Sbsp affirmative- arl lab- ndi 2011

SBSP Affirmative- ARL Lab- NDI 2011 1

Plan 2

1AC Oil Advantage (First Draft) 3

1AC Warming Advantage 13

1AC Heg Advantage 21

1AC Solvency Contention 27

***Oil Advantage*** 29

***General Solvency*** 30

SBSP solves Oil 31

Solves quickly/Now is key 32

***Peak Oil/Inherency*** 33

Dependence Increasing 34

High Prices/Shocks Inevitable 35

Peak Oil = true 36

***Economy*** 39

Oil Dependence kills the Economy 40

Solvency- Economy 44

***Middle East Oil*** 45

Inh- ME oil imports now 46

ME Dependence = War 48

ME Dependence Bad- laundry list 50

ME Dependence = Terrorism 53

SBSP solves ME Oil dependence 54

***Resource Wars*** 55

Oil Dependence  Resource Wars 56

SBSP solves Resource Wars 57

Resource wars turn all other impacts 59

***Oil Impacts*** 60

Turns heg 61

Turns Terrorism/Anti-Americanism 62

China War 63

Iran War 64

Environment 65

Democracy 66

***Russia Add On*** 67

***AT: Russian Oil DA*** 69

No link- transition will be slow 70

Price Volatility Inevitable 71

No Diversification now 72

Russian Econ Defense 73

Russia War Defense 75

***Warming Advantage*** 77

***Solvency*** 78

SBSP solves Warming 79

AT: SBSP not sufficient 82

AT: SBSP causes warming 83

AT: too late to solve/warming inevitable 84

***Top Level Nuts and Bolts*** 86

Warming is Fast 87

Warming = Existential Threat 88

Our EV most qualified 89

***Warming Impacts*** 90

Laundry List Impact 91

Turns Hegemony 92

2AC Resource Wars 93

2AC Protectionism 94

2AC US Russia War 95

2AC Navy 96

2AC Middle East War 97

2AC African War 98

2AC Ocean Acidification 99

2AC Amazon 101

2AC Water Wars 103

2AC Indo-Pak War 104

Biodiversity 106

Ocean Biodiversity 108

African Biodiversity 109

***AT: Warming Good*** 111

AT: CO2 Ag-Defense- Uniqueness 112

AT: CO2 Ag- Defense- Warming Outweighs 113

AT: CO2 Ag- Offense 117

AT: CO2 Ag- Prefer our ev 119

AT: Ice Age 120

AT: Ice Age- SBSP solves 121

AT: Ice Age- Warming causes it 122

AT: Ice Age- Timeframe 125

AT: Ice Age- Probability 126

AT: SO2 Screw 127

*** Warming = Anthropogenic*** 128

CO2 Key 129

AT: Water Vapor More 130

AT: Solar Variations 131

AT: Solar Variations (Mars) 132

AT: Cosmic Rays 133

AT: Milankovitch Cycles 134

AT: El Nino 135

AT: Ozone Hole 137

AT: Volcanoes 138

AT: CO2 from Oceans 139

***Warming Indicators** 140

AT: Balloons/Satellites 141

AT: Satellites 142

AT: Balloons/Satellites 143

AT: Iris Hypothesis 144

AT: Stopped in 1998 145

AT: Antarctic Cooling 146

AT: Sunspot Hibernation 147

AT: 1934 148

AT: Oceans 149

AT: Ocean Sinks 150

AT: Biomass 151

*** Positive Feedbacks *** 152

AT: Forests 153

AT: Water Vapor 154

AT: Clouds 155

AT: Carbon Sinks 156

AT: Plankton 157

***Hegemony Advantage*** 159

***Readiness Extensions*** 160

1ac worthy Inh/Link card 161

FF kills flexibility 162

FF  vulnerabilities 165

SBSP solves Flexibility 167

Flex key to heg 168

FF kills Rapid Response/Effectiveness 169

Rapid Response key to heg 171

FF undermine Basing 172

SBSP solves Basing 173

Basing impacts 175

Fwd Deployments key to heg 177

Now key time 178

***Budget Extensions*** 179

FF kill the budget 180

Budget key to heg 182

SBSP solves Budget 184

Perception 186

Funding Tradeoff 187

***Radar/Lasers*** 189

Radar Scenario 190

ASATs Scenario 192

Ext- SBSP solves radar 194

Ext- Radar key to capabilities 196

Ext- SBSP solves ASATs 197

SBSP key to UAVs 198

SBSP key to lasers/BMD 199

***Space Leadership*** 200

Space Leadership Scenario 201

Ext- Solves space leadership 204

***Other Heg Internal Links*** 205

Military Technologies 206

*** Add Ons/Ideas *** 208

***Water*** 209

2ac Water Scarcity Add On 210

Ext- Scarcity now  conflict 212

Ext- SSP Solves Water 213

***Ideas-need impacts*** 214

Chinese Economy 215

Aerospace 216

Commercial Space Industry 217

Nuke Power 219

Competitiveness 220

Colonization 221

***Solvency*** 223

US Key 224

Technologically Feasible 225

Deployed Quickly 227

SBSP solves energy needs 228

Space better than Ground 231

Better than other renewables 232

AT: Nuke Power Solves 235

Nuke Power Bad 238

AT: Natural Gas Solves 240

***2AC*** 244

***Politics*** 245

Plan pop- Bipart 246

2AC Plan popular- Defense Industry 247

Ext-Military loves the plan 248

Plan popular- Public 250

2AC Plan Popular- NASA Transition Team 251

2AC Plan Popular- Tea Party 252

Plan Popular- Renewables Lobby 254

Plan Popular- Swing States 257

AT: Spending is unpopular 258

Plan Unpopular-General 259

Plan Unpopular- Fossil Fuel Lobby 260

***NASA Trade-Off*** 261

N/U Cuts Now 262

Link N/U 263

No Trade-off Link 264

Cut Webb Telescope instead 266

AT: Earth Science Impact 267

***AT: Launches/Debris*** 268

N/U Launches now 269

N/U Collisions now 271

N/U Cascade Now 272

Link turn- SBSP solves 273

AT: Debris turns the case 274

AT: Launches bad-Ozone 275

SBSP solves Satellite Operability 276

***Other Disads*** 277

AT: Weaponization 278

AT: Commercialization DA 280

AT: US oil DA 281

***Counterplans*** 282

***AT: EU CP and Soft Power NB*** 283

No Solvency 284

Soft Power NB N/U 287

Soft Power Alternative Causality 288

***AT: Prizes CP*** 292

Prizes Bad 293

Solvency Deficit- R&D 296

AT: Prizes CP- Perm Solves 297

***AT Consult CPs*** 298

Unilateral Action key 299

Delay- Now is key 300

Perm solves 301

Theory- Consult Illegit 302

***Other CPs*** 303

AT: Private Sector CPs 304

AT: Goals CP 306

AT: Agent CPs 310