Introduction
What you
will learn
By the end of this section, you should:
-
be able to describe methods of conducting STI surveillance
-
be able to describe how STI surveillance data can be used in understanding HIV epidemics
-
have an understanding of aetiologic and syndromic reporting
-
understand basic, intermediate and advanced STI surveillance.
STI and HIV
inter-relationship
There is a complex inter-relationship between STIs and sexually transmitted HIV:
Behavioural factors – Both STIs and HIV can be sexually transmitted by vaginal, anal and oral intercourse. The risk of HIV transmission is generally greatest for anal intercourse and least for oral intercourse.
Epidemiological factors – Populations with high rates of STIs have high rates of sexually transmitted HIV.
Host factors – The presence of STIs causes local immunologic changes in the mucous membranes of the genital track, and, in the case of genital ulcers, cause tears in the protective layer of skin. These changes make it easier to acquire and transmit HIV.
How STI surveillance data are used
STI surveillance data can be used for a variety of purposes related to the monitoring, prevention, control and allocation of resources for STIs and HIV. For example, the data can be used to:
-
assess the overall burden of STIs
-
monitor trends in recently acquired STIs
-
provide information necessary for physicians to treat STI patients and their sex partners
-
provide information to assist in planning and managing STI and HIV prevention and control programme efforts
-
provide data for the purposes of advocacy and resource mobilisation and for programme planning, targeting, monitoring and evaluation
-
serve as a marker of HIV risk behaviours
-
monitor the number of people infected with HIV who develop an STI, which is a marker of risky behaviours.
STI Surveillance and HIV Epidemic State
The role that STI surveillance can play in HIV surveillance differs depending on the state of the HIV epidemic. It is important to recognise that the type of HIV epidemic in a given area may change over time.
WHO describes three different types of HIV epidemics. Table 6.1 details the different states of HIV epidemics and the benefits of STI surveillance for each.
Table 6.1. State of HIV epidemic and benefit of STI surveillance.
-
HIV epidemic state
|
Benefits of STI surveillance
|
Low-level epidemic:
HIV prevalence has not consistently exceeded 5% in any group.
| -
an early warning system for HIV infection and emergence of HIV in new groups or new geographical areas
-
an evaluation tool for HIV prevention programmes
|
Concentrated epidemic:
HIV prevalence consistently exceeds 5% in one or more groups with high-risk behaviour. HIV prevalence is less than 1% in pregnant women.
| -
a marker for the emergence of HIV in new groups
-
a marker of how successful prevention programmes have been in high-risk populations
|
Generalised epidemic:
HIV prevalence is consistently greater than 1% in pregnant women.
| -
a marker of how successful prevention programmes have been in the general population
|
Discussing
the table
Look at Table 6.1 and answer the following questions:
-
For which epidemic state(s) can STI surveillance be used to determine the effectiveness of HIV prevention programmes?
-
If HIV prevalence in Cariba is 6% in one population sub-group and 0.5% in pregnant women, what epidemic state is Cariba experiencing?
STI Aetiologies versus STI Syndromes
Reporting of sexually transmitted infections can be based on the aetiology or presenting syndrome. These are described and compared below, with a discussion of their advantages and disadvantages.
Aetiologic
reporting
In aetiological case reporting, the specific STI (for example, gonorrhoea) is reported. Aetiologic reporting requires laboratory confirmation of diagnoses and is, therefore, only possible where well-developed systems of laboratory diagnosis are incorporated into routine STI clinical case management. In some countries of the Caribbean, the use of laboratory services for diagnosis is frequently not available for routine care.
Syndromic
reporting
Syndromic case reporting relies on examining a patient and identifying a syndrome (that is, a group of symptoms that are characteristic of a specific condition, reported by a patient and detected in an examination). The limitations of syndromic case reporting are:
-
The syndromes are not specific to a particular pathogen. Laboratory studies are required to determine which organisms are causing the symptoms.
-
Only urethral discharge in men and non-vesicular genital ulcers in men and women are likely to reflect recent infection. They are, therefore, important for detecting trends in STI incidence.
-
Syndromic reports are a poor tool for assessing disease burden among women. Clinical infection is not always readily apparent in women compared to men, so syndromic case reporting may underestimate disease burden in women.
-
When possible, STI prevalence assessment and monitoring should be undertaken as a supplement to case reporting.
Table 6.2 shows the relationship between STI syndromes and aetiologies.
Table 6.2. The relationship between syndromes and aetiologies.
-
STI syndrome
|
Possible aetiology
|
Urethral discharge
| -
caused by Neisseria gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia trachomatis
-
other possible infectious agents include Trichomonas vaginalis, Ureaplasma urealyticum and Mycoplasma spp.
|
Genital ulcer (non-vesicular)
| -
caused by syphilis, chancroid, lymphogranuloma venereum, granuloma inguinale or atypical types of genital herpes
-
reporting only non-vesicular genital ulcers excludes most herpes infections, which are most often the result of prior infection
|
Source: UNAIDS/WHO Working Group on Global HIV/AIDS/STI Surveillance. Guidelines for Sexually Transmitted Infections Surveillance. Geneva: World Health Organization, Communicable Disease Surveillance and Response, 1999. Available at www.who.int/hiv/pub/me/en/GuidelinesforSTISurveillance1999_English.pdf
Discussing
the table
Look at Table 6.2., above, and answer the following questions:
-
Which STI syndrome can be caused by N. gonorrhoeae and C. trachomatis?
-
What are some of the limitations of reporting vaginal discharge?
Share with your friends: |