5.Linkage of OASIS SP3 services and use cases with the end-user profiles and INTERVIEWS results
This chapter provides a linkage between the OASIS users’ groups and interviews results with the Use Cases of SP3, as presented in Chapter 4 above. The defined UCs (38 in total) were linked to the specific end user profiles and interviews results. The aim is to provide extra insight in understanding which use cases are taking on board which user groups’ needs, as well as which use cases can be directly linked to the (simplified) user profiles, as were defined in ID5.5.6 “OASIS users’ and stakeholders’ groups”.
The exercise undertaken in this section is not an absolute one, rather it wants to give a guidance regarding the linkage between the OASIS use cases, and the activity patterns of the older people, for whom the OASIS services are being developed. It also wants to provide feedback on how the input received from the end-users in the context of the interviews are reflected in the selected Use Cases.
MA TA REQUIREMENTS ypotithetai VGHKAN PRIN TA UCS!
The various subcategories of OASIS users are mapped to their activities, their living conditions, etc. This will help in better understanding the diversity of the end-users, while allowing to better pinpoint what services (covered by specific UCs) they need, according to the interviews results of Chapter 3.
The outcome offers an indicator of services and use cases preference per specific user group. The identified user groups are most likely to use the identified services, albeit not absolute as a lot depends on the individual preferences.
The link of the UCs to the specific end user profiles and interviews results, proved that they fully abide to the users expectations. In fact, none of the UCs was considered unacceptable by the majority of the interviewees, whereas of course some were preferred more than others and some are relevant to many more user profiles.
The findings are presented in the tables below.
End-user categories
|
Relevant OASIS services
|
Relevant use cases
|
Living outside own house
|
With family
|
Supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-4, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-11, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
-
|
-
|
Not supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-10, SP3-11, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
-
|
-
|
Residential accommoda-tion
|
Not alone
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-4, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-16
|
Not active
|
Route guidance
|
SP3-16
|
Alone
|
Supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-4, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-14,SP3-15, SP3-16, SP3-17
|
Not active
|
Route guidance
|
SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
-
|
-
|
Sheltered accommodation
|
Not alone
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
-
|
-
|
Alone
|
Supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
|
|
Not supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not active
|
-
|
-
|
Living inside own house
|
Not alone
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
Personal mobility
Smart workplaces
|
SP3-11, SP3-12, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19, SP3-23, SP3-24, SP3-25, SP3-27, SP3-28, SP3-29, SP3-30, SP3-31, SP3-33, SP3-34, SP3-36, SP3-37, SP3-38
|
Not active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
Personal mobility
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5,SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-13, SP3-21, SP3-29, SP3-30
|
Alone
|
Supported
|
Route guidance
|
SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Not supported
|
Active
|
Transport information services
Route guidance
Personal mobility
Smart workplaces
|
SP3-1, SP3-2, SP3-3, SP3-5, SP3-6, SP3-7, SP3-8, SP3-9, SP3-10, SP3-11, SP3-12, SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19, SP3-21, SP3-22, SP3-23, SP3-24, SP3-25, SP3-26, SP3-27, SP3-28, SP3-29, SP3-30, SP3-31, SP3-32, SP3-33, SP3-34, SP3-36, SP3-37, SP3-38
|
Not active
|
Route guidance
|
SP3-13, SP3-16, SP3-17, SP3-19
|
Table 1: Linkage of end-user profiles with OASIS SP3 services and priority use cases per user group.
Following, for each main Use Case, the feedback as received during the interviews, is reflected.
Use case
|
Explanation of use case
|
Explanation of linkage to interview findings
|
Elderly friendly transport info services
|
Pre-trip info
|
Providing to the user info about a trip & destination (e.g. nearest hotels, parking, touristic places, medical centers, etc.), allowing him/her to plan it correctly.
| -
While the usage of public and private transport is overall different in intensity among the pilot countries, overall the concern is the same, namely that there is a general unpreparedness of elderly users, combined however with a need for assistance while actually undertaking the travelling. This specific use case on pre-trip info addresses these needs thoroughly, thus reducing considerably any anxiety feeling.
|
Short-range trip info
|
To give to the elderly user accurate information when planning a short trip
| -
Planning short and long trips is an event occurring in all pilot sites, however to a different degree. Nevertheless, support is desired during all steps of travelling when using private but especially when using public transport. This short- and long-range trip info is therefore also addressing the specific needs of elderly as identified during the interviews.
-
In addition, support is often used while travelling via public and private transport means. Therefore the trip info has to be provided throughout the journey. Here as well, the use cases long- and short range trip info provide the necessary support.
-
The information about sites of interest (Points of interest = POI) is requested often while travelling, using private transport means. These 2 use cases are to address this as well.
|
Long-range trip info
|
To provide accurate and efficient information on long trips
|
Info in stations & hubs
|
To give to the elderly user info on public transport timetables for a specific line or stop.
| -
Information about time tables of the public transport services have been indentified as the most requested information in all pilot sites ahead of preparing a trip. However, during the trip, it has been exactly this lack of information that caused a lot of problems for travellers, as well as unclear information about the various stops. The use case on info in stations and hubs is therefore addressing this “getting informed” concern of elderly travellers.
|
TMIC interface
|
To inform the user on the current traffic situation & notify while on-trip when a disruption happens along the planned route and then re-plan the trip
| -
Information about traffic conditions and the travel itinerary have been identified as main requested information issues. The TMIC interface use case is to address these concerns.
|
Multimodal trip planning
|
To plan a public transport trip efficiently & accurately
| -
The usage of combined modes of public transport was for most of the interviewed causing problems, especially in finding the corresponding timetables, and in being unable in creating the own travel itinerary. The multimodal trip planning is to address this need.
|
Elderly friendly route guidance
|
In-vehicle
|
To provide info on parking availability and in car (on-board & off-board) navigation, avoiding heavy traffic and specific (difficult) traffic scenarios to enhance safety and comfort
| -
Finding parking space was together with traffic jams and the occurrence of aggressive drivers a major difficulty in using private transport means. This could be solved by ensuring that elderly avoid specific roads with heavy traffic, and where consequently there are also a lot of aggressive drivers. This in-vehicle use case addresses exactly these needs of the elderly.
|
Pedestrian
|
To monitor the user and provide user’s location, support and guidance en route or at any instance
To provide info on how to reach a specific POI using a safe, calm or scenic route
To notify the user in case of deviation from the planned trip and provide possibility to re-plan the trip
| -
A large part of the interviewed older people are still going on foot to visit places, and are thus also confronted with a number of issues: lack of street name signs, unclear direction to destination, etc. This use case would address these concerns and offer a secure manner for pedestrians to walk in more confidence, finding their destination easily, and being able to always position themselves.
|
Personal mobility
|
On-demand services
|
To provide accurate and efficient demand responsive services
| -
Interviewees identified their need for guidance in organising their itinerary, specifically when using multiple modes. The on-demand services of this use case can address this need adequately, making it in fact a “point A to point B query”.
-
Because many of the interviewed older people use mobile phones, this mode of communication could easily support on-demand services.
|
Driver telematic support
|
To monitor the health status of driver/passenger, and to take necessary actions, if needed.
To start an emergency call automatically or manually whenever a car accident has occurred.
| -
Older drivers have a major concern with regards to anxiety in traffic (aggressive drivers, etc.), and many are somewhat reluctant to use the car due to their health condition. Some of the interviewed people are still able to drive, and would gain much more confidence if they would know that they are monitored. These 2 use cases address this specific need.
|
Driver comfort support
|
To automatically detect driver discomfort & stress and adapt driving environment and task.
To enhance driver safety & comfort
|
Tourism and leisure
|
To get info, according to user’s preferences, about POIs/events/trips in his/her home or another city.
Find the opinion of other users or insert his/her opinion regarding the evaluation of a POI/event/trip for his/her or another city/country.
To inform the user when a person of the list enters a physical activity space (café, cinema, etc.) and start communicating.
| -
Being informed about sites of interest in the place of destination, or during the trip has been identified as important by the interviewed in all countries.
-
Social contacts have been indentified as very important in all pilot sites, whether related to leisure or work. Therefore, also the combination of travelling and the community aspects has to be considered.
|
Smart workplaces
|
Smart workplaces applications
|
To facilitate the user to be connected with his/her company IT environment.
To provide synchronised work environment, hiding all complex technological aspects from the elderly user and provide a “plug and play” connectivity with the working environment.
| -
Quite a large minority of the interviewees was still working (mostly self-employed), but did identify problems related to ergonomic issues and the usage of different ICT technologies, thus requiring a simpler interfacing. The latter was also identified by their carers, thus will play an important role in the acceptance of any ICT driven innovations. These use cases could support this need through their plug and play connectivity support, as well as through the offered telematic tools and technologies. Important aspect is also that the desktop operating systems used by the interviewed older people were in most cases Windows based (NT, XP, Vista).
-
A majority of the interviewed used the internet mainly at home, or wanted to get connected.
-
Easier home working environments should also make it easier for people to continue working at home, and where needed be involved in training schemes with younger colleagues.
|
Telematic tools and technologies for flexi-work
|
To facilitate access to user’s data while freely moving from a device to another.
|
Table 2: Linkage of SP3 use cases to the interview findings.
Share with your friends: |