Economic Evaluation of an Investment in Medical Websites and Medical Web-Based Services 1
Table of Contents 3
Table of Tables 3
Table of Figures 4
Acknowledgements 5
Publications 6
Abstract 7
Chapter 1: Introduction 8
1 Research Contribution, Aims and Objectives 10
2 Research Design 10
3Thesis Outline 12
4 Challenges of the Research 14
Chapter 2: Literature Review 16
1.1 Introduction 16
5Economic Evaluation in Healthcare 16
5.1Evaluation and Accountability 18
2.2.2 Complexivity and Reflexivity in Healthcare Evaluation 19
6 Evaluation of Medical Websites and Medical Web-Based Services 20
6.1Medical Websites and Medical Web-Based Services 22
7 Cost-Benefit Analysis 28
7.1Cost-Benefit Analysis in HealthCare 30
7.2Issues Concerning Cost-Benefit Analysis Web-Based Services 31
8 Return on Investment (ROI) 39
8.1ROI in IT and Technology Investments 40
8.2ROI in Healthcare 41
8.3Benefits of ROI 42
8.4Concerns, Myths and Barriers of ROI Application 43
9 Willingness to Pay (WTP) 44
9.1Willingness to Pay vs. Human Capital Approach vs. Quality Adjusted Life Years 49
9.2Biases and Other Issues Encountered While Using WTP Approach 50
10 Concluding Remarks from the Extant Literature Examination 51
Chapter 3: Methodology 54
11 Introduction 54
1.1 Research Philosophies within the Information Systems (IS) Discipline 54
1.2 Research Methodology 55
1.2.1Investigation in Success and Failure Factors for the Market Of Medical Web-Based Services 55
1.2.2Cost-Benefit Analysis and ROI 60
1.2.3Applying Evaluation Methods 68
Chapter 4: A New Holistic Evaluation Framework 71
12Towards the Formation of a Holistic Framework for the Evaluation of an Investment on the Medical Web Interventions 71
1.2.4The Developed Holistic Evaluation Framework 78
13Concluding Remarks 81
Chapter 5: Success and Failure Factors of Medical Websites 82
14 Introduction 82
15 Sample Formation 83
16Variable Formation 84
17 Data Descriptive Metrics/Statistics 89
17.1Popular Revenue Models in the Medical Websites 91
18Factors of Excellence and Enhanced Survivability 93
18.1Searching For the Factors that Affect the Global Rank of the Medical Websites 93
18.2The Highest and Lowest Globally Ranked Medical Websites 96
18.3Factors that Affect Survivability of the Medical Websites 110
18.4Other Factors that Affect the Excellence and the Survivability of the Medical Websites 112
18.5Factors that Affect the Offering of Interactive Web Applications/ Services 125
19 Chapter’s Concluding Remarks 126
Chapter 6: Assessing the value of an investment in Medical Websites 128
20 Introduction 128
21 Key Stakeholder Identification 129
21.1Key Stakeholders’ Identification and Description 129
21.2Relationship between the Medical Websites and the Stakeholders 131
22 Assessing the “Benefits” 133
22.1WTP versus Human Capital Approach and QALYs 133
22.2Survey Formation 135
22.3Willingness to Pay Questions Formation 137
22.4Participants Recruitment 138
22.5Survey’s Data Analysis 139
22.6Analysis by Question 142
23 Assessing the “Costs” 153
24 Cost Benefit Analysis and Return on Investment Estimation 154
24.1Cost-Benefit Analysis of the Medical Websites Offering Medical Web-Based Services 154
24.2Return on Investment of the Medical Websites Offering Medical Web-Based Services 156
25 Concluding Remarks 156
Chapter 7: Discussion and Concluding Remarks 159
26 Research Summary 159
27 Research Contributions 162
28 Current Research Limitations 166
29 Future Research Directions 167
30 Personal Reflections 168
Appendix A: Statement of Ethics Approval 169
Appendix B: Willingness to Pay Survey 171
Appendix C: Medical Websites Dataset 179
References 192
There are many people who helped me accomplish this thesis. First of all my parents Athanasios Xydopoulos and Vasiliki Karageorgou, and my uncles Dimitrios and Konstantinos Karageorgos who supported me and funded most of my PhD studies. I would like also to thank my aunt Anastasia Karageorgou for her continuous prays that helped me to overcome every obstacle in my way.
Moreover, I would like to thank my colleagues in room SJ127 for their support and help. More specifically I would like to express my gratitude to Georgios (“Geeko”) Ioannou for his general support and the infinite moment of laugh that offered to me, Konstantina (“The Crazy”) Vasileiou for her emotional support as well as Konstantina (“The Cretan”) Spanaki for her patience support and delicious food and sweets.
I would like to thank also my friends Chrisros (“Barclay”) Barkoukis, Alexis (“The winner”) Georgiadis, and Dimitrios (“The Roque”) Karagiozidis, Anastasia (“The Zouzou”) Goutzioti and Christos (“The Sting”) Tsibas for their support and the endless hours they spent hearing me nagging for my research.
Finally, I am grateful to all the people from the Faculty of Business Economics and Law of Surrey University, and the Department of Information Systems and Computing (DISC) of Brunel University, not only for their logistic, financial and academic support, but mostly for the level of friendship and respect I was constantly experiencing during my studies.