Thief in the Night or The Strange Case of the Missing Millennium

by William Sears

[Some minor grammatical corrections have been made to the text, newer translations of quotations or those from prime sources have been substituted, prime references have been used where available, some errors were corrected and a few explanatory Footnotes added.

A formatted and corrected copy of the Index prepared by Merle Cates has been added.—M.W.T, August 2001]

George Ronald

Oxford, England

First edition 1961
“But the day of the Lord will come as a thief in the night; in which the heavens shall pass away with a great noise, and the elements shall melt with fervent heat, the earth also and the works that are therein shall be burnt up.”

II Peter 3:10

This is a mystery story with a difference: the mystery is a real one, and of vital importance to every human being. The author presents the evidence in The case of the missing millennium in such a way that you can solve it for yourself.

1. Once to Every Man and Nation 1–5

2. The Strange Case of the Missing Millennium 5–8

3. The First Promise 8–11

4. The Second Promise 11–16

5. The Third Promise 16–21

6. Other Promises 21–25

7. And Others Still 25–29

8. Lift Up Your Heads 29–31

9. The Mystery of the White Stone 31–35

10. The Rich Who are Poor 35

11. The Light that Blinds 38

12. For None Can Read 43

13. A Mysterious Springtime 47

14. The Living and the Dead 52

15. The Mouthpiece of God 58

16. One Shepherd but Many Folds 62

17. The Unmistakable Signs 66

18. Lightning from the East 72

19. The Vision of the Last Days 74

20. The Avalanche 79

Part Two—The Solution

1. The Mystery Begins to Unravel 84

2. The Remarkable Parallel 87

3. The Twin Fires of Heaven 90

4. The Witnesses 94

5. The Hidden is Revealed 98

6. The Glory of God 102

Part Three—The Proof

1. The King from the Sunrise 107

2. Ancient Land of Mystery 110

3. Begotten in Babylon 114

4. The Amazing Micah 117

5. The Eight Astonishing Steps 123

6. No Need of the Sun 127

7. The Families of the Earth Shall Be Blessed 132

8. The Lord of the New Era 137

9. The Door of Hope 144

10. Where the Poor are the Kings of Paradise 152

11. The Blossoming Desert 159

12. Fire in the Sky! 165

13. He Shall Glorify Christ 172

1. The Signs in the Heavens 178

2. The Shaking Earth 181

3. The Blast of the Trumpet 183

4. When Stars Fell Like Snowflakes 186

5. The Face of Heaven 189

6. The Night Visitor 194

Part Five—The Final Evidence

1. Beware of False Prophets 200

2. Enemy of the People 205

3. The Tree of Life 208

4. The First Fruit: Home and Family 210

5. The Second Fruit: Country 213

6. The Third Fruit: Religion 216

7. The Fourth Fruit: Individual Life 221

8. A Searching Eye 227

9. The Bird with Two Wings 229

10. The Real Treasury 231

11. No Man is a Stranger 233

12. Partners in Progress 235

13. The Beauty of the Rainbow 237

14. The Worlds Beyond 241

15. Food for the Soul 245

1. Except These Days be Shortened 251

2. Nuclear Giants and Ethical Midgets 256

3. The Chariots Shall Rage in the Streets 260

4. Terror in the Sky 265

5. The Hour Hath Come 271

6. The Day of the Lord 275

7. The Dawn of a New Day 279

Index 284-305

Arrive London airport tonight

Science proves soul immortal

Continent of Atlantis rises in

sea off Portugal

I looked across the television news desk at the editor.

‘Anything else?’

He pointed.

Medical discovery ends all disease

Hitler found alive in Vienna

I nodded. ‘It’s the end of the world, all right.’

He handed me the magazine in which these headlines were printed.

‘Take it along and read it.’

I went back to my desk in the Sports Department, opened the magazine and began to study it carefully. It was a shot in the arm. Only this morning I had felt like a detective who was trying to solve a crime one hundred years after the deed had been committed. Until this moment, the trail had been very cold. At least this article encouraged me to go on with my search. Apparently, thousands of people were still as keenly interested in solving the mystery as I was, even after more than a century.

I took a folder out of my filing cabinet and with a soft black pencil wrote on it: The strange case of the missing millennium.

The magazine article consisted of sample headlines from newspapers all over the country. Editors had been asked to submit to the magazine some imaginary headlines, headlines which, the editor felt, would be capable of arousing the greatest possible excitement.

They had chosen some dandies:

Scholars prove Shakespeare really Marlowe

No more winter ever

Holy Grail found in Wales

Conan Doyle contacts earth

Santa Claus no myth

I chuckled. The morning that all these headlines were printed would certainly be a day to run for the hills.

There was one particular effort that instantly gripped my attention. According to these hard-boiled newspapermen, this headline, if authentic, would be the most electrifying of all. This one, they said, would really rock the world back on its heels. It consisted of only two words:

Christ returns

I had been working on just such a news story for two years. I had accidentally come upon what I had considered to be an amusing and puzzling mystery, and had already spent two years trying to solve it. It all began harmlessly enough when someone handed me a book written by a namesake of mine, Clara Endicott Sears. No relative. At least so they told me around Searsport and Vanceborro in Maine. If I had known what lay ahead, I might have burned the book right then and there.

I was working a night-wire for the United Press at the time, so I had a few hours in which to sit and think. In Clara’s book I found an entertaining and fascinating story about the people who had eagerly awaited the return of Christ during the nineteenth century.

My big surprise came when I learned that magazines and newspapers in that day had actually printed stories about this spectacular event. Some were told in jest, some in ridicule and some with deadly seriousness. In the press and on the streets, you could savour every emotion:

Christ—coming or not?

End of the world tomorrow

Jesus at the door

Terrifying comet alarms earth

The Advent: truth or hoax?

Everyone enjoys a good suspense story, especially the kind of thrill implied in the threatening words: ‘The end of the world!’ The prophets of doom had run the gamut, from the literalist who said, ‘The world will come to an end on Thursday, 23 November at seven p.m. beginning in the Ohio valley and spreading north through Michigan’, to the earnest student of Scripture who warned that ‘in the day the stars shall fall from heaven and the earth be removed from her place.’

There is no greater suspense story than this. It is filled with terror and magic, and it had been told with fantastic fervour in the 1840s.

Excited reports spread through the United States, Britain, Canada, Europe, Asia, even to Africa and Australia. People throughout those regions were strongly warned to prepare for the sudden appearance of Christ, the results of whose ‘coming’

promised to be either delightful or disastrous, depending on the teller.

The vast majority of people went on their way with tolerant, amused smiles. They pitied the victims of such fanaticism. Many, however, found it a time fraught with fear and panic. In pamphlets, on the platform, in the pulpits, and in the press, Bible scholars called upon a non-listening, uninterested world to repent.

‘Now is the hour!’ they threatened.

Many believed them. Whole families sold their homes and possessions. Others cashed in their bank accounts and gave away their worldly goods to the unbelieving. Some prepared special ascension robes. Tradition states that some went up into the hills on a fatal, chosen day to await the descent of Christ upon a cloud, only to be greeted by a downpour of rain.

I examined actual legal records in which some of the zealous deeded their property over to the coming Christ. An entire village was prepared for His coming. It was called Heaven (Paradise), and was established as His American residence.

A passionate madness seized people in widely separated sections of the Christian world at that time. Why? Why did they all expect Christ? Why at that particular time?

It was a puzzling, first-class mystery story. It was as though a ‘millennial’ virus had suddenly infected people in five continents. As I read about the colourful, amusing, and sometimes shocking things that happened in these widely scattered parts of the world, I became curious, and that curiosity was the beginning of this volume.

I can’t honestly say whether it was in the Library, the Museum, or by the Cave of Elijah on Mount Carmel that I suddenly found myself engrossed in a fascinating full-time

study. The growth of interest had been gradual, but eventually I was determined to find out whether the return of Christ was a myth, a mistake, or the greatest unsolved mystery of our age.

One day in the reference room of one of the endless libraries I haunted during this period, I experienced a sudden, unique thrill, the sort the archaeologist must feel when his pick strikes a wall and he sees it crumble before his eyes, revealing an ancient, exciting new world, at the very moment he was about to abandon his search.

I discovered I was not on a wild-goose chase! Among those dusty library shelves I found a fellow-detective, and in his company the excitement of the chase began all over again. Professor E. G. Browne of Pembroke College, Cambridge, had broken the ground before me. He, too, apparently had been fascinated by the same story and had already unravelled a part of it. He wrote likening it to the story of Christ:

‘I feel it my duty, as well as pleasure … to bring the matter to the notice of my countrymen …’¹

Later I traced Browne’s searching steps in the Holy Land; I read the letter in his own handwriting in which he made plans to come to Israel to meet this great Figure. He admitted that he would not rest until he had settled the matter in his own mind.²

I found that a contemporary of Browne’s, the renowned Benjamin Jowett of Balliol College, Oxford, has echoed this feeling. He, too, had chanced upon the story that now lay open before me. He wrote:

“It is too great and too near for this generation to comprehend. The future alone can reveal its import.”³

Both Professors Browne and Benjamin Jowett associated their dis-

covery with the return of Christ. They both expressed keen interest in the relevance and import of the story. Now, after several years of careful research and study, I, too, had arrived at this same conclusion. I decided to take up the story where they had left it and to follow it to its end.

The following chapters are the record of my seven years of search; they offer my solution to this intriguing century-old mystery. They suggest that our modern newspapermen are one hundred years too late in wishing that they were able to print the dramatic headline:

Christ returns

In fact, our press has been scooped by over a century. You will find here considerable evidence to show that when the newspapers and publications of the 1840s printed their stories headed, Return of Christ expected, they were printing not fancy, but fact, even though they were unaware of the nature of the story at the time, and were totally unable to substantiate its truth in that hour.

If what I have uncovered is the truth, then (according to the testimony of the hard-boiled newspaper editors of the West) it is the most shocking and dramatic story that anyone could possibly tell in print.

But will anyone believe me?

You are now starting where I started a few years ago on The strange case of the missing millennium.

William Sears.