' profiles;
-
To evaluate the quality of interaction and engagement within the platform;
-
To assess artistic impacts stemming from digital experiences.
State of the art(s)
First research results emerging from field visits, questionnaires and interviews provide preliminary project insights. At this stage, only limited analysis is available and concerns solely the first two main actions of Be SpectACTive! Program – Participatory Programming and Creative Residencies. Nevertheless, exploratory review may reveal some interesting issues and make room for considerations.
Firstly, it has been noticed that different actions of the program present different rates of advancement, depending on a variety of factors:
-
Heterogeneity of the performing arts system (coexistence of well-structured organisations with others undergoing change or restructuring);
-
Difference in nature and attitude of the stakeholders, also in terms of dimension (different budget, staff and role within their environment);
-
Level of involvement by project partners with regard to Be SpectACTive! goals and objectives;
-
Degree of personalization of audience engagement actions and strategies;
-
Commitment to involving staff in decision making (delegated versus shared responsibilities);
-
Familiarity with tools for audience profiling.
Another important consideration regards timing. While Participatory Programming requires participants to take part in mid-long term activities - usually for periods of months – Creative Residencies call for intensive meetings in a limited time. This affects levels of participation and involvement in several ways.
First of all, in terms of trust between audiences and organisations, as relationships of trust need longer time frames and constant interaction. For example, Kilowatt's Visionari meet fortnightly to discuss in a collective way, whilst they dedicate a weekly informal meeting to watch their shows in small groups. Hence, participants are able to balance personal and work commitments with these meetings; while intensive participation requires more time and effort, thus for example discouraging full-time workers from taking part in the activities.
Second, in terms of responsibilities, as during Participatory Programming audiences are involved not just in the artistic decision-making process, but also in management and organisational activities. This approach may lead to disruptive practices, as it is the case of TakeOver, where the overall management of the festival is delegated to the young staff (all under 26). Therefore, theatres and festivals have the opportunity both to experiment new participatory forms and to trace a path for participants' professionalization.
An additional factor to take into account is the language component. While Participatory Programming initiatives employ local language to communicate, Creative Residencies may face some problems related to the use of English as vehicular language.
As the project is ongoing, many questions remain open. Most importantly, researchers will have to verify whether in the long term Be SpectACTive! will be able to influence European cultural policies with a strong orientation to active citizenship, extending the benefits of the initiative beyond the fields of arts and culture.
Share with your friends: |