7.5 Public consultation on farm irrigation compensation/alternative scheme
7.5.1 Method of public consultation
The occupied land scope of Shangrao Sanqingshan airport is involving the irrigation facilities and source of drinking water of surrounding residents, therefore, the airport shall decide the detailed irrigation compensation/alternative scheme and ask for the public opinions. Due to the alternative schemes has not been confirmed yet, according to the current conceptual compensation/alternative scheme, the airport and local water department ask for opinion from the public. The project office of the airport organized the public consultation with the residents influenced by the irrigation ponds occupation. The public meeting mainly includies the design unit which introduces the basic information, environmental impact and planning solutions of the irrigation scheme and the aiport project →discussion and question by participants → the construction unit and design unit of water conservancy solve the problems demonstratively →site survey and recheck →adjust and optimize the scheme.
7.5.2 The first time of public consultation
On August 29th 2012, the project office organizes the design institute of water conservancy planning, villagers' representatives from Zaotouzhen, Zunqiaoxiang, Tashui villages of Maojialing, total of 16 people, to take part in the public meeting on the preliminary scheme on irrigation compensation on the 2nd floor of the construction office of Shangrao Sanqingshan airport. The villager’s representatives discuss the preliminary schemes on irrigation compensation and put forward detailed opinions and suggestions (see Figure 7-5-1 in detail). After the meeting, the project office and design institute of water conservancy, conduct site survey immediately, adjust and optimize the scheme.
Figure 7-5-1 Result of public consultation of airport irrigation schemes (the first time)
Time
|
Place
|
Content
|
Participant
|
Opinion or suggestion
|
Reply
|
August 29th 2012
|
Conference meeting on the 2nd floor of the construction office of Shangrao Sanqingshan airport
|
Discussion meeting on the preliminary scheme on water draining of Shangrao Sanqingshan airport
|
Ding jinhua, Tong xiaojun, He zijun, Zhouhuajun, Jiangyan from the airport office; Lijianchu, Ligong, Zhujinzhen from water conservancy and planning institute of Shangrao; Shaoqingsong, Chenguangliang, Chenyangshui from Zaotou village, Zhengzengquan,Libianzhen ,Dongjinshuai from Zunqiaoxiang, Xugongmao, Huangbo from Tashui village of Maojialing, totally 16 people.
|
1. Zunqiaoxiang:
(1) The airport construction need expropriate three ponds which lead to water shortage of 300 mu farmland of the downstream. The recommended solution is to draw water from other ponds or establish new ponds.
(2) It suggests changing part of the internal drainage path and reducing the irrigation pressure of Longzhan Pond (No.3 outlet slightly eastward about 300m, where can consider to discharge Longzai )
(3) No. 2 outlet eastward 150 m, where can increase a outlet for shunt
(4) Whether the flow of No.1 outlet is large, it suggests to broadening and reinforcement the drainage channel of the downstream of Huangwu reservoir
2. Zaotou town
(1) For the relevant five requisition ponds of airport construction, the recommended solution is to heighten and strengthen the existing pools to enlarge its capacity or establish new ponds.
(2) There is no special water channel in the downstream of 38 reservoirs, and the floodway is not enough to guarantee the complete drainage, hence, No.5 outlet can be changed through Xiaojiashan reservoir, and strengthen Shishantang
(3)Check the flow from the No.4 outlet to 38 reservoirs is large or not, and heighten and strengthen the drainage channel of the downstream
(4) No.5 outlet flows into xiaojiashan ponds, it suggests to one divide into two and increase one outlet to flow into Shigu ponds.
3. Tashui village of Maojialing
(1) Suggest adding an outlet in Lianhua ponds
(2) Suggest canceling the box culvert 2 and establishing a new pond on the north side.
(3) It puts forwards to block the dozens of farmland of Tashui Xujia on the south side of the airport after the airport construction from south to north. The cultivation is far away and very inconvenient, hence it shall requisition and replacement.
|
The airport office and water conservancy and planning unit shall take the opinions from various villages and towns, combine drainage with irrigation, settle the newly added or original outlet, survey on site, compare the discussion result of this conference, and adjust and optimize the design scheme.
|
7.5.3 The second time of public consultation
On September 26th 2012, the project office organizes the design institute of water conservancy planning, villagers' representatives from Zunqiaoxiang, totally 22 people, to participate in the public meeting on irrigation compensation alternatives which covers the Songsanlong pond and Xukulong pond in Zunqiao village committee of Zunqiaoxiang. The villager’s representatives discuss and compare the three schemes to solve the problem of farmland irrigation compensation because there are two ponds are to be occupied due to the airport construction (see Figure 7-5-2 in detail). Since there are technical and procedural problems in each scheme, design unit and EA unit work together making improvement according to various suggestion.
Figure 7-5-2 Result of public consultation of irrigation compensationschemes (the second time)
Time
|
Place
|
Content
|
Participant
|
Opinion or suggestion
|
Reply
|
September 26th 2012
|
Zunqiao vallige committee of Zunqiaoxiang, Shangrao
|
Discussion meeting on water alternatives in Songsanlong pond and Xukulong pond of the drainage scheme of Shangrao Sanqingshan airport
|
Tong Xioajun, Lin Ming, Jiang yan from the airport office, Li Jianchun from water conservancy and planning institute of Shangrao, the deputy township head of Zunqiaoxiang, Wang Bingbing, the village officer of Zunqiao village, Fang Zhaohua, the head of water conservancy protection station of Zunqiao village, Zheng Zengquan, villages’ representatives of Zunqiao village (15 people): Xu Maosong, Huang Liangkun, Huang Fushan, Xu Maokun, Xu Zhengwu, Xu Maoqing, Cheng Zuhua, Fang Shenbing, Fang Shenlin, Fang Shenguo, Wu Xiaomao, Fang Zhaoshi, Xu Wubei, Xu Deyuan, and Ren Bingxing, totally 22 people.
|
1. The villager Huang Liangkun: I think the best way is to establish a reservoir for irrigation near the airport, if repair the original irrigation system, which department shall manage this problem.
2. The head of water conservancy protection station of Zunqiao village, Mr. Zheng said: according to the conditions and experience I have learned, if repair and reconstruct the original water channel, it will be feasible to construct in accordance with standards of three-surface light and it also can ensure the irrigation of paddy field. For the first method, it can establish a reservoir for irrigation near the airport, which is feasible in my opinion. I think that only the two method can be used, and I would like to listen to the opinions from your.
3. The villager Xu Maoqing: If recovery to use the north branch canal, the water source will not in our village. We can not manage the water source of other villages, during the irrigation peak, like the busy season, the water may be stopped in the upstream and we can not guarantee the water in our village.
4. The villager Xu Zhengwu: the water level of 38 reservior is lower than the paddy field in our village at first, if we want to guarantee the water for paddy field in our village, we will have no water to use in the future.
5. The village officer, Fang Zhaohua: It is beneficial for the villagers to establish a pond with 10 to 15 mu.
6. Compare the two scheme of reconstructing north main canal and establish a new pond, the villagers, as Huang Laingkun as a representative are more likely to build a new pond with 10 to 15 mu.
| -
There are many problems like technology and procedure relevant to build a new pond near the airport.
-
Reconstruct the original water channel shall take the water quantity of water source into consideration, the cost will increase when transport water on the local hilly country.
-
It shall think about the optimized design from the opinions of villagers.
|
Share with your friends: |
