Abbott, Rachael, Victoria University of Wellington; Ben Bell


When the policy tool fails: Explaining Land Use Change in Protected Areas



Download 3.46 Mb.
Page51/66
Date19.10.2016
Size3.46 Mb.
#4989
1   ...   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   ...   66

When the policy tool fails: Explaining Land Use Change in Protected Areas

Land use change is one of the major threats faced by protected areas. Based on in depth interviews with 55 protected area managers from 17 countries in the Americas this paper systematically analyzes the influence of demographic, economic, institutional, governance and policy factors on land use change. The findings indicate that land use change in protected areas is critically driven by the lack of policy integration between environmental, development and social agencies. Protected areas often swim against the current as other governmental agencies invest resources and provide incentives to the neighboring communities that increase land use change. The findings also indicate that land use change can be reduced through the development of sustainable livelihood projects by protected areas. Surprisingly, economic welfare of neighboring communities does not play a significant role explaining land use change.



Rodriguez, Jon Paul, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Cientificas; David Keith, University of New South Wales; Edmund Barrow, International Union for Conservation of Nature; Kathryn Rodriguez-Clark, Instituto Venezolano de Investigacines Cientificas; Maria Oliveira-Miranda, Provita; Patrick Comer, NatureServe; Emily Nicholson, The University of Melbourne
IUCN Red List of Ecosystems: tests of this new global standard for applying conservation science to environment and development policies

The 2008 World Conservation Congress of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), launched the IUCN Red List of Ecosystems (RLE). After an initial stage of designing and testing draft categories and criteria for assessing ecosystem risk of collapse, the revised version became available in 2013. Applicable to terrestrial, freshwater, marine and subterranean ecosystems at multiple spatial and temporal scales, the criteria focus on reductions in geographical distribution, restricted extent, degradation of the abiotic environment and disruption of biotic processes. We present initial results of the first continental test of the RLE, applied to the Americas (Alaska to Patagonia). The analysis was undertaken both as a top-down and a bottom-up exercise. The top-down approach, mainly science-driven, began with development of a map of ecosystem units of the Americas, whose status was assessed by the proportion of extant natural vegetation and recent changes in their distribution. The bottom-up approach began with a meeting of national-level policy-makers from Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador and Peru, asked to consider what they would use an ecosystem red list for. Their input informed national-level risk assessments, anchored on local data sources, needs and expertise. Integration of the regional analysis with national perspectives provides a broader context to the local risk assessment, enhancing the role of RLE on environment and development policies.



Rodriguez-Clark, Kathryn, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Cientificas; Ada Sanchez-Mercado, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Cientificas; Jose Ferrer-Paris, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Cientificas; Shaenandhoa Garcia-Rangel, Universidad Simón Bolívar; Edgard Yerena, Universidad Simon Bolivar; Bruce Robertson, Bard College
A novel combination of habitat and threat models can reveal potential ecological traps

Ecological traps can threaten the persistence of affected populations, so techniques to predict and map potential traps are needed. However, existing methods provide no estimate of spatial uncertainty. Here we present a novel method for visualizing potential ecological traps and their uncertainty at large scales in a natural landscape, and demonstrate its application using presence data for Andean bears (Tremarctos ornatus, Ursidae) in the Cordillera de Mérida, Venezuela. We applied a partitioning procedure to generate partially independent datasets, and used them to fit maximum likelihood models of the probability of occupancy. These were combined with an existing model of hunting risk to predict potential trap location and uncertainty. The best habitat suitability model predicted high suitability in the center and in northern parts of Cordillera de Mérida, as expected from expert opinion. However, more than a third of suitable area had a high potential trap index, and was next to or within the largest national parks. Conservation actions for Andean bears may be planned more effectively following field confirmation of trap predictions. Managers should avoid increasing connectivity between trap and safe habitat, and focus targeted education and law enforcement in confirmed trap habitat. Our approach will be useful in other species for identifying possible ecological traps created by hunting and other human activities at the landscape level



Rodríguez-Estrella, Ricardo, Centro de Investigaciones Biológicas del Noroeste; Lucía Campos, Centro de Investigaciones Biológicas del Noroeste; Laura Rivera, Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa
Fishing scallops, oysters and associated epifauna in Baja California Peninsula: Loss of non-officially recorded biodiversity

Scallops, oysters and other mollusks are annually collected by local fisheries of Baja California Peninsula. Fisheries extractions of scallops and clams have officially reached ca. 6000 tons/year. Although evaluations have been made in order to determine the potential impact of fisheries in scallops and mollusk populations, it has not been evaluated the "parallel" impacts of fishing on epibionts or associated biological diversity to shells. In 2005, we randomly collected 1500 shells of scallops and oysters from shell dumps scattered located in Bahia Magdalena and identified and quantified the numbers of epifaunal groups (e.g. polychaetes, barnacles). More than 60% of epifaunal species were counted in scallop shells and 36% in oyster shells. However, more than 50% of scallop shells contained epifaunal groups while only 5% of oyster shells contained them. We estimated the impact of the total extraction of scallops during every year and found that deep impacts on this biological diversity are occurring. We stress the need to better evaluate the neglected impacts on structure and function of communities given by fisheries when the loss of epifauna occurs.



Rohlf, Dan, Lewis and Clark University
The Evolution Of US Policy On Endangered Species Recovery Since Passage Of The ESA

When enacting the Endangered Species Act in 1973, Congress emphasized recovery of species facing extinction as the statute’s primary purpose. In the statute’s early years, lawmakers emphasized this goal by amending the statute to require preparation of recovery plans, allow for public participation in plan development, and require that recovery plans set forth both site-specific recovery measures and “objective, measureable criteria” to define when a species has recovered. Implementing recovery plans has faced many obstacles, however, including delays in plan preparation, funding shortfalls for recovery actions, and determinations that the measures set forth in recovery plans are merely discretionary even for federal agencies. Other challenging questions about recovery arise as the ESA enters its fifth decade, such as whether species dependent on human intervention in some facet of their life cycle can be termed recovered, and how to deal with uncertainties caused by climate change. Finally, a 2012 court decision giving federal agencies broad discretion to delist species as recovered regardless of whether the species has attained the criteria set forth in its recovery plan raises anew the fundamental question of when it means to “recover” imperiled species.



Rolhf, Dan, Lewis and Clark Law School

Prospects for Progress
The Endangered Species Act -- Still Vigorous at 40?--The State of the ESA on its 40th Anniversary and

Roman, Joe, Gund Institute Ecological Economics
Applying ecosystem service valuation tools to environmental policy and decision-making

There is a critical need to link our understanding of ecosystem-service flows to policies that ensure their sustainable delivery. Ecosystem accounting provides one method for organizing and integrating information about how humans and nature interact. Such a framework can detail the interactions of a specific ecosystem, characterizing ecosystem-service flows, evaluating tradeoffs, and comparing projected outcomes of alterative management strategies. Ecosystem accounting models, such as the Multiscale Integrated Model of Ecosystem Services (MIMES) and InVEST, can be made spatially explicit and dynamic to account for variations in time, space, and decision-making. Although these models tend to be limited in their ability to directly inform stakeholders--since running them requires a high level of technical know-how and software requirements--new user interfaces have been designed to overcome this hurdle and allow stakeholders to explore various scenarios. Several case studies will be discussed, including the evaluation of tradeoffs for the Massachusetts Ocean Plan and efforts to revise economic analyses of critical habitat under the U.S. Endangered Species Act and other assessments required for most agency regulations by the White House Office of Management and Budget. Although these tools are still in development, their analyses are vastly preferable to overlooking ecosystem-service information when making policy decisions, which risks assigning a zero value to all services.



Romanach, Stephanie, U.S. Geological Survey; Craig Conzelmann, U.S. Geological Survey; Kevin Suir, U.S. Geological Survey; Christina Hunnicutt, U.S. Geological Survey; Mark McKelvy, U.S. Geological Survey; Sumani Chimmula, University of Louisana
EverVIEW data visualization software designed for Everglades restoration decision-making, used internationally

Methods developed in the Greater Everglades are influencing restoration programs worldwide. Joint Ecosystem Modeling (JEM) has facilitated collaboration among federal and state agencies, universities, and NGOs, resulting in a suite of software tools to help with restoration decision making. EverVIEW Data Viewer provides side-by-side map panels to compare model output and simultaneously examine species or habitat impacts from alternative restoration plans. Other uses include multiple geographic or temporal displays. Animations highlight general trends in model output over time, e.g., changes from wet to dry seasons. An extensible framework to EverVIEW allows for customized tools to analyze model outputs in a spatial context. By introducing metadata standards and producing standards-compliant model output, national programs have leveraged models, tools, and source code within the EverVIEW platform. JEM products are being used in: 1) USDA's Natural Resources Conservation Service's Conservation Effects Assessment Project, 2) State of Louisiana's Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority Coastal Master Plan, and 3) United States Army Corps of Engineers and South Florida Water Management District's Central Everglades Planning Project. Informally, EverVIEW has been adopted by researchers in several parts of the world. JEM remains committed to its standards-driven philosophy to allow products to be relevant well beyond the Everglades.



Romero, Jorge Alvarez, ARC COE for Coral Reef Studies
Marine conservation planning in practice: lessons learned from the Gulf of California

Overfishing, pollution, coastal development and climate change threaten marine biodiversity globally and compromise the services that marine ecosystems provide. Systematic conservation planning (SCP) provides a framework to identify areas where actions can be effective in addressing these threats, while minimizing the costs of interventions. We investigated the application of SCP in the Gulf of California, a marine hotspot where seven spatial prioritization exercises have been undertaken. We found that the use of SCP methods has progressed slowly (gaps include planning for land-sea connections and ecosystem services) and highlighted benefits and difficulties of undertaking SCP. According to experts, the implementation of new marine protected areas (MPAs) in the region has been influenced by some of the planning exercises. However, uptake of planning outputs has progressed slowly due to multiple factors (e.g., conflicting mandates and interests between organizations, limited technical capacities and resources, insufficient political commitment). Apart from MPAs, other benefits included: developing institutional skills and knowledge; improving collaboration and coordination between organizations; converging on the need to assess priorities for marine conservation in regional context; and building trust among organizations. The existence of multiple marine conservation plans in the region highlighted some of the complexities and benefits of having multiple sets of priorities.



Romulo, Chelsie, Virginia Tech; Miriam Westervelt, Virginia Tech; Amanda Miner, Virginia Tech; Dennis Sonkoi, Virginia Tech
Community Based Forest Conservation in Kenya
This project is a case study in natural resource conservation planning with the Loita Maasai tribe of southwestern Kenya. Due to the traditional nomadic lifestyle and small population of the Maasai in this region, most of the forest and surrounding rangelands are undeveloped. Some of the forest is experiencing increasing threats from resource extraction and development. As Maasai continue to transition from a predominantly pastoral nomadic lifestyle to a mixed farming economy there is an urgent need for a conservation and land use management plan to conserve Loita's ecological integrity. Attempts to provide the community with forest management plans have been rejected in the past on the basis of lack of community involvement. During the spring semester of 2011 a team of 3 students created a preliminary plan using the Open Standards for the Practice of Conservation. This plan provided the basis for a 3-day workshop with the Loita Maasai Council of Elders to assist the community in developing their own plan for resource conservation. With guidance from the authors, the Council employed Participatory Rural Appraisal methods to share their local knowledge of resource use and to plan for the future. The final plan identified biodiversity targets (lion, elephant, olive tree), threats (energy demand, drought, agriculture), and adaptive management strategies (education, compensation). The authors plan to continue the project by engaging the community in a second planning workshop.

Root-Bernstein, Meredith, Oxford University
Interactions between qualitative methods and complexity modelling: a case study of conservation in the Espinal

Complexity modelling has lent concepts and analytical tools to conservationists interested in systems approaches. While feedback, lags, scaling, emergence or historicity describe some macro aspects of socio-ecological systems, they lead to few actionable predictions. We need to focus on core properties unique to socio-ecological systems, such as context-dependence, hierarchical control of behavior, and constructed niches. These properties problematize the idea of the unit as integral and invariant, and complicate modelling multiple interacting units. Qualitative social sciences methods are better equiped to consider these "complicated" interactions, and may already use complex systems thinking. I show how three qualitative concepts, practice, foreshadowing, and emergent properties of objects, can inform a complex-systems approach to modelling complicated conservation conflicts. I provide concrete examples of their application from my research on conservation in a silvopastoral system, the espinal of Chile. Practice means behaviors enter the repertoire in context-dependent groups, preventing tree lovers from supporting conservation of espinals. Foreshadowing means the future has "already happened" in the past, and results in conservationists focusing effort on areas of lower conservation priority. Finally, the emergent properties of objects such as rodent burrows and runways increase biodiversity, while those of cars reduce perceptions of it.



Rose, Eli, North Carolina Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, NCSU; Theodore Simons, US Geological Survey, North Carolina Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit
Using remotely sensed fire severity indices to predict bird distributions in southern Appalachian forests; an occupancy modeling approach

Prescribed fire is increasingly used to reduce fuel loads and improve conditions for wildlife. Nevertheless, landscape scale fire effects are often highly variable and difficult to quantify. Recent advances in the application of remotely sensed information are providing new tools for assessing habitat changes associated with fire. We illustrate the application of several fire severity metrics to models of avian distribution and abundance. We develop occupancy models for six avian species using habitat and burn severity co-variates and avian point count data collected in Great Smoky Mountains National Park during May and June 2012. Three species are associated with early succession habitats and three associated with late succession habitats. Overstory cover, difference Normalized Burn Ratios, and field derived fire severity metrics were consistently found among top models. Our results suggest that remotely sensed fire severity metrics can be a useful predictor of occupancy probability for five of the six species modeled.



Rose, Robert, Wildlife Conservation Society; Allison Leidner, NASA Earth Science division; David Wilkie, Wildlife Conservation Society
Identifying the Top 10 Conservation Challenges that Can Be Answered Through Remote Sensing Technologies

Remote sensing plays a vital role in helping the conservation community monitor threats to the planet's ecological systems. With rapid advancements in remote sensing technology and increasing rates of ecosystem degradation, there is a need to both help the conservation community best use remote sensing to address the most critical environmental challenges and help the remote sensing community better understand what imagery and tools would most contribute to conservation activities. With support from NASA, the Wildlife Conservation Society organized a workshop that brought together 32 leaders from the conservation and remote sensing communities, representing the academic, government and NGO sectors, in order to address these needs. The goals of the workshop were to: identify the 10 highest priority conservation challenges that could be resolved using remote sensing technologies; renew relationships within the community to address these challenges; and outline a process to re-energize a conservation remote sensing working group. During the workshop, the 300+ challenges were narrowed down to the top ten. In addition, workshop participants outlined a plan to develop a conservation remote sensing working group. This session will review the process used to conjure the initial questions and distill the list to 10, present the results, and discuss the implications of making the list broadly available to the conservation, remote sensing and donor communities.



Rose, Naomi, Humane Society of the US
Human Dimensions in Marine Mammal Science

It should be a truth universally acknowledged that many problems in conservation have little to do with science but rather with human perceptions, opinions and values. In the case of marine mammals, some communities may value them as food, whereas in others they are valued as cultural icons. Public sentiment can run very high, whether marine mammals are considered competitors for fish, or species that must be protected at all costs, regardless of what science might show. In many, but not all, developed countries, marine mammals (especially cetaceans) occupy a special place in the public psyche and numerous studies have shown an elevated concern for marine mammal conservation, regardless of their actual conservation status. For example, one U.K. study found that 40% of the public would view more favorably, and more likely vote for, a politician who proposed a law specifically for the protection of cetaceans. In the past, such public opinion led to the passage of laws such as the 1972 US Marine Mammal Protection Act. Conservation interventions involving marine mammals that approach situations from a purely scientific standpoint, without considering the human dimension, are almost certainly doomed to failure; for example, the current stalemate at the International Whaling Commission and the failure of conservation attempts related to endangered marine mammals such as the Yangtze River dolphin.



Rosenthal, Amy, Natural Capital Project at the World Wildlife Fund; Emily McKenzie, Natural Capital Project at WWF
Why Every Conservation Scientist Should Have a SPI, or Making Conservation Science Matter in the Anthropocene

"SPI" is the science-policy interface, the mechanisms and routes through which conservation science results have the potential to be applied in management and policy decisions. Despite the potential, many conservation science studies remain locked away in journal articles and fail to be taken up by decision makers. This failure is the result of a variety of challenges, e.g. low salience to decisions, perceived illegitimacy, unclear or mis-communication, inappropriate endpoints, or poor framing or visualization of study and results. Fortunately, there are strategic ways to overcome these challenges, as long as conservation scientists are willing to take a systemic approach. The Natural Capital Project and the World Wildlife Fund have done just this, pioneering a transdisciplinary SPI program that focuses on emerging ecosystem service science. In this talk, we explore the world of SPIES, identifying how this work can ensure better science and uptake of results, with a focus on the key areas of framing, scenario development, stakeholder engagement, selecting appropriate endpoints, and lessons learned.



Rosson, James, USDA Forest Service; Southern Research Station; Anita Rose, USDA Forest Service; Southern Research Station
Mortality Impact of the Hemlock Woolly Adelgid in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park

The hemlock woolly adelgid (Adelges tsugae Annand) (HWA) is native to Japan and China and was first discovered in North America in British Columbia in the 1920's. The Park Service discovered HWA near Fontana Dam in 2002 and since then it has spread throughout the Great Smoky Mountains National Park (GSMNP), killing many hemlocks and leaving a devastating visual impact to park visitors. We used landscape-level data from the USDA Forest Service, Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) program to statistically assess the impact of the HWA and describe the current status of Tsuga canadensis (L.) Carr. in the GSMNP. Individual T. canadensis trees ≥ 12.7 cm in dbh were tracked on sample units systematically located across the GSMNP and measured between 1998 and 2011. For all species, there were 2,892 dead and live trees ≥ 12.7 cm dbh measured on 83, 0.674 ha sample units; 304 of these were T. canadensis spread across 50 of the sample units. The mortality rate of T. canadensis for the period, between 1998 and 2011, was 26 percent, the highest of any tree in the park. Of all dead trees in the park, 16.9 percent were T. canadensis followed by Picea rubens Sarg. at 11.6 percent. For live trees, as of 2011, T. canadensis ranked second behind Acer rubrum L. in the total tree population but ranked eighth in trees ≥ 20.0 cm dbh. The continued loss of this keystone species in the GSMNP will provide an open niche for other species and dramatically alter forest structure and communities.



Rostal, Melinda, EcoHealth Alliance
USAID PREDICT Wildlife Surveillance in Mexico and Brazil

PREDICT is a USAID funded global zoonotic disease surveillance of wildlife program designed to detect new viruses and predict viruses of zoonotic potential. Wildlife disease surveillance is important to human and domestic animal health; 70% of emerging infectious diseases are reported to be of animal origin, and of that, 75% have wildlife origins. PREDICT uses ecological modeling to target surveillance for emerging infectious diseases based on global “hotspots for emergence” and targeting high-risk wildlife species at human- wildlife interfaces. Standard protocols for field and laboratory techniques have been developed to generate comparable data across 20 countries on three continents. This presentation focuses on the progress of PREDICT in Mexico and Brazil after three years, including the development of a surveillance program that is scalable to country level, discovery of new viruses, interactions with the universities and national governments and characterizing human-wildlife contact.


Roth, Robin, York University; Brian Thom, University of Victoria
Idle No More: Best Practices and Lessons Learned from Indigenous Conservation Partnerships in Canada

It is necessary to build successful conservation partnerships with indigenous communities and yet concrete examples of how to do so from the perspective of indigenous peoples are difficult to encounter. This paper recounts the findings from a research project that focused on the best practices and lessons learned from indigenous conservation partnerships in Canada. We present the key findings from our detailed conversations with community leaders and practitioners who have built and worked within successful partnerships. Our findings point to essential elements, from the legal context of partnership arrangements, to strategies for incorporating indigenous knowledge and cultural practice, to the values embodied within interpersonal relationships while navigating these complex matters. The results are hopeful and demonstrate that meaningful conservation partnerships with indigenous communities are possible. And they are timely, as indigenous movements around the world, such as Idle No More in Canada, have renewed a debate about the recognition of aboriginal and treaty rights, the role of indigenous peoples environmental decision-making and governance, and the importance of partnerships between indigenous and settler communities. These questions have been central to the on-going collaborations between indigenous peoples and their conservation partners. The paper contributes to a renewed practice that can respond to the demands of indigenous peoples that we be idle no more.



Ruch, Jeff, Public Employees for Env'l Respons
Federal Scientific Integrity Policies: On Paper and In Practice

Reacting to the perceived abuses under his predecessor, in March 2009, less than two months into his tenure, President Obama issued a directive banning political manipulation of governmental science. This directive also required all science-based agencies to adopt policies for ensuring that the integrity of scientific and technical data, analysis and conclusions produced are safeguarded from suppression or inappropriate alteration. The resultant policies, for the first time, conferred a legal status on both the content and treatment of technical documents, as well as legal protections for scientists and other specialists who create them. They also purported to limit the ability of political appointees and senior managers to “create their own set of facts.” This presentation provides a broad comparison of the scientific integrity polices ultimately adopted by federal agencies, including how they differ in scope and application. This will be followed by a description of how these policies have actually operated in a handful of high-profile cases involving complaints of scientific misconduct, in violation of the policies adopted by the U.S. Department of Interior and the National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration. The presentation will conclude with recommendations for strengthening these policies and closing glaring gaps.



Russell, Gareth, New Jersey Institute of Technology; Joseph Wilder, Rutgers University
An underwater, camera-based, automatic identification system for coral reef fish: a prototype of a continuous monitoring network for reef populations

Coral reefs around the world are in decline, but monitoring reef communities is costly and time-consuming. We developed an underwater camera system that can identify coral reef fish to species as they swim past. The system was deployed in a large aquarium with a simulated Caribbean reef environment, and captured image sequences that, over a two-month period, included 16 species. A tracking algorithm located individual swimming fish, which were segmented from the frame. Basic shape statistics were used to select the 'best' (most side-on) images from an individual sequence, and a number of shape, color and texture features were extracted. These were then classified via trained neural nets organized in a hierarchical manner to progressively eliminate errors. Using independent testing sets, each of the eight 'common' species (accounting for 93% of the observations) were correctly identified at least 95% of the time. (The rarer species were lumped as 'unknown,' with their images being stored for later identification by hand.) A system like this could provide a network of reef census stations operating many hours a day. The output would have high statistical power for detecting changes in reef fish populations, providing an early warning system for reef impacts. It would also improve in accuracy and scope as the database of images grew. While our prototype system proved the principle, it was not fully ocean-worthy. The remaining challenges are largely those of marine engineering.



Russell, Kimberly, New Jersey Institute of Technology; Sarah Kornbluth, Rutgers University
Integrated Vegetation Management in Powerline Rights-of-way Provides Quality Habitat for Native Bees

Evidence from Europe and the U.S. suggests a recent decline in the abundance and diversity of native bees (Potts et al. 2010). Increasing habitat that provides forage and nesting sites could boost struggling populations in the U.S., particularly in urban, suburban and agricultural landscapes. The millions of acres beneath US powerlines are kept free of tall-growing vegetation to meet Federal Energy Regulatory Commission standards, and hence have the potential to provide suitable habitat for most native species. Prior work (Russell et al. 2005) demonstrated that bee communities in easements managed using Integrated Vegetation Management (IVM) were more diverse than in nearby annually mowed areas. To further evaluate the impact of vegetation management, we conducted a two-year study in cooperation with three power companies across the U.S. (BGE in Maryland, BPA in Oregon, ATC in Wisconsin). Bee communities within rights-of-way managed by periodic mowing on a 1, 2 or 4 year rotation were compared to sites managed using either IVM, seeding, or planting, and also to other open habitats near the ROW. Regional differences were profound, but bee richness was higher in the IVM sites than either open or mowed sites. Bee diversity tracked estimated nest site diversity measured using a combination of quadrat sampling and nest box colonization. We conclude that IVM creates quality habitat for native bees, especially in a powerline context that includes connectivity and relative stability.



Russell, Diane, USAID
Evidence and evaluation in conservation program design: USAID's experience

The US Agency for International Development is a major investor in international conservation with over two decades of programming experience. This paper describes how USAID has employed evaluation findings and other data to inform design of new programs. Examples include evaluations of the Global Conservation Program, the Central African Regional Program on the Environment and the Liberia Land Rights and Community Forestry Program as well as evidence from applied research and “stocktaking,” international fora, and partner consultations. Evaluation and evidence-based programming has growing prominence within the Agency. As such, the Forestry and Biodiversity Office launched a new program “Measuring Impact” (MI) that links improvements in and insights from evaluation, monitoring, and adaptive management to program design. MI is working with USAID/Washington and several USAID Missions on specific evaluations, including an innovative two-stage impact evaluation of its flagship program Sustainable Conservation Approaches in Priority Landscapes (SCAPES). This work bolsters the evidence base for USAID’s emerging Biodiversity Policy, which emphasizes the role of biodiversity conservation in development outcomes. Challenges include making evidence from biodiversity sector meaningful to other sectors and the complexity of institutional learning in a complex, decentralized information-overloaded agency.



Ryan, Maureen, University of Washington & Simon Fraser University; Alan Hamlet, University of Notre Dame; Wendy Palen, Simon Fraser University; Se-Yeun Lee, University of Washington, Climate Impacts Group; Meghan Halabisky, University of Washington; Michael Adams, US Geological Survey; Joshua Lawler, University of Washington; Lara Hansen,

EcoAdapt
Amphibians squeezed between introduced fish and climate change in montane wetlands

Amphibians in the mountains of western North America are squeezed between two synergistic threats: rapidly changing climate and introduced predatory fish. Exotic trout exclude amphibians from many deep, permanent ponds and lakes. Yet climate-induced hydrologic changes may eliminate shallow fishless habitats on which amphibian populations now rely. Fish removals from mountain lakes have been successful in restoring aquatic habitat for amphibians, and thus represent a viable option for restoring resilience to climate change. However, the intensity of synergistic effects, and hence the effectiveness of fish removals for preventing declines, will vary among landscapes and species based on the amount and quality of fishless habitat and the proportion of habitats that are likely to become unsuitable in future climates. We present results from a study in Mount Rainier National Park. We developed projections of climate impacts to montane wetlands using the Variable Infiltration Capacity hydrologic model and new remote sensing approaches to classify existing wetland habitats. We show how these tools, in combination with amphibian life history and occupancy data, can be used to identify hot spots of synergistic effects of climate change and fish, where fish removal efforts can be targeted to restore resilience. These approaches can be applied to vulnerability assessment more broadly to support wetlands conservation and climate adaptation planning.



Ryder, Ollie, San Diego Zoo Institute
Preserving the last individuals of a species: Advances in methods to culture amphibian tissues for cryobanking

The IUCN Amphibian Conservation Action Plan calls for bioresource banking efforts for viable gametes and somatic cells of amphibian taxa, ideally as a distributed network of centers. Such a resource would facilitate research in systematics, disease risk factors and their management, as well as development and application of advanced reproductive technologies. With support from the U.S. Institute of Museum and Library Services, we have undertaken efforts to initiate, culture and freeze somatic cells from amphibians, with an emphasis on endangered taxa. Although amphibian tissues have historically proven more challenging to culture than other vertebrates, cell lines from six species have been successfully established and frozen, and methodological improvements in establishing amphibian cell cultures identified. Initial cell growth was achieved for >300 samples; 29 cell lines were successfully frozen, including the critically endangered Rana sevosa. These efforts more than tripled the prior number of reported amphibian cell lines. It is especially critical to establish and cryopreserve cell lines from amphibian species that might not be available in the future. The cell cultures can be expanded to generate large quantities of DNA/RNA, and could potentially be used for future somatic cell nuclear transfer or generating induced pluripotent embryonic stem cells. For species at the brink of extinction, access to banked viable cells may afford options for genetic rescue of critically small populations.



Saba, Vincent, NOAA NMFS NEFSC, Princeton, NJ
Projected response of an endangered marine turtle population to climate change

Assessing the potential impacts of climate change on individual species and populations is essential for the stewardship of ecosystems and biodiversity. Critically endangered leatherback turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) in the eastern Pacific Ocean are excellent candidates for such an assessment because their sensitivity to contemporary climate variability has been substantially studied. If incidental fisheries mortality is eliminated, this population still faces the challenge of recovery in a rapidly changing climate. Here we combined an Earth system model, climate model projections assessed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and a population dynamics model to estimate a 7% per decade decline in the Costa Rica nesting population over the twenty-first century. Whereas changes in ocean conditions had a small effect on the population, the ~2.5 ◦ C warming of the nesting beach was the primary driver of the decline through reduced hatching success and hatchling emergence rate. Hatchling sex ratio did not substantially change. Adjusting nesting phenology or changing nesting sites may not entirely prevent the decline, but could offset the decline rate. However, if future observations show a long-term decline in hatching success and emergence rate, anthropogenic climate mitigation of nests (for example, shading, irrigation) may be able to preserve the nesting population.



Saif, Samia, Durrell Institute of Conservation & Ecology, University of Kent; Christina Barlow, WildTeam; Douglas MacMillan, Durrell Institute of Conservation & Ecology, University of Kent
Local consumption of tiger parts in the Bangladesh Sundarbans
Sundarbans is the largest mangrove forest in the world and the Bangladesh Sundarbans comprises an area of about 6017 sqkm. The tiger population of 300-500 individuals which inhabits it is one of the largest remaining populations of wild tigers on earth. About 4 million people live in villages adjacent to the Sundarbans and depend on the forest directly or indirectly for their livelihoods. Over the time many medicinal, traditional and economic values of tiger parts have emerged among these people. This study was conducted in Bangladesh Sundarbans to investigate the existing values in the area. Semi-structured interviews were carried out to gain an in depth understanding of the innately clandestine topic. The study found that tiger parts have medicinal, traditional and economic values for the local people. These values are not same as those in traditional Chinese medicine which is thought to be the main demand for the tiger parts. Most of the local values of tiger parts were unique in terms of the ways they are used and purposes they are used for. A total of 139 people were interviewed across the 4 ranges and 43 were found to use tiger parts, 46 owned tiger parts at their home and 79 believed in the traditional and medicinal values of it. Tiger parts used by the villagers were tooth, bone, meat, tongue, genital organs, claw, whisker, stool and even the pugmark. It is important to understand the local demand of tiger parts as it might be an unexplored reason of tiger poaching.

Salafsky, Nick, Foundations of Success; Matt Deniston, Sitka Technology Group; Brian Knowles, Sitka Technology Group; Dan Salzer, The Nature Conservancy
Scaling-Up Adaptive Management from Individual Projects to Aggregate Programs

Conservation practitioners have a long history of using adaptive management principles and tools, such as those contained in the Open Standards for the Practice of Conservation, to design, manage, monitor, and learn from specific site-based and thematic projects. There is now growing interest in scaling these principles and tools to apply to "parent programs" composed of multiple "sibling projects" - for example, a network of sites managed by an organization, or a portfolio of grants funded by an agency or foundation. In this talk, we share recent experiences in program-level adaptive management, drawing on examples of developing a donor's funding strategy for the Galapagos Archipelago, performance measures for US State and Federal Fish and Wildlife Agencies, and a new cloud-based information system to manage and share conservation actions and projects. As with most scaling efforts, taking adaptive management from projects to programs is not a simple linear transformation. Key lessons include the need to 1) adjust planning, monitoring, and analysis units to a larger scale, 2) invest in developing standard lexicons, templates and information technology tools that ensure that projects are designed and monitored in a comparable fashion, and 3) ensure that adaptive management takes place in the context of regular program business practices. If done appropriately, program level adaptive management can improve cross-project learning and ultimately, the practice of conservation.



Sanderson, Eric, Wildlife Conservation Society
The Human Footprint: A Retrospective

The human footprint map helps us see, understand, and plan for human influence on Earth. The human footprint map shows the physical mark of humanity on Earth. The human footprint is created by compiling global datasets on population, land use, transportation networks, and power infrastructure at approximately 1 km2 resolution to show the global gradient of human influence on the land’s surface at a particular point in time. Such a map allows one to map cities, suburbs, rural areas, and wilderness; it represents a spatially explicit measure of threat; and it helps conservationists better frame the tradeoffs between economic development and nature conservation. In the decade since it was published, the map dataset has been used in over 360 different peer-reviewed studies to test propositions regarding protected area effectiveness, susceptibility to biological invasion, species range changes and diversity, ecosystem services, environmental sustainability, and conservation planning. It has encouraged researchers to pursue higher resolution versions for the western US, the Northern Appalachian mountain range in the US and Canada, Guatemala, and Israel, and a global effort for the world’s oceans. The most important use of the human footprint, however, has been for communication, showing people outside of conservation biology how and why the distribution, magnitude, and extent of humanity’s mark on Earth is critical to what it means to be human in the twenty-first century眠牯摬࠮慆牢



Sandin,, Stuart, Scripps Institute of Oceanography; Les Kauffman, Boston University
Can the Coral Health Index (CHI) support Pacific Ocean reef conservation and management?

Sandström, Annica, Stockholm Resilience Centre
Treating networks seriously' in conservation management: How a network approach enhances our understanding of collective action and adaptive capacity

The challenges of conservation management originate in ecological as well as social complexities. Social factors like institutional uncertainties, multi-actor settings, competing goals, and conflicts of interest often impede the evolution of legitimate and adaptive management systems. The argument proposed here is that these challenges should be approached through social networks. Based on social science theories and by means of empirical illustrations from fishery and carnivore management, three arguments for a social network approach are suggested. The first emphasizes the descriptive value of a network perspective; it contributes greatly to the process of defining the boundaries of the social system and to the generation of important information regarding the actors and their interactions. The second argument stresses the theoretical contribution of a network approach and rests on findings from previous research on the interplay between different network characteristics and management outcome. The main message is that the structure of a network affects the way it functions. The third argument is based on a managerial perspective and discusses implications for institutional design. The issue of how to design new, or influence existing, management systems to improve their capacity to deal with social challenges is elaborated. To conclude, research on conservation management has much to gain by ‘treating networks seriously.’



Sawaya, Michael, Sinopah Wildlife Research Associates; Steven Kalinowski, Montana State University; Anthony Clevenger, Western Transportation Institute
Genetic Connectivity at Wildlife Crossing Structures in Banff National Park.

Roads fragment and isolate wildlife populations which will eventually decrease genetic diversity within populations. Wildlife crossing structures may counteract these impacts by maintaining or restoring gene flow, but most crossings are relatively new, and there is little evidence that they facilitate gene flow. We conducted a three-year research project in Banff National Park, Alberta, to evaluate genetic connectivity at wildlife crossings. Our main objective was to determine how the Trans-Canada Highway and the crossing structures along it affect gene flow and population structure in grizzly (Ursus arctos) and black bears (Ursus americanus). We compared genetic data generated from wildlife crossings with data collected from greater populations using noninvasive genetic sampling. We detected a genetic discontinuity across the highway in grizzly bears but not in black bears. Grizzly bears detected at crossings assigned to populations north and south of the highway, providing evidence of bidirectional gene flow and genetic admixture at wildlife crossings. Genetic parentage tests showed that 47% of black bears and 27% of grizzly bears that used crossings were successful breeders. Differentiating between dispersal and gene flow is difficult, but we documented gene flow at wildlife crossings by showing a migration event followed by successful reproduction and genetic admixture. We conclude wildlife crossing structures allow sufficient gene flow to prevent genetic isolation.



Saxena, Anuj, Government of Rajathan
Biotechnology and Biodiversity conservation: Attaining synergy through policy making.

India is one of the 12 mega diversity "hotspot" regions of the world with an inventory of over 47,000 species of plant and 89,000 species of animals. Biotechnology has already assisted in the conservation of plant and animal genetic resources and offers vast potential for improving the productivity of agriculture, forestry and fisheries. In recent past, emerging biotechnologies have simultaneously added to the inequities by displacing traditional agricultural products, introducing new environmental and health hazards along with serious hardship for rural communities. Therefore the technology use for the benefit of farmers and conservation of traditional knowledge and biodiversity needs a revaluation in the context of Biotechnology. A scope for synergy can be achieved through policy document, a comprehensive note of the same must include some key elements like- Building and strengthening Knowledge ecosystem by setting up centres of excellence with development of gene bank to capture unique biodiversity of the region, catalyse industrial development through growth centre, Promoting investment and above all ensuring regulatory and compliance mechanism through task force to address the issues of bio-safety, bio-ethics and intellectual property rights in the field of biotechnology. Policy document thus enables and facilitates a need based support for the convergence of the interests of the industry, government and other stakeholders.



Saxon, Earl, Forest Inform Partners


Download 3.46 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   ...   66




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page