Foundation Briefs Advanced Level Sept/Oct 2013 Brief



Download 0.95 Mb.
View original pdf
Page50/186
Date16.12.2020
Size0.95 Mb.
#54643
1   ...   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   ...   186
174826514-Foundation-Briefs-compulsory-voting
elected or reelected. Inequalities in turnout are troubling, then, because they suggest a vicious circle in which the most marginal members of society are further marginalized. (1)


Sept/Oct 2013

Aff: Turnout Inequality Harms Democracy

foundationbriefs.com

Page 32 of 104
Mandatory voting is rooted in the concept of universal suffrage, DAT 9/10 am
Malkopoulou, Anthoula. Lost Voters Participation in EU Elections and the Case for
Compulsory Voting Center for European Policy Studies (July 2009).
Compulsory voting was introduced for the first time on a national scale in Belgium in 1893. A rather technical reason at that time was to protect poor voters from forced abstention, i.e. negative vote-buying, by their employers. Although this is not an issue inmost European countries today, it may still be a useful mechanism to prevent electoral corruption and abstention-buying in countries that feature large economic divides and labour dependence.
The main rationale behind the system in Belgium was to complement and enforce universal suffrage,
which was introduced in the same constitutional reform of 1893. Compulsory voting was away to fulfil
the principle of political integration, in other words it was a method to politically unite a socially
disparate people. In this sense, if the principle of universality is a central aspect of voting rights, its progressive realisation requires respect from the state and protection from third-party interference. As with all human rights, the third and most advanced step is fulfilling such rights, in other words providing guarantees that they will be exercised. So, full political integration is perhaps the strongest argument for compulsory voting. Indeed, the most
important implication of universal participation is political equality. In his milestone article in 1997,
Arend Lijphart argued that low turnout is biased against citizens with a lower education, income and
social class. According to him, citizens with lower education or modest social status, as well as those
belonging to ethnic, linguistic or religious minorities, are more prone to abstention than others.
Conversely, voluntary voting perpetuates political inequalities and misrepresentation. Paradoxically, the claim of abstainers that the European Parliament is an elitist establishment is reinforced by abstention itself. (1)
Law of Dispersion AMS
Armin Shafer. Republican Liberty and Compulsory Voting Max Planck Institute for
the Study of Societies November 2011.
The main reason fora concern with falling turnout is that lower participation rates mean more unequal

Download 0.95 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   ...   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   ...   186




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page