AXIS 1 COMPETITIVENESS
|
Measure
|
Suggestion
|
Response
|
Young Farmers Installation Scheme
|
2006 transfers should be eligible for the new rate
|
Not possible under terms of regulation
|
Minimum size of farm should be 10ha in disadvantaged areas and 15ha in non-disadvantaged areas
|
The minimum sizes of farms provided for in the programme are more appropriate in the context of the competitiveness aim
|
Minimum length of lease should be 5 years and not 10
|
The 10-year lease requirement provided for in the programme is more appropriate. This will however be the subject of a review after 5 years
|
FETAC level 6 Advanced Certificate in Agriculture should be the new minimum educational requirement
|
FETAC level 6 or equivalent provided for in the measure
|
Early Retirement from Farming
|
Index linking of pension
|
Not possible. Previously rejected by EU Commission for legal reasons
|
Basic payment rate of 75 per cent of total payment on 1st 5ha and a payment rate of €198 per ha for 1st 24ha
|
This issue is partially addressed in the re-structuring of the pension payments now in measure
|
Maximum age of transferee should be 50 years
|
Acceptable in certain circumstances and now in measure
|
Retired farmers should be given the farmer rate of forestry premium
|
This proposal is precluded by EU regulation
|
Retirees to be allowed work a certain number of hours a week on son/daughter’s farm
|
This proposal is precluded by EU regulation, which states that Transferors must cease all agricultural activity
|
Small farmers should be encouraged to participate. Therefore pension calculation needs to be examined
|
Restructured pension calculations now in measure
|
In case of intensive farmers calculations should be based on a standard amount and not hectares
|
The revised pension calculation will be of increased benefit to intensive farmers
|
Minimum size of farm should be 10ha in disadvantaged areas and 15ha in non-disadvantaged areas
|
The minimum sizes of farms provided for in the programme are more appropriate in the context of the competitiveness aim
|
Age of transferee must be less than 40 years rather than 45 years
|
See reply above regarding age of transferee
|
Transferors should be between 55 and 66 and not 56 years
|
This proposal has been accepted
|
On-Farm Investment
|
Maximum grant rates allowable should be used
|
The rates and other conditions reflect the investments needed, the available funding and the likely uptake. Progress will be kept under review
|
Investment ceilings need to be increased in line with increases in standard costs and these need to be increased
|
There should be greater flexibility on spending within the schemes
|
Separate investments limit of €120,000 for farm waste Management and dairy hygiene should apply.
|
A separate investment limit of €120,000 for dairy hygiene is now provided
|
A scheme to support wood chip boilers should be considered
|
Already provided by Sustainable Energy Ireland through the Greener Homes Scheme
|
Provisions should be made for partnerships
|
Where appropriate special conditions are applied in individual schemes to cover farm partnerships
|
AXIS 2 ENVIRONMENT |
Measure
|
Suggestion
|
Response
|
Less Favoured Areas Compensatory Allowances Scheme
|
Minimum stocking density should be abolished
|
While both suggestions have alternative merits, it has been decided to continue with a minimum level of 0.15lu/ha. Matter can be re-examined in light of planned review of disadvantaged areas
|
Minimum stocking level should be 0.3lu/ha
|
Review of areas outside of disadvantaged areas with a view to including marginal land
|
Not issue for programme. Review of disadvantaged areas’ classification already planned
|
Natura 2000 payments and payments linked to Directive 2000/60/0EC
|
NHA, SPA and SAC land should all attract the same payment level
|
Designated NHA, SPA and SAC all attract the same level of payment. The justification for paying the same rate for proposed/candidate NHA will need to be examined
|
Payment rate of €243 should apply on 1st 20ha of no designated land
|
The payment rate for the 1st 20ha of non-designated land has been set at €234/ha, and represents the 17 per cent increase agreed in recent partnership talks
|
Rural Environment Protection Scheme – REPS Agri-environment payments
|
A review of operating costs and income foregone should occur in 2008 and payments rates increased where necessary
|
The mid-term review can examine all aspects of REPS payments
|
Payment rates need to be frontloaded to encourage greater uptake by small-scale farmers
|
The proposed rates reflect the agreement reached in recent partnership talks
|
Concerns over Nitrates Regulations compliance
|
There are no additional compliance requirements in the Nitrates Action Programme for REPS farmers over and above non-REPS farmers
|
Requirement for 5-year lease prior to application should be amended
|
Farmer must give a commitment for 5 years and, therefore, the lease must cover the full period of the REPS contract
|
5 per cent inspection rate
|
Not a matter for the programme; can be dealt with in the scheme’s terms and conditions
|
No need for a minimum stocking density
|
A minimum stocking level is required to provide an environmental return and to ensure against land abandonment. It will also ensure that the person getting the benefit is farming. Ownership of land does not entitle a person to REPS payments
|
Should be a grazing period of 6 months, not 3
|
The length of the grazing agreement can be decided later in drawing up the REPS specification. On the basis of grazing aftergrass the period of 6 months could not be justified
|
Farmers utilising a nitrate derogation of 250kg/ha should be able to participate
|
All farmers will be eligible for REPS 4
Farmers operating over 170kg/ha will be required to apply annually for a derogation and will require a nutrient management plan under the nitrates directive. The nutrient levels in the management plan approved for the purposes of the derogation will be acceptable for REPS also.
|
Increase payment rates for supplementary measures in line with increased costs
|
Rates reviewed and adjusted
|
Farmers should be allowed accumulate aid by taking on more than 2 supplementary measures
|
Not acceptable on grounds of extra cost. The funding provided for the programming period only assumes a maximum of two supplementary measures in the cumulation of aid
|
A traditional grazing supplementary measure is required
|
Such a measure is included
|
Various suggestions in relation to supplementary measures
|
Details will be examined in drawing up the specification for REPS
|
If restriction of payments to 55ha is to continue the farmer should be allowed exclude any areas exceeding 55ha
|
Payments are not restricted to 55ha. All land in REPS qualifies for a payment
|
First afforestation of non-agricultural land grant should be limited to private individuals, with premiums limited to farmers
|
Regulation does not limit measure to private individuals. Limited premiums are payable in respect of abandoned farmland
|
FEPS should be targeted towards new afforestation on REPS farms
|
FEPS establishment is targeted towards new afforestation on REPS farms and is designed to encourage the establishment of high nature value forests
|
Funding should be provided for forest roads
|
A Forest Infrastructure Scheme is included as provided for under Article 30 of Council Regulation 1698/2005
|
AXIS 3 RURAL ECONOMY/ QUALITY OF LIFE
|
Measure
|
Suggestion
|
Response
|
Diversification into Non-Agriculture
|
Support should be available to promote production of artisan foods, food tourism and farm shops
|
All of these initiatives are eligible for support
|
Development of Micro-Enterprise
|
Government should introduce a programme for Rural Enterprise Development and establish a Rural Enterprise Agency. Mentoring should be supported
|
The business plans of Local Action Groups must be submitted to, and support, the development strategy of the local County Development Board. Sectoral agreements must also be agreed with the County Enterprise Boards to maximise the impact of public funding on local micro-enterprise development.
|
Rural Tourism
|
A dedicated measure should be introduced to support development of countryside recreation, including resourcing landowners
|
The Rural Tourism measure specifies the need for complementarity with the Countryside Recreation Strategy
|
Village Enhancement
|
Develop a Farmers Market Network
|
Support is available for the further development of Farmers’ Markets
|
Basic Services for the Rural Economy
|
Increase availability of broadband
|
Provision of ICT infrastructure is not within the scope of this measure
|
Provision of adequate funding and resources to provide sufficient level of services such as child care, care of the elderly, rural transport system, water treatment.
|
The provision of mainstream social service is in the remit of several Government Departments. This measure will cater for provision of specific local cultural and recreational infrastructure, in agreement with local authorities
|
Upgrading of Rural Heritage
|
Specific support should be given to the protection of local beaches and coastal areas from erosion
|
There is provision for support for the protection and upgrading of local amenity landscape
|
Conservation of biodiversity, particularly in relation to fruits and plants should be encouraged
|
A number of initiatives implemented by the Department of Agriculture and Food currently address the conservation of plant and animal genetic resources
|
Support should be available for small-scale renewable energy projects by Community groups and other local actors
|
This will be the case where appropriate projects are submitted to the Local Action Group
|
Training and Skills
|
A Community Training Programme similar to a former FÁS programme should be introduced
|
Provision of mainstream training is within the remit of FÁS
|
An existing Small Holder Initiative to assist low-income farm holders should be supported under this measure
|
Relevant actions to develop the economic capacity of this and other target groups can be undertaken by Local Action Groups as relevant to the local area
|