Acknowledgements 5
Executive Summary 6
Methodology 9
The Context of Risk and Vulnerability to Food Insecurity 11
Economic Risk and Vulnerability 11
A Debt Disaster: Debt Burdens, Low Availability and Costs of Credit 14
Table II. Classifications of Debt Security 17
Chart I. Changes in Debt Security 17
Monetary Instability: Winners, Losers and Continued Uncertainty 18
Table III: Afghani - US Dollar Exchange Rate Fluctuations, 1996 – 2001 18
Weak Purchasing Power: Unemployment and Loss of Income 20
Production Failure: Drought, Distress Sale of Assets and (For Some) Poppy 21
Map I. Water Insecure Households Afghanistan 2001 - 2002 22
Transportation and Markets: Potholes, Landmines and Isolation 24
Socio-Political Risk and Vulnerability 25
War, Old and New 25
Politicized Ethnicity 27
Division of Labor 28
It was very difficult for my children and me. I was thinking that I might not be able to feed my children, and I agreed to give my 9-year-old girl into marriage. My husband agreed to marry off my daughter. My ten-year-old son was working for someone who had a car. We sent our kids to collect fuel wood. There are many children from our villages who go far away to other villages to work as shepherds. 29
Woman 29
Shahrak District, Ghor 29
Location: The address is (almost) everything 30
Hazards: Afghanistan’s Four (Plus) Horsemen of the Apocalypse 31
Drought: Relief for the North & West; Crises in the South and East 31
Map II. Drought Affected Countries in the Region 31
Table IV. Classifications of Household Water Security 33
Chart II. Changes in Water Security 33
Figure I. Food Security and Access to Water 35
Multiple Hazards: When It Rains, It Pours -- and Other Disasters 36
Relief Inadequacies: The Aspirations-Reality Gap 39
Food Aid: Relieving Food Insecurity or Merely a Light Dusting of Wheat Flour? 40
Chart III. Percentage of Households Receiving Food Aid, 1999 – 2002 41
Table V. Classifications of Household Diet Security 43
Map II. Diet Insecurity in Afghanistan 2001 - 2002 44
Relief Operations Management: Challenges of Logistics, Management, Security Transportation, Communication, Information and Coordination 44
Coping with Food Insecurity 46
Recommendations 52
Recommendation One: Commit to a multi-year strategy of assistance of expanded relief and development assistance 52
Recommendation Two: Commit to a Strategy of Principled Humanitarian Engagement to Alleviate Food Insecurity in Afghanistan 53
Principle One: Appropriate Assistance 53
Principle Two: Impartial Assistance 56
Principle Three: Accountable Assistance 58
Annex I. WFP Vulnerability Assessment Map 59
Annex II. Select Bibliography 60
We are grateful to the many organizations and individuals who assisted us with our work. In particular, we acknowledge the support of USAID Administrator Andrew Natsios; US Ambassador Ryan Crocker; the US-, Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based USAID staff, especially Jim Kunder, Bernd “Bear” McConnell, Tish Butler, Elizabeth Kvitashvili, Mike Marx, James Fleming and other OFDA colleagues, Eric Picard, Amy Paro, Jessica Powers, Malek Zimmer and the rest of the CATF; the US-, Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based staff of Save the Children US, especially Lisa, Noorulah, Jalil, Saddiq, Millie, Teresa, Babar, Abdal Ahad, Lucienne, Yoshi, Iqbal, John, and Fitsum; the Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based staff of UNICEF, especially Eric Laroche, Angela Kearny, Peter Salama, Hannan Sulieman and Al Alami; the Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based staff of Mercy Corps International, especially Jim, Alex, Patrick, Zahar, Gav, Nigel, Ghulam and Lizzy; the Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based staff of the Coordination for Humanitarian Assistance (CHA), especially Dr. Waqfi, Salma Waqfi, Dr. Ayoobi and Engineer Ekhpolwak; the Mazar-i-Sharif-based staff of the World Food Program (WFP), especially Pascale, Scott and Zabi; and, the Pakistan- and Afghanistan-based staff of the Dutch Committee for Afghanistan (DCA), especially Dr. Fakhri and Dr. Fazli. Angela Raven-Roberts, Annalies Borrel and Ann O’Brien provided key support at the Feinstein International Famine Center, Tufts University. Wendy Johnecheck and Valerie Gantchell provided key assistance in data analysis, as did a number of research assistants (Diane, Sucheta, Kate, Nyaki, Martin, Francis and Humanyun). We are grateful to David Hastings and Dean Irwin Rosenburg of the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy, Tufts University for their support. The team also appreciates the assistance of Michael “HB” Phelan.