Pesticide Evaluation Report and Safe Use Action Plan (persuap)


Table1: Allowed and Rejected Pesticide AIs, by country or registration system



Download 5.7 Mb.
Page4/18
Date19.12.2017
Size5.7 Mb.
#35919
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   18

Table1: Allowed and Rejected Pesticide AIs, by country or registration system





Allowed Fumigant AIs (with strict conditions) all countries

  • aluminum phosphide for stored grains (for use only by trained and certified applicators, not farmers; see Fumigation PEA)

  • magnesium phosphide for stored grains (for use only by trained and certified applicators, not farmers; see Fumigation PEA)







Allowed Miticide AIs registered by INSAH-Harmonized Registration





Rejected Miticide AIs registered by INSAH-Harmonized Registration and considered but Rejected for “Use” by USAID Projects


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • amitraz




  • tetradifon (not EPA registered)




Allowed Insecticide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration




Rejected Insecticide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration, and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF & WASP Projects


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • azadirachtin/neem seed extract

  • Bacillus sphaericus

  • Bacillus thuringiensis/BT

  • bifenthrin (use only 10% EC and 2.5% ULV formulations)

  • deltamethrin (use care around water)

  • diflubenzuron (use formulations less than 25%)

  • emamectin benzoate (registered for use for household cockroach bait)

  • fenothrin/phenothrin (use care around water)

  • flubendiamide

  • fludioxonil/fludioxonyl

  • imidacloprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • indoxacarb, S isomer

  • lambda-cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)

  • lufenuron

  • malathion

  • Metarhizium flavoviride anisoplae

  • novaluron

  • permethrin

  • pirimiphos-methyl

  • spinetoram

  • spinosad

  • spirotetramat

  • Tagetes oil

  • tetramethrin

  • thiamethoxam (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • thyme oil

  • zeta-cypermethrin (use only non-RUP products)



Allowed Insecticide AIs registered by Benin


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • beta cyfluthrin (use formulations 10% and below)

  • beta cypermethrin (use all but 2.5EC formulations)

  • bifenthrin (use only 10% EC and 2.5% ULV formulations)

  • cyfluthrin (use only acute toxicity Class III products; not Class II)

  • deltamethrin (use care around water)

  • flubendiamide

  • imidacloprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • indoxacarb, S isomer

  • lambda cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)

  • malathion

  • novaluron

  • pirimiphos-methyl

  • spinetoram

  • spinosad

  • spirotetramat


Allowed Insecticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • acephate

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • Bacillus thuringiensis/BT

  • bifenthrin (use only 10% EC and 2.5% ULV formulations)

  • chlorantraniliprole/rynaxypyr

  • deltamethrin (use care around water)

  • ethofenprox

  • imidacloprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • lambda cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)

  • malathion

  • permethrin

  • pyrimiphos methyl

  • propoxur

  • spinosad

  • thiamethoxam (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)



Allowed Insecticide AIs registered by Ghana


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • acephate

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • Bacillus sphaericus

  • Bacillus thuringiensis/BT

  • bifenthrin (use only 10% EC and 2.5% ULV formulations)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not for agricultural use; for uses except spraying for household pests, favor the use of granular formulations for soil pests)

  • dimethoate

  • imidacloprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • lambda cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)

  • malathion

  • Metarhizium anisopliae

  • novaluron

  • oxamyl (use only non-RUP Class II granular formulations)

  • permethrin

  • pyrimiphos methyl

  • pyrethrum

  • sulfur/sulphur

  • tetramethrin

  • thiamethoxam (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)


Allowed Insecticide AIs registered by Togo


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • beta cypermethrin (use all but 2.5EC formulations)

  • coconut oil

  • chlorpyrifos methyl

  • cyfluthrin (use only acute toxicity Class III products; not Class II)

  • deltamethrin (use care around water)

  • dimethoate

  • fenpropathrin (use only non-RUP products)

  • flubendiamide

  • imidacloprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • indoxacarb, S isomer

  • lambda cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)

  • malathion

  • soybean oil

  • spinosad

  • spirotetramat


Allowed Miticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • abamectin/avermectin (use only formulations below 1.9%)

  • acetamiprid (but only when plants are in vegetative state, not when flowering due to risk to pollinators and honeybee colony collapse disorder)

  • acequinocyl

  • dimethoate

  • lambda cyhalothrin (use only formulations 10% and below)



Allowed Molluscicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • metaldehyde


Allowed Nematicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire

  • oxamyl (use only non-RUP Class II granular formulations)

Allowed Rodenticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • chlorophacinone

  • difethialone

  • zinc phosphide (only in concentrations of 2% and lower, which are EPA acute toxicity Class III)



Allowed Rodenticide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration


  • brodifacoum (products sold as bait traps only, not just bait)


Allowed Fungicide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration


  • azoxystrobin

  • copper sulfate (pentahydrate) (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • iprodione

  • mancozeb

  • metalaxyl-M (mefenoxam)

  • myclobutanil

  • thiram/TMTD



Allowed Fungicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • mancozeb

  • thiram/TMTD



Allowed Fungicide AIs registered by Ghana


  • azoxystrobin

  • captan (likely carcinogen at higher doses, so use PPE)

  • copper-fixed or tribasic copper sulfate (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • copper (cupric) oxide (CuO) (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • copper (cupric) hydroxide (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • cuprous oxide (Cu2O) (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • difenoconazole

  • folpet (likely carcinogen at higher doses, so use PPE)

  • fosetyl aluminum

  • mancozeb

  • metalaxyl

  • propiconazole

  • sulfur (sulphur, hydrogen sulfide)

  • thiophanate methyl

  • triadimenol (on pre-treated seed for maize only; not for sorghum seed)

  • Trichoderma asperellum



Allowed Fungicide AIs registered by Togo


  • copper oxychloride (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • fosetyl aluminum

  • sulfur (sulphur, hydrogen sulfide)

  • thiophanate methyl



Allowed Herbicide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration


  • 2,4-D

  • 2,4-D amine

  • acetochlor (use non-RUP formulations)

  • bensulfuron

  • bensulfuron methyl

  • clethodim

  • clomazone

  • diuron (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • fluazifop-P-butyl

  • fluometuron

  • glyphosate

  • hexazinone (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • isoxaflutole (likely carcinogen, use PPE)

  • mesotrione

  • metolachlor (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • nicosulfuron

  • orthosulfamuron

  • oxadiazon

  • pendimethalin

  • penoxysulam/penoxsulam

  • prometryn

  • propanil

  • terbuthylazine

  • thiobencarbe/benthiocarb

  • triclopyr

  • trifloxysulfuron sodium



Allowed Herbicide AIs registered by Ghana


  • 2 4 D amine (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • 2 4 D amine salt (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • bensulfuron methyl

  • bentazon

  • bispyribac-sodium

  • bromacil (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • diuron (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • fluazifop-P-butyl

  • gibberellic acid

  • glyphosate

  • imazapyr/imazapir

  • mesotrione

  • metolachlor (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • nicosulfuron

  • oxyfluorfen

  • pendimethalin

  • propanil

  • terbuthylazine

  • triclopyr



Allowed Herbicide AIs registered by Benin


  • 2 4 D (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • 2 4 D dimethylamine salt (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • clethodim

  • flumetralin

  • fluometuron

  • glyphosate

  • isoxaflutole (likely carcinogen, use PPE)

  • metolachlor (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • nicosulfuron

  • pendimethalin

  • prometryn/prometrine

  • propanil

  • pyraflufen-ethyl (likely carcinogen, use PPE)

  • triclopyr



Allowed Herbicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • 2 4 D amine salt (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • 2 4 D dimethylamine salt (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • 2 4 D isooctyl ester (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • acetochlor (use non-RUP formulations)

  • ametryne/amethrin

  • amicarbazone

  • bentazon/bendioxide

  • bispyribac-sodium

  • clomazone

  • diuron (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • fluometuron

  • fluroxypyr

  • glyphosate

  • isoxaflutole (likely carcinogen, use PPE)

  • mesotrione

  • metolachlor (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • metsulfuron-methyl

  • nicosulfuron

  • oxadiazon

  • pendimethalin

  • penoxysulam



  • propanil

  • saflufenacil

  • terbuthylazine

  • thiobencarbe/benthiocarb

  • triclopyr



Allowed Herbicide AIs registered by Togo


  • 2 4 D dimethylamine salt (use only acute toxicity Class II or III products; not Class I)

  • ametryne/amethrin

  • diuron (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • fluometuron

  • glyphosate

  • isoxaflutole (likely carcinogen, use PPE)

  • mesotrione

  • metolachlor (known water pollutant, use care around open water)

  • nicosulfuron

  • prometryn

  • propanil

  • terbuthylazine

  • triclopyr

  • trifloxysulfuron sodium




  • allethrin (not EPA registered)

  • alpha-cypermethrin (RUP)

  • bendiocarb/benthiocarb (not EPA registered)

  • cartap hydrochloride (not EPA registered)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not registered for agricultural spraying)

  • cyantraniliprole (not EPA registered)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • fenitrothion (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • profenofos (RUP)

  • teflubenzuron (not EPA registered)


Rejected Insecticide AIs registered by Benin and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects

  • alpha-cypermethrin (RUP)

  • carbosulfan (not EPA registered)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not registered for agricultural spraying)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • emamectin benzoate (EPA RUP for all horticultural products)

  • fenitrothion (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • profenofos (RUP)

  • triazophos (not EPA registered)



Rejected Insecticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • allethrin/bio-allethrin (not EPA registered)

  • alpha-cypermethrin (RUP)

  • carbofuran (EPA has revoked tolerances; cancellation in progress)

  • carbosulfan (not EPA registered)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not EPA registered for agricultural spraying)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • fenitrothion (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • fipronil (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • iodofenphos (not EPA registered)

  • triazophos (not EPA registered)


Rejected Insecticide AIs registered by Ghana and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • allethrin/bio-allethrin (not EPA registered)

  • alpha-cypermethrin (RUP)

  • cadusafos (not EPA registered)

  • carbofuran (EPA has revoked tolerances; cancellation in progress)

  • carbosulfan (not EPA registered)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not EPA registered for agricultural spraying)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • diazinon (not registered for agricultural spraying)

  • emamectin benzoate (EPA RUP for all horticultural products)

  • fenitrothion (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • fenvalerate (not EPA registered)

  • fipronil (not registered by EPA for agricultural use)

  • profenofos (RUP)

  • temephos (no EPA registered crop uses; cancellation in progress)

  • thiocyclam hydrogen oxalate (not EPA registered)


Rejected Insecticide AIs registered by Togo and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • alpha-cypermethrin (RUP)

  • chlorpyrifos-ethyl (not EPA registered for agricultural spraying)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • endosulfan (POPs list)

  • methyl parathion (RUP, Class I)

  • profenofos (RUP)

  • triazophos (not EPA registered)


Rejected Miticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • acrinathrin (not EPA registered)

  • carbofuran (EPA has revoked tolerances; cancellation in progress)

  • cypermethrin (registered USA for medical, veterinary and household use, not agriculture)

  • triazophos (not EPA registered)


Rejected Molluscicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire


  • thiodicarb (More hazardous than metaldehyde)


Rejected Nematicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • carbofuran (EPA has revoked tolerances; cancellation in progress)

  • ethoprophos (RUP)


Rejected Rodenticide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects
None
Rejected Rodenticide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects
None

Rejected Fungicide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • pencycuron (not EPA registered)


Rejected Fungicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • pencycuron (not EPA registered)


Rejected Fungicide AIs registered by Ghana and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • carbendazim (EPA registered uses are not for food crops)

  • dichlofluanid (not EPA registered)

  • fenpropimorph (not EPA registered)

  • maneb (registrations cancelled by EPA)


Rejected Fungicide AIs registered by Togo and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • pencycuron (not EPA registered)



Rejected Herbicide AIs INSAH-Harmonized Registration and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • aclonifen (not EPA registered)

  • cycloxydim (not EPA registered)

  • haloxyfop-R-methyl (not EPA registered)

  • S-metolachlor (only “metolachlor” is registered by EPA)

  • oxadiargyl (not EPA registered)

  • pretilachlor (not EPA registered)

  • propaquizafop (not EPA registered)

  • pyribenzoxime (not EPA registered)

  • terbutryne (not EPA registered)


Rejected Herbicide AIs registered by Ghana and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • 2 4 D isobutylate (not EPA registered)

  • butachlor (not EPA registered)

  • cycloxydim (not EPA registered)

  • ethephon (Class I, too toxic)

  • haloxyfop (not EPA registered)

  • paraquat (dichloride) (RUP)

  • propaquizafop (not EPA registered)


Rejected Herbicide AIs registered by Benin and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • aclonifen (not EPA registered)

  • haloxyfop-R-methyl (not EPA registered)

  • haloxyfop R methyl ester (not EPA registered)

  • oxadiargyl (not EPA registered)

  • prosuler (psoralen) (not EPA registered)

  • terbutryne (not EPA registered)



Rejected Herbicide AIs registered by Côte d’Ivoire and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • aclonifen (not EPA registered)

  • alachlor (all products RUP)

  • atrazine (known water pollutant)

  • cyanazine (not EPA registered)

  • cyclosulfuramon (not EPA registered)

  • haloxyfop-R-methyl (not EPA registered)

  • S-metolachlor (only “metolachlor” is registered by EPA)

  • piperofos (not EPA registered) pretilachlor (not EPA registered)

  • propisochlor (not EPA registered)

  • pyrazosulfuron-ethyl (not EPA registered)

  • pyribenzoxime (not EPA registered)

  • terbutryne (not EPA registered)


Rejected Herbicide AIs registered by Togo and considered but Rejected for “Use” by CORAF/WECARD FTF and WASP Projects


  • aclonifen (not EPA registered)

  • alachlor (all products RUP)

  • atrazine (known water pollutant)

  • S-metolachlor (only “metolachlor” is registered by EPA)

  • oxadiargyl (not EPA registered)

  • pretilachlor (not EPA registered)

  • pyribenzoxime (not EPA registered)





Results of Pesticide Evaluation Report (PER) 12-Factor Analyses
Factor A (EPA &West Africa CORAF/WECARD Registration and RUP Status) &

Factor E (Acute/Chronic Toxicological Hazards)
The primary outcomes of Factor A & E analyses are the allowed AIs listed above in the left-hand column. A key point from this analysis is that several dangerous chemicals that should be banned or restricted are still encountered in the West Africa region and CORAF/WECARD countries. These include the pesticide AIs:


  • organochlorine insecticide endosulfan (banned internationally on the Persistent Organic Pollutants, or POPs treaty list in 2011);

  • organophosphate insecticides containing methyl-parathion in Togo, as well as cadusafos, profenofos and triazophos (all Class I, highly toxic and higher risk for small farmer use) in Togo and other countries;

  • herbicides containing known water pollutants alachlor and atrazine, as well as highly-toxic and problematic paraquat (which has chronic human health issues).

Pesticides containing these AIs are generally found in small retail agro-dealer shops, and small-scale farmers should be discouraged by USAID projects. Several safer alternatives to these older types of chemicals now exist.


Factor B (Pesticide Selection Basis): Farmers Select Pesticides by Agro-dealer Advice and Cost
Most West African farmers use relatively high quantities of pesticides, especially in the cotton sector. Those that do use pesticides often do so based upon the advice of agrodealers or neighbors. And, they will often select the lowest cost pesticides, which is not ideal as many of the low-cost generic products, particularly from China and India, are also of low quality and not reliable.
Just the fact that a few farmers will already value or buy and use pesticides—even the cheapest low quality pesticides—does provide a market entry point for name-brand products once their benefit for cost value is realized. This PERSUAP makes pesticide selections based upon registration, safety and resistance management. And, it encourages USAID projects to promote name brand pesticides where applicable.
Factor C (IPM): Limited use of IPM &

Factor I (Chemical and Non-Chemical Alternatives Available): Little use of Chemical and Non-Chemical Alternatives
Other than some use of resistant varieties, most small-scale farmers use few preventive non-chemical IPM tools and tactics on food security cereal row crops covered by CORAF/WECARD, and even root crops, vegetables and fruits. Exceptions in the region include small-scale production of high-value crops cotton, groundnuts, sugarcane, soybeans, and some export fruit crops. Estate farms growing high-value crops like cacao, coffee, and sugar have incentives to produce clean produce for export. They have access to high levels of resources, education, information and training, and they actively use preventive IPM tools and tactics to the maximum in order to reduce costs and pesticide residues.
This PERSUAP provides the beginnings of Pest Management Plans (PMPs) in Annex 5. This annex contains numerous non-chemical preventive measures and curative chemical pesticide choices for crop-pest pairs likely to be encountered in West Africa CORAF/WECARD programs/projects FTF and WASP on crops supported by USAID. CORAF/WECARD training on these elements will help further socialize and raise awareness of the importance and benefits of using an IPM approach to agricultural production, including pesticide rotation.

Factor D (Pesticide Application & Safety Equipment):


  • Knapsack Sprayers Leak onto Users. Hand-pump backpack sprayers, used by small- and medium-scale farmers, among others, can and do eventually develop leaks at every junction where sprayer parts meet (filler cap, pump handle entry, exit hose attachment, lance attachment to the hose and at the lance handle) and these leaks soak into exposed skin. Moreover, clothing serves as a wick that holds these pesticides in constant contact with the skin. Unless the clothes are washed immediately after use, other family members may also come in contact with pesticide residues.

CORAF/WECARD, where applicable, could promote the development and use of professional spraying and record-keeping services. These can be designed to be accessible by farmers at congregation places (farms stores, cooperatives/associations, produce consolidation and processing sites). Such services will be encouraged to properly maintain spray equipment and use recommended PPE. In the absence of such spray services, promote and teach proper sprayer maintenance and repair, and post-spraying hygiene during training.




  • Farmers and some Fumigators do not use Personal Protection Equipment. Very few small-scale producers have access to, or can afford Personal Protection Equipment (PPE) when applying pesticides. Larger-scale certified estate farms have, and make their farm laborers use, PPE. Many small village and even some city agrodealers in West Africa do not stock sufficient or appropriate PPE.

Provision of PPE and repeated training on pesticide risks and the use of appropriate (for the pesticide) PPE are recommended for reducing risks to users.


CORAF/WECARD is recommended to encourage farmers to purchase pesticides only from reliable companies and in the original bottles with labels containing essential safety information.


  • Females, Immune Compromised Pesticide Applicators and Children. Although pesticide use on food security crops in West Africa is relatively low, there are risks, especially in households that are headed by women. Some female farmers and immune compromised individuals will use pesticides on their crops. Pesticides add additional stresses to the health of individuals who are pregnant, lactating or immune-compromised. Furthermore, farmers often store pesticides in the home. This practice increases the risks that children will get access and accidentally ingest them.

CORAF/WECARD is recommended to discourage pregnant and lactating female farmers, as well as immune compromised (HIV, TB, malaria, etc.) individuals, from using pesticides. All pesticide applicators, including women, need to use recommended PPE. Project staff should train farmers on the risks to children, and the need to secure pesticides from them.




  • No Proper Disposal of Empty Pesticide Bottles. Empty pesticide bottles are thrown in the field, burned, buried or reused. There is a system being developed internationally for collecting empty bottles for rinsing, disposal or recycling. Ideally, empty bottles would be collected, cleaned properly by triple rinsing and recycled into plastic objects like fence posts. In the absence of such a collection and recycling system, the next best approach is to wash, puncture and bury empty bottles. Burning them creates toxic and carcinogenic fumes.


Factor E (Acute/Chronic Toxicological Hazards) All Pesticide AIs Present Risks &

Factor G (Target and Non-Target Hazards) Pesticides Kill More Than Target Pests
In addition to acute and chronic human health hazards and water pollution risks of the proposed chemicals, almost all pesticide AIs present some degree of additional chronic risks to people including potential carcinogenic, endocrine, developmental and reproductive risks. And, almost all pesticide AIs present risks to some other organisms, including fish, honeybees, birds, amphibians, earthworms, mollusks, crustaceans, aquatic insects and plankton. Moreover, “natural, botanical or biological” pesticide AIs extracted from plants and microbes carry these risks as well.
For pesticides that possess chronic health risks for humans, pesticide users need to be encouraged to use appropriate PPE. For pesticides highly or very highly toxic to honeybees, all spraying should be done late in the day when the winds have calmed and bees are at the hive. For pesticides highly or very highly toxic to aquatic organisms, application should not be done within 30 meters of open water.
Factor F (Pesticide Effectiveness): Variable Product Quality, Development of Pesticide Resistance
This PERSUAP does not, and cannot, make pesticide brand or content quality determinations or distinctions; the bodies that can and should do this are West Africa Ministries of Agriculture (MOA), when they test, accept, register, sample and control pesticide products entering West Africa CORAF/WECARD countries. In general, multinational companies like Arysta, Bayer, BASF, Dow, DuPont, FMC, Monsanto and Syngenta, as well as other companies from developed market countries that produce generics have reputations to protect. Thus their products are more likely to be of a consistently high quality. This is often reflected in higher pricing, or value, as well. Some generic pesticides from companies in Asia may or may not be as reliable.
Pesticide resistance can become a problem when the same chemicals are used over and over to control a particular pest. After a period of time, the pest may develop resistance to a chemical so that the chemical no longer effectively controls the pest at the same rate. Higher and higher rates or dosages and more frequent applications become necessary until eventually the chemical ceases to provide adequate control. Farmers who use cheap unreliable generic pesticides can exacerbate the development of resistance.
CORAF/WECARD can encourage beneficiaries to use reliable name brand products and rotate pesticides from one class or type of chemical to another to reduce the development of pesticide resistance.
Factor H (Climate, Flora, Fauna, Geography, Hydrology, and Soils Pesticide Use Conditions): The Lack of Use of GAPs Can Lead to Damage of Natural Resources
USAID Foreign Assistance Act (parts 118/119) emphasis and studies on the Conservation of Tropical Forests and Biodiversity in West Africa provide ample information on the natural resources at risk from multiple threats. Principal among them is agriculture, and especially the use of inputs like synthetic fertilizers and pesticides.
Deforestation, soil erosion and loss of soil fertility, as well as loss of biodiversity, is due to both small-scale producers and large-scale plantations. The vast majority of pesticide pollution comes from large-scale commercial and estate farms. Clearly, USAID-funded projects have a major challenge to promote Good Agriculture Practice (GAPs) and preventive IPM tactics and tools in order to improve agricultural production among small to medium scale farmers, so that natural resources are less threatened.
Factor J (Host Country Pesticide Management Abilities): A Lack of Resources Can Lead to Increased Risks
Most emerging market countries, West Africa CORAF/WECARD countries included, do not have sufficient resources to do all that is needed to better manage pesticides and use. As noted above, some very toxic and banned pesticides are still found in West Africa, and the extension service cannot reach most farmers. The lack of resources lead to increased risks.
Fortunately, projects from or funded by developed market countries (like the USA) help fill this resource gap, often serving as de facto extension services. What this means is that donor projects also have a responsibility to know about, understand and promote the best practices, IPM and recommendations available. For USAID projects, this PERSUAP, and the information in it, is meant to assist with this challenge.
Factor K (Training): Limited IPM and Pesticide Safety Training of Implementers and Beneficiaries
Most West Africa farmers have had limited national and donor assistance with farmer IPM and pesticide safety training. As a follow-up to this PERSUAP, such training should be performed by USAID projects for select leader beneficiaries on all projects doing agriculture value chain and food security projects. CORAF/WECARD is expected to use the GAP/IPM information in Annex 5 as well as hot-linked pesticide safety websites referred to in this PERSUAP to train beneficiaries.
Factor L (Monitoring): Small Scale Farmers do not Monitor or Keep Farm Records
West Africa small-scale farmers do not keep records of information on crops grown, production, pest attack, pesticides used, if the pesticides worked well or not, and respect post-harvest intervals to reduce pesticide residues. Certified large-scale commercial and estate farms, on the other hand, all keep detailed records. As small and medium scale farmers move further toward producing certified (Organic, FairTrade, GlobalGAP, British Retail Consortium—BRC) export crops, they will need to be taught how to do proper record keeping. USAID projects like CORAF/WECARD can teach this during training to begin to prepare ambitious farmers looking to get ahead.
USAID projects like CORAF/WECARD will keep records of crops supported, primary production constraints, as well as IPM, pesticides and PPE used on supported farms.
How to Use this PERSUAP Efficiently
The best way to use this document is to focus on the parts that apply to the crops produced, the pests of each and the preventive and curative tools and tactics, including pesticides. To do this efficiently, search this document for the crops or pests (common or scientific name) using the Word computer program’s “Find” feature, which allows one to enter the word or phrase desired, and then takes one to the exact parts of the report where the word or phrase is used. Specific pesticide active ingredients in Annexes 5 and 7 can be found using the same method.
Update the Report Annually and Amend the Report in Two Years
New pesticides and EPA registrations change weekly. In addition, new human health and environmental data is produced continuously. For these reasons and others, this PERSUAP should be updated, and amended after a time in order to remain current and accurate.



Download 5.7 Mb.

Share with your friends:
1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   18




The database is protected by copyright ©ininet.org 2024
send message

    Main page